27 September 2021 at 11:18
VOTING LIST
EMPL first voting session, Monday 27 September 2021
Concerned
AM
Tabled by
Remarks
Rapp Vote
text
Employment and social policies of the euro area 2021 (Lina Gálvez Munoz)
Paragraph 1
CA 1 Rapporteur
If adopted, 59, 60, 61, 62
+
+
and 63 fall
41/9/3
Paragraph 1
59 Ždanoka
Falls if CA 1 adopted
+
↓
Paragraph 1
60 Szydło, Rafalska,
Falls if CA 1 adopted
-
↓
Zalewska
Paragraph 1
61 Vedrenne, Brunet,
Falls if CA 1 or 59 adopted
+
↓
Ďuriš
Nicholsonová,
Pîslaru, Cañas,
Rafaela, Trillet-
Lenoir, Bijoux,
Cicurel
Paragraph 1
62 Lexmann
Falls if CA 1 adopted
-
↓
Paragraph 1
63 de la Pisa Carrión
Falls if CA 1 or 60 adopted
-
↓
Paragraph 1 a
64 Vedrenne, Brunet,
+
+
(new)
Ďuriš
39/2/10
Nicholsonová,
Pîslaru, Cañas,
Rafaela, Trillet-
Lenoir, Bijoux,
Cicurel
Paragraph 2
CA 2 Rapporteur
If adopted, 68, 67, 69, 70,
+
+
71, 66, 72 and 77 fall
39/12/1
Paragraph 2
68 Szydło, Rafalska,
Falls if CA 2 adopted
-
↓
Zalewska
Paragraph 2
67 Gálvez Muñoz,
Falls if CA 2 or 68 adopted
+
↓
Homs Ginel, Durá
Ferrandis, Brglez,
Pizarro, Gualmini,
Blinkevičiūtė,
Lalucq, Dobrev
Paragraph 2
69 Rondinelli
Falls if CA 2 or 68 adopted
+
↓
Paragraph 2
70 Sander
Falls if CA 2 or 68 adopted
-
↓
Paragraph 2
71 Kympouropoulos
Falls if CA 2, 68 or 70
-
↓
adopted
Paragraph 2
66 Vedrenne, Brunet,
Falls if CA 2, 68, 70 or 71
-
↓
Ďuriš
adopted
Nicholsonová,
Pîslaru, Cañas,
Rafaela, Trillet-
Lenoir, Bijoux,
Cicurel
Paragraph 2
72 Ždanoka
Falls if CA 2 or 68 adopted
+
↓
Paragraph 7 a
CA 7 A Rapporteur
If adopted, 74 and 219 fall
+
+
(new)
39/6/7
Paragraph 3
CA 3 Rapporteur
If adopted, 74, 76, 78, 82,
+
+
80, 73, 75 and 77 fall
26/21/5
Paragraph 3
74 Arvanitis, Chaibi,
Falls if CA 7 A or CA 3
+
↓
Villumsen,
adopted
Rodríguez Palop
Paragraph 3
76 Vedrenne, Brunet,
Falls if CA 3 adopted
-
↓
Ďuriš
Nicholsonová,
Pîslaru, Cañas,
Rafaela, Trillet-
Lenoir, Bijoux,
Cicurel
Paragraph 3
78 Szydło, Rafalska,
Fall if CA 3 adopted
-
↓
Zalewska
Identical
79 Skyttedal, Polfjärd
Paragraph 3
82 Kympouropoulos
Falls if CA 3 adopted
-
↓
Paragraph 3
80 Sander
Fall if CA 3, 78 or 82
-
↓
adopted
81 Lexmann
Identical
Paragraph 3
73 Gálvez Muñoz,
Falls if CA 3, 76, 78, 82 or
+
↓
Homs Ginel, Durá
80 adopted Ferrandis, Brglez,
Pizarro, Gualmini,
Blinkevičiūtė,
Lalucq, Dobrev
Paragraph 3
75 Ždanoka
Falls if CA 3, 76, 78, 82 or
+
↓
80 adopted
Paragraph 3
77 Rondinelli
Falls if CA 2, CA 3, 76, 78,
+
↓
82 or 80 adopted
Paragraph 3 a
83 Ždanoka
+
-
(new)
21/31/0
Paragraph 19
CA 19 c Rapportuer
If adopted, 84, 140 and 219
+
+
c (new)
fall
27/23/2
Paragraph 3 b
84 Ždanoka
Falls if CA 19 c adopted
+
↓
(new)
Paragraph 4
