This is an HTML version of an attachment to the Freedom of Information request 'Oliver Wyman contracts'.

Oliver Wyman
Criterion
Score 
Comment on Score 
Score
 
Comment on Score 
Score Oliver 
Comment on Score Oliver Wyman
Comment on 
 
Wyman
Proposed approach, concept and methodology for the performance 
(+) 
 
(+
 
4
(+) Integrated PMO methodology with PMO 
(+)
of the Contract.
 
responsible for both content steering and project 
 
 
progress reporting. 
 
 
(+) 
(+) Good structured approach to PMO for a very 
large scale project with very good coverage of the 
(-) 
(-) 
 
 
issues at stake (very clear elaboration of key services 
(-) 
 
 
to be provided under Lot 1). 
 
(+) Good understanding of relevant issues the ECB 
 
(-) 
 
(-)
 
will deal with in the months to come (based on past 
 
 
 
projects, key risks to be managed by PMO team 
 
 
elaborated upon). 
(+) Good expertise and reach out to provide 
(-)
(-) 
 
(+) 
 
benchmarking information and best practices. 
 
(+) Good market intelligence in areas of the ECB's 
(-)
 
(+
 
interest for this project, plus potential handover of 
(-) 
 
reusable tools to the ECB for future exercises.             
(+) 
 
(+) Good elaboration of NCAs role in the PMO
                   
(-) Foreseen timing September-March too optimistic.
(+) 
 
(-) 
.
Appropriateness of the experience and qualifications of the 
(+) 
(+) 
 
3
(+) Different team size proposed for different project 
(+)
 
proposed project team members in view of the tasks assigned to 
 
 
phases
 
 
them.
 
 
(+) 
 
(+) PMO performed hand in hand with ECB team.
(-)
 
 
(+) 
 
(+) Relevant experience from partners and strong fit 
                   
 
as sparring partners with senior stakeholders within 
(-)
 
(+) 
 
the ECB; however not all CVs for all roles have been 
provided in the proposal. 
(-) No elaboration of ECB role in PMO, nor of the 
(+) 
role of Senior oversight team vs. Partner Execution 
Team vs. Principal vs. Central Support team vs. 
(+) 
 
Country teams.
 
(-)
 
 
(-)
 
(-) 
 
(-)
 
Compliance with contract
 
 
3