CA 4 Rapporteur
If adopted, 89, 85, 93, 92,
+
+
86, 87, 88, 90 and 94 fall
25/24/3
Paragraph 4
89 Arvanitis, Chaibi,
Falls if CA 4 adopted
-
↓
Villumsen,
Rodríguez Palop
Paragraph 4
85 Skyttedal, Polfjärd
Falls if CA 4 or 89 adopted
-
↓
Paragraph 4
93 Lexmann
Falls if CA 4, 89 or 85
-
↓
adopted
Paragraph 4
92 Kympouropoulos
Falls if CA 4, 89, 85 or 93
-
↓
adopted
Paragraph 4
86 Vedrenne, Brunet,
Falls if CA 4, 89, 85, 93 or
-
↓
Ďuriš
92 adopted
Nicholsonová,
Pîslaru, Cañas,
Rafaela, Trillet-
Lenoir, Bijoux,
Cicurel
Paragraph 4
87 Rondinelli
Falls if CA 4, 89, 85, 93 or
+
↓
92 adopted
Paragraph 4
88 Gálvez Muñoz,
Falls if CA 4, 89, 85, 93 or
+
↓
Homs Ginel, Durá
92 adopted Ferrandis, Brglez,
Pizarro, Gualmini,
Blinkevičiūtė,
Dobrev
Paragraph 4
90 de la Pisa Carrión
Fall if CA 4, 89, 85, 93, 92
-
↓
or 86 adopted
91 Szydło, Rafalska,
Identical
Zalewska
Paragraph 4
94 Sander
Falls if CA 4, 85, 93, 92, 86
+
↓
or 90 adopted
Paragraph 5
CA 5 Rapporteur
If adopted, 98, 96, 97, 102,
+
+
101, 95, 99 and 100 fall
40/0/12
Paragraph 5
98 Sander
Falls if CA 5 adopted
-
↓
Paragraph 5
96 Lexmann
Falls if CA 5 or 98 adopted
-
↓
Paragraph 5
97 Skyttedal, Polfjärd
Falls if CA 5, 98 or 96
-
↓
adopted
Paragraph 5
102 Kympouropoulos
Falls if CA 5, 98, 96 or 97
-
↓
adopted
Paragraph 5
101 Szydło, Rafalska,
Falls if CA 5, 98, 96, 97 or
-
↓
Zalewska
102 adopted
Paragraph 5
95 Arvanitis, Chaibi,
Falls if CA 5, 98, 96, 97,
+
↓
Villumsen,
102 or 101 adopted
Rodríguez Palop
Paragraph 5
99 Vedrenne, Brunet,
Falls if CA 5, 98, 96, 97,
-
↓
Ďuriš
102, 101 or 95 adopted
Nicholsonová,
Pîslaru, Cañas,
Rafaela, Trillet-
Lenoir, Bijoux,
Cicurel
Paragraph 5
100 Rondinelli
Falls if CA 5, 98, 96, 97,
+
↓
102 or 99 adopted
Paragraph 5 a
103 Rondinelli
+
-
(new)
21/28/3
Paragraph 6
CA 6 Rappoerteur
If adopted, 105, 107, 109,
+
+
111, 104, 106, 112 and 113
26/15/10
fall
Paragraph 6
105 Gálvez Muñoz,
Falls if CA 6 adopted
+
↓
Homs Ginel, Durá
Ferrandis, Brglez,
Pizarro, Gualmini,
Blinkevičiūtė,
Dobrev
Paragraph 6
107 Skyttedal, Polfjärd
Fall if CA 6 adopted
-
↓
Identical
108 Szydło, Rafalska,
Zalewska
Paragraph 6
109 de la Pisa Carrión
Fall if CA 6 or 107
-
↓
adopted
110 Sander
Identical
Paragraph 6
111 Kympouropoulos
Falls if CA 6 adopted
-
↓
Paragraph 6
104 Arvanitis, Chaibi,
Falls if CA 6, 107, 109 or
+
↓
Villumsen,
111 adopted
Rodríguez Palop
Paragraph 6
106 Vedrenne, Brunet,
Falls if CA 6, 107, 109 or
+
↓
Ďuriš
111 adopted
Nicholsonová,
Pîslaru, Cañas,
Rafaela, Trillet-
Lenoir, Bijoux,
Cicurel
Paragraph 6
112 Ždanoka
Falls if CA 6, 107, 111 or
+
↓
106 adopted
Paragraph 6
113 Lexmann
Falls if CA 6, 107, 109, 111
-
↓
or 106 adopted
Paragraph 7
CA 7 Rapporteur
If adopted, 114, 120, 118,
+
-
119, 117, 121 and 122 fall
24/25/3
Paragraph 7
114 Skyttedal, Polfjärd
Fall if CA 7 adopted
-
-
Identical
23/24/3
115 Sander
Deletion
116 Lexmann
Paragraph 7
120 Kympouropoulos
Falls if CA 7 or 114
-
+
adopted
26/24/0
Paragraph 7
118 Vedrenne, Brunet,
Falls if CA 7, 114 or 120
-
↓
Cañas, Rafaela,
adopted
Trillet-Lenoir,
Bijoux, Cicurel
Paragraph 7
119 Szydło, Rafalska,
Falls if CA 7, 114 or 120
-
↓
Zalewska
adopted
Paragraph 7
117 Arvanitis, Chaibi,
Falls if CA 7, 114, 120, 118
+
↓
Villumsen,
or 119 adopted
Rodríguez Palop
Paragraph 7
121 Gálvez Muñoz,
Falls if CA 7, 114 or 119
+
-
Homs Ginel, Durá
adopted
20/22/8
Ferrandis, Brglez,
Pizarro, Gualmini,
Blinkevičiūtė,
Dobrev
Paragraph 7
122 Ždanoka
Falls if CA 7, 114, 120 or
+
↓
118 adopted
Paragraph 8
CA 8 Rapporteur
If adopted, 125, 126, 124,
+
+
123, 127, 131, 128, 129, 130
30/15/7
and 132 fall
Paragraph 8
125 Lexmann
Falls if CA 8 adopted
-
↓
Paragraph 8
126 Kympouropoulos
Falls if CA 8 or 125
-
↓
adopted
Paragraph 8
124 Fest
Falls if CA 8, 125 or 126
-
↓
adopted
Paragraph 8
123 Skyttedal, Polfjärd
Falls if CA 8, 125, 126 or
-
↓
124 adopted
Paragraph 8
127 Sander
Falls if CA 8 or 125
-
↓
adopted
Paragraph 8
131 Vedrenne, Brunet,
Falls if CA 8 or 125
-
↓
Ďuriš
adopted
Nicholsonová,
Pîslaru, Cañas,
Rafaela, Trillet-
Lenoir, Bijoux,
Cicurel
Paragraph 8
128 Szydło, Rafalska,
Falls if CA 8, 125, 126,
-
↓
Zalewska
124, 123, 127 or 131
adopted
Paragraph 8
129 Arvanitis, Chaibi,
Falls if CA 8, 125, 126,
-
↓
Villumsen
124, 123 or 131 adopted
Paragraph 8
130 Rondinelli
Falls if CA 8, 125, 126,
+
↓
124, 123, 127 or 131
adopted
Paragraph 8
132 Gálvez Muñoz,
Falls if CA 8, 125, 126,
+
↓
Homs Ginel, Durá
124, 123, 127, 131 or 128
Ferrandis, Brglez,
adopted
Pizarro, Gualmini,
Blinkevičiūtė,
Lalucq, Dobrev
Paragraph 9
CA 9 Rapporteur
If adopted, 133, 136, 137,
+
+
134 and 135 fall
27/24/1
Paragraph 9
133 Gálvez Muñoz,
Falls if CA 9 adopted
+
↓
Homs Ginel, Durá
Ferrandis, Brglez,
Pizarro, Gualmini,
Blinkevičiūtė,
Lalucq, Dobrev
Paragraph 9
136 Kympouropoulos
Falls if CA 9 adopted
-
↓
Paragraph 9
137 Fest
Falls if CA 9 adopted
-
↓
Paragraph 9
134 Vedrenne, Brunet,
Falls if CA 9, 136 or 137
+
↓
Ďuriš
adopted
Nicholsonová,
Pîslaru, Cañas,
Rafaela, Trillet-
Lenoir, Bijoux,
Cicurel
Paragraph 9
135 Ždanoka
Falls if CA 9 adopted
+
↓
Paragraph 9 a
138 Gálvez Muñoz,
+
+
(new)
Homs Ginel, Durá
25/24/3
Ferrandis, Brglez,
Pizarro, Gualmini,
Blinkevičiūtė,
Lalucq, Dobrev
Paragraph 9 b
139 Gálvez Muñoz,
+
-
(new)
Homs Ginel, Durá
18/30/4
Ferrandis, Brglez,
Pizarro, Gualmini,
Blinkevičiūtė,
Lalucq, Dobrev
Paragraph 9 c
140 Gálvez Muñoz,
Falls if CA 19 c adopted
+
↓
(new)
Homs Ginel, Durá
Ferrandis, Brglez,
Pizarro, Gualmini,
Blinkevičiūtė,
Lalucq, Dobrev
Paragraph 10
CA 10 Rapporteur
If adopted, 141, 146, 147,
+
+
142, 143, 145 and 144 fall
37/12/3
Paragraph 10
141 Skyttedal, Polfjärd
Falls if CA 10 adopted
-
↓
Deletion
Paragraph 10
146 Kympouropoulos
Falls if CA 10 or 141
-
↓
adopted
Paragraph 10
147 Lexmann
Falls if CA 10, 141 or 146
-
↓
adopted
Paragraph 10
142 Gálvez Muñoz,
Falls if CA 10, 141 or 147
+
↓
Homs Ginel, Durá
adopted Ferrandis, Brglez,
Pizarro, Gualmini,
Blinkevičiūtė,
Lalucq, Dobrev
Paragraph 10
143 Ždanoka
Falls if CA 10 or 141
+
↓
adopted
Paragraph 10
145 Sander
Falls if CA 10, 141, 146 or
-
↓
147 adopted
Paragraph 10
144 Arvanitis, Chaibi,
Falls if CA 10, 141, 147 or
+
↓
Villumsen
145 adopted
Subheading 1
CA 10 Rapporteur
If adopted, 149 and 148
+
+
A
fall
39/4/8
Subheading 1
149 Kympouropoulos
Falls if CA 10 A adopted
-
↓
Subheading 1
148 Vedrenne, Brunet,
Falls if CA 10 A or 149
-
↓
Ďuriš
adopted
Nicholsonová,
Pîslaru, Cañas,
Rafaela, Trillet-
Lenoir, Bijoux,
Cicurel
Paragraph 10
150 Pereira
-
-
a (new)
4/44/4
Paragraph 10
151 Pereira
-
-
b (new)
1/45/5
Paragraph 11
CA 11 Rapporteur
If adopted, 152, 154, 155,
+
-
157 and 156 fall
26/26/0
Paragraph 11
152 Fest
Fall if CA 11 adopted
-
-
Identical
11/40/0
153 Szydło, Rafalska,
Deletion
Zalewska
Paragraph 11
154 Kympouropoulos
Falls if CA 11 or 152
-
-
adopted
21/24/5
Paragraph 11
155 Gálvez Muñoz,
Falls if 144, CA 11 or 152
+
+
Homs Ginel, Durá
adopted
26/19/4
Ferrandis, Brglez,
Pizarro, Gualmini,
Blinkevičiūtė,
Lalucq, Dobrev
Paragraph 11
157 de la Pisa Carrión
Falls if CA 11 or 152
-
-
adopted
22/28/0
Paragraph 11
156 Vedrenne, Brunet,
Falls if CA 11, 152, 154 or
-
-
Pîslaru, Cañas,
157 adopted
11/34/5
Rafaela, Trillet-
Lenoir, Bijoux,
Cicurel
Paragraph 12
CA 12 Rapporteur
If adopted, 158, 160, 159,
+
-
162, 161 and 163 fall
24/24/4
Paragraph 12
158 Szydło, Rafalska,
Falls if CA 12 adopted
-
-
Zalewska
Deletion
24/26/0
Paragraph 12
160 Kympouropoulos
Falls if CA 12 or 158
-
+
adopted
25/24/1
Paragraph 12
159 Lexmann
Falls if CA 12, 158 or 160
-
↓
adopted
Paragraph 12
162 Vedrenne, Brunet,
Falls if CA 12, 158, 160 or
-
↓
Ďuriš
159 adopted
Nicholsonová,
Pîslaru, Cañas,
Rafaela, Trillet-
Lenoir, Bijoux,
Cicurel
Paragraph 12
161 de la Pisa Carrión
Falls if CA 12, 158, 160 or
-
↓
162 adopted
Paragraph 12
163 Sander
Falls if CA 12, 158, 160,
-
↓
159 or 161 adopted
Paragraph 12
164 Gálvez Muñoz,
No vote
+
↓
a (new)
Homs Ginel, Durá
Covered by par 12 Ferrandis, Brglez,
Pizarro, Gualmini,
Blinkevičiūtė,
Lalucq, Dobrev
Paragraph 12
165 Sander
+
+
a (new)
31/18/2
Paragraph 12
166 Gálvez Muñoz,
+
-
b (new)
Homs Ginel, Durá
21/28/2
Ferrandis, Brglez,
Pizarro, Gualmini,
Blinkevičiūtė,
Lalucq, Dobrev
Paragraph 13
CA 13 Rapporteur
If adopted, 167, 168, 170
+
+
and 171 fall
38/12/1
Paragraph 13
167 Kympouropoulos
Falls if CA 13 adopted
-
↓
Paragraph 13
168 Ždanoka
Falls if CA 13 adopted
+
↓
Paragraph 13
169 Gálvez Muñoz,
+
+
a (new)
Homs Ginel, Durá
24/23/5
Ferrandis, Brglez,
Pizarro, Gualmini,
Blinkevičiūtė,
Lalucq, Dobrev
Paragraph 13
170 Rondinelli
Falls if CA 13 adopted
+
↓
a (new)
Paragraph 13
171 Gálvez Muñoz,
Falls if CA 13 adopted
+
↓
b (new)
Homs Ginel, Durá
Ferrandis, Brglez,
Pizarro, Gualmini,
Blinkevičiūtė,
Dobrev
Paragraph 13
172 Rondinelli
+
+
b (new)
32/18/2
Paragraph 14
CA 14 Rapporteur
If adopted, 173, 174, 175,
+
+
176 and 177 fall
26/21/5
Paragraph 14
173 Arvanitis, Chaibi,
Falls if CA 14 adopted
+
↓
Villumsen,
Rodríguez Palop
Paragraph 14
174 Gálvez Muñoz,
Falls if CA 14 adopted
+
↓
Homs Ginel, Durá
Ferrandis, Brglez,
Pizarro, Gualmini,
Blinkevičiūtė,
Lalucq, Dobrev
Paragraph 14
175 Ždanoka
Falls if CA 14 adopted
+
↓
Paragraph 14
176 Szydło, Rafalska,
Falls if CA 14 adopted
-
↓
Zalewska
Paragraph 14
177 Lexmann
Falls if CA 14 or 176
-
↓
adopted
Paragraph 14
178 Gálvez Muñoz,
Split vote (Renew)
+
+
a (new)
Homs Ginel, Durá
Part 1
24/23/5
Ferrandis, Brglez,
“Warns about the need …
Pizarro, Gualmini,
and climate change;” Blinkevičiūtė,
Lalucq, Dobrev
Part 2
+
+
“calls for the protection …
40/9/3
an inclusive transition;”
Paragraph 14
179 Arvanitis, Chaibi,
+
+
a (new)
Villumsen
36/4/12
Subheading 2
CA 14 Rapporteur
If adopted, 180 fall
+
+
A
43/5/4
Subheading 2
180 Vedrenne, Brunet,
Falls if CA 14 A adopted
-
↓
Ďuriš
Nicholsonová,
Pîslaru, Cañas,
Rafaela, Trillet-
Lenoir, Bijoux,
Cicurel
Paragraph 14
181 Gálvez Muñoz,
+
+
b (new)
Homs Ginel, Durá
47/2/3
Ferrandis, Brglez,
Pizarro, Gualmini,
Blinkevičiūtė,
Lalucq, Dobrev
Paragraph 14
182 Pereira
0
-
a (new)
8/26/18
Paragraph 14
183 Arvanitis, Chaibi,
+
+
b (new)
Villumsen,
34/14/4
Rodríguez Palop
Paragraph 15
CA 15 Rapporteur
If adopted, 185, 208 and
+
+
a (new)
A
217 fall
47/1/4
Paragraph 15
CA 15 Rapporteur
If adopted, 185, 184, 186,
+
+
and 15 b
187, 188, 189 and 190 fall
30/11/10
(new)
Paragraph 15
185 Kympouropoulos
Falls if CA 15 A or CA 15
-
↓
adopted
Paragraph 15
184 Vedrenne, Brunet,
Falls if CA 15 or 185
+
↓
Pîslaru, Cañas,
adopted
Rafaela, Trillet-
Lenoir, Bijoux,
Cicurel
Paragraph 15
186 Arvanitis, Chaibi,
Falls if CA 15 adopted
+
↓
Villumsen
Paragraph 15
187 Szydło, Rafalska,
Falls if CA 15 adopted
-
↓
Zalewska
Paragraph 15
188 Cañas
Falls if CA 15 adopted
+
↓
Paragraph 15
189 Fest
Falls if CA 15, 185 or 184
-
↓
adopted
Paragraph 15
190 Rondinelli
Falls if CA 15 or 186
+
↓
adopted
Paragraphs
CA 19 Rapporteur
If adopted, 191, 193, 196,
+
+
19 a and b
A
218 and 220 fall
37/8/7
(new)
Paragraph 15
191 Kympouropoulos
Falls if CA 19 A adopted
+
↓
a (new)
Paragraph 15
192 Vedrenne, Brunet,
+
+
a (new)
Pîslaru, Cañas,
37/14/1
Rafaela, Trillet-
Lenoir, Bijoux,
Cicurel
Paragraph 15
193 Gálvez Muñoz,
Falls if CA 19 A adopted
+
↓
a (new)
Homs Ginel, Durá
Ferrandis, Brglez,
Pizarro, Gualmini,
Blinkevičiūtė,
Lalucq, Dobrev
Paragraph 15
194 Cañas
+
+
a (new)
32/18/2
Paragraph 15
195 Cañas
+
+
b (new)
52/0/0
Paragraph 15
196 Kympouropoulos
Falls if CA 19 A adopted
+
↓
b (new)
Paragraph 16
CA 16 Rapporteur
If adopted, 197, 203, 198,
+
+
199, 201, 200, 202 and 204
29/23/0
fall
Paragraph 16
197 Lexmann
Falls if CA 16 adopted
-
↓
Deletion
Paragraph 16
203 Kympouropoulos
Falls if CA 16 or 197
-
↓
adopted
Paragraph 16
198 Ždanoka
Falls if CA 16, 197 or 203
+
↓
adopted
Paragraph 16
199 Arvanitis, Chaibi,
Falls if CA 16 or 197
+
↓
Villumsen,
adopted
Rodríguez Palop
Paragraph 16
201 Szydło, Rafalska,
Falls if CA 16, 197 or 203
-
↓
Zalewska
adopted
Paragraph 16
200 Sander
Falls if CA 16, 197 or 201
-
↓
adopted
Paragraph 16
202 de la Pisa Carrión
Falls if CA 16, 197, 203 or
-
↓
201 adopted
Paragraph 16
204 Vedrenne, Brunet,
Falls if CA 16, 197, 203 or
-
↓
Pîslaru, Cañas,
201 adopted
Rafaela, Trillet-
Lenoir, Bijoux,
Cicurel
Paragraph 16
205 Gálvez Muñoz,
+
-
a (new)
Homs Ginel, Durá
20/30/2
Ferrandis, Brglez,
Pizarro, Gualmini,
Blinkevičiūtė,
Lalucq, Dobrev
Paragraph 16
206 Vedrenne, Brunet,
+
+
a (new)
Ďuriš
40/10/2
Nicholsonová,
Pîslaru, Cañas,
Rafaela, Trillet-
Lenoir, Bijoux,
Cicurel
Paragraph 16
207 Arvanitis, Chaibi,
+
+
a (new)
Villumsen,
28/24/0
Rodríguez Palop
Paragraph 16
208 Vedrenne, Brunet,
Falls if CA 15 A adopted
+
↓
b (new)
Ďuriš
Nicholsonová,
Pîslaru, Cañas,
Rafaela, Trillet-
Lenoir, Bijoux,
Cicurel
Paragraph 16
209 Arvanitis, Chaibi
+
-
b (new)
24/25/3
Paragraph 17
CA 17 Rapporteur
If adopted, 213, 210, 211,
+
+
and 17 a
212, 214, 215, 216, 65 and
43/1/8
(new)
221 fall
Paragraph 17
213 Fest
Falls if CA 17 adopted
-
↓
Paragraph 17
210 Arvanitis, Chaibi,
Falls if CA 17 or 213
+
↓
Villumsen,
adopted
Rodríguez Palop
Paragraph 17
211 Kympouropoulos
Falls if CA 17 adopted
-
↓
Paragraph 17
212 Rondinelli
Falls if CA 17 adopted
+
↓
Paragraph 17
214 Ždanoka
Falls if CA 17 adopted
+
↓
Paragraph 17
215 Lexmann
Falls if CA 17 or 211
-
↓
adopted
Paragraph 17
216 Szydło, Rafalska,
Falls if CA 17 or 213
-
↓
Zalewska
adopted
Paragraph 1 b
65 Vedrenne, Brunet,
Falls if CA 17 adopted
+
↓
(new)
Ďuriš
Nicholsonová,
Pîslaru, Cañas,
Rafaela, Trillet-
Lenoir, Bijoux,
Cicurel
Paragraph 17
217 Arvanitis, Chaibi,
Falls if CA 15 A adopted
+
↓
a (new)
Villumsen,
Rodríguez Palop
Paragraph 17
218 Gálvez Muñoz,
Falls if CA 19 A adopted
+
↓
a (new)
Homs Ginel, Durá
Ferrandis, Brglez,
Pizarro, Gualmini,
Blinkevičiūtė,
Lalucq, Dobrev
Paragraph 17
219 Vedrenne, Brunet,
Falls if CA 7 A or CA 19 c
+
↓
a (new)
Ďuriš
adopted
Nicholsonová,
Pîslaru, Cañas,
Rafaela, Trillet-
Lenoir, Bijoux,
Cicurel
Paragraph 17
220 Gálvez Muñoz,
Falls if CA 19 A adopted
+
↓
a (new)
Homs Ginel, Durá
Ferrandis, Brglez,
Pizarro, Gualmini,
Blinkevičiūtė,
Dobrev
Paragraph 17
221 Kympouropoulos
Falls if CA 17 adopted
-
↓
a (new)
Paragraph 17
222 Vedrenne, Brunet,
Split vote (EPP)
+
+
b (new)
Ďuriš
Part 1
39/8/5
Nicholsonová,
Whole AM without part 2
Pîslaru, Cañas,
Rafaela, Trillet-
Lenoir, Bijoux,
Cicurel
Part 2
+
-
Falls if 222 Part 1 NOT
23/24/4
adopted “establish clear quantitative
… publication of country-
specific recommendations in
order to”
Paragraph 17
223 Vedrenne, Brunet,
+
+
c (new)
Ďuriš
40/8/4
Nicholsonová,
Pîslaru, Cañas,
Rafaela, Trillet-
Lenoir, Bijoux,
Cicurel
Paragraph 17
224 Gálvez Muñoz,
Split vote (Renew)
+
+
c (new)
Homs Ginel, Durá
Part 1
48/1/3
Ferrandis, Brglez,
“Reminds that principle 15
Pizarro, Gualmini,
… ensure living in dignity;” Blinkevičiūtė,
Lalucq, Dobrev
Part 2
+
-
Falls if 224 Part 1 NOT
23/25/4
adopted “warns that any pension
reform … majority
recipients;”
Paragraph 17
225 Arvanitis, Chaibi,
+
-
a (new)
Villumsen,
19/30/3
Rodríguez Palop
Paragraph 18
CA 18 Rapporteur
If adopted, 227, 230, 228,
+
+
226, 229 and 231 fall
39/9/4
Paragraph 18
227 Rondinelli
Falls if CA 18 adopted
+
↓
Paragraph 18
230 Fest
Falls if CA 18 adopted
-
↓
Paragraph 18
228 Szydło, Rafalska,
Falls if CA 18 or 230
-
↓
Zalewska
adopted
Paragraph 18
226 Kympouropoulos
Falls if CA 18, 230 or 228
-
↓
adopted
Paragraph 18
229 Vedrenne, Brunet,
Falls if CA 18, 230, 228 or
-
↓
Ďuriš
226 adopted
Nicholsonová,
Pîslaru, Cañas,
Rafaela, Trillet-
Lenoir, Bijoux,
Cicurel
Paragraph 18
231 Ždanoka
Falls if CA 18, 230 or 226
+
↓
adopted
Paragraph 18
232 Pereira
0
-
a (new)
10/24/18
Paragraph 18
233 Ždanoka
+
-
a (new)
26/26/0
Paragraph 18
234 Cañas
+
+
a (new)
46/3/3
Paragraph 18
235 Gálvez Muñoz,
Split vote (Renew)
+
+
b (new)
Homs Ginel, Durá
Part 1
45/5/2
Ferrandis, Brglez,
Whole AM without part 2
Pizarro, Gualmini,
Blinkevičiūtė,
Lalucq, Dobrev
Part 2
+
-
Falls if 235 Part 1 NOT
19/32/1
adopted “and to reject those that
might be … precariousness
in the labour market”
Paragraph 18
236 Gálvez Muñoz,
+
-
c (new)
Homs Ginel, Durá
20/31/1
Ferrandis, Brglez,
Pizarro, Gualmini,
Blinkevičiūtė,
Lalucq, Dobrev
Paragraph 18
237 Gálvez Muñoz,
+
+
d (new)
Homs Ginel, Durá
27/25/0
Ferrandis, Brglez,
Pizarro, Gualmini,
Blinkevičiūtė,
Lalucq, Dobrev
Paragraph 18
238 Gálvez Muñoz,
+
+
e (new)
Homs Ginel, Durá
44/7/1
Ferrandis, Brglez,
Pizarro, Gualmini,
Blinkevičiūtė,
Lalucq, Dobrev
Paragraph 19
CA 19 Rapporteur
If adopted, 239, 240, 241,
+
+
243 and 242 fall
38/8/6
Paragraph 19
239 Fest
Falls if CA 19 adopted
-
↓
Deletion
Paragraph 19
240 Kympouropoulos
Falls if CA 19 or 239
-
↓
adopted
Paragraph 19
241 Lexmann
Falls if CA 19, 239 or 240
-
↓
adopted
Paragraph 19
243 de la Pisa Carrión
Falls if CA 19, 239, 240 or
-
↓
241 adopted
Paragraph 19
242 Szydło, Rafalska,
Falls if CA 19, 239, 240,
-
↓
Zalewska
241 or 243 adopted
Paragraph 19
244 Ždanoka
+
+
a (new)
40/12/0
Paragraph 19
245 Gálvez Muñoz,
+
+
a (new)
Homs Ginel, Durá
28/23/1
Ferrandis, Brglez,
Pizarro, Gualmini,
Blinkevičiūtė,
Lalucq, Dobrev
Paragraph 19
246 Gálvez Muñoz,
Split vote (EPP)
+
+
b (new)
Homs Ginel, Durá
Part 1
40/8/4
Ferrandis, Brglez,
“Stresses that social
Pizarro, Gualmini,
dialogue … in times of
Blinkevičiūtė,
economic crisis;”
Lalucq, Dobrev
Part 2
+
-
“stresses that in several
21/21/10
countries … drafting their
NRRPs”
Paragraph 19
247 Gálvez Muñoz,
+
-
c (new)
Homs Ginel, Durá
24/27/1
Ferrandis, Brglez,
Pizarro, Gualmini,
Blinkevičiūtė,
Dobrev
Paragraph 19
248 Gálvez Muñoz,
+
+
d (new)
Homs Ginel, Durá
27/25/0
Ferrandis, Brglez,
Pizarro, Gualmini,
Blinkevičiūtė,
Lalucq, Dobrev
Citation 6 a
1 Skyttedal, Polfjärd
-
-
(new)
23/24/5
Citation 10 a
2 Rondinelli
+
+
(new)
40/12/0
Citation 10 b
3 Rondinelli
+
+
(new)
40/10/2
Citation 11
4 Szydło, Rafalska,
-
-
Zalewska
12/40/0
Citation 12
5 de la Pisa Carrión
-
-
12/40/0
6 Ždanoka
Identical
+
9 Gálvez Muñoz,
Homs Ginel, Durá
Citation 13 a
Ferrandis, Brglez,
+
(new)
Pizarro, Gualmini,
46/4/2
Blinkevičiūtė,
Lalucq, Dobrev
Citation 17 a
7 Rondinelli
+
+
(new)
40/12/0
Citation 21
8 de la Pisa Carrión
-
-
10/42/0
Citation 21 b
10 Gálvez Muñoz,
+
+
(new)
Homs Ginel, Durá
40/4/8
Ferrandis, Brglez,
Pizarro, Gualmini,
Blinkevičiūtė,
Lalucq, Dobrev
Citation 21 c
11 Gálvez Muñoz,
+
+
(new)
Homs Ginel, Durá
40/6/6
Ferrandis, Brglez,
Pizarro, Gualmini,
Blinkevičiūtė,
Lalucq, Dobrev
Recital A
CA A Rapporteur
If adopted, 12, 13, 16, 14,
+
+
15, 17 and 21 fall
44/0/8
Recital A
12 Ždanoka
Falls if CA A adopted
+
↓
Recital A
13 Gálvez Muñoz,
Falls if CA A adopted
+
↓
Homs Ginel, Durá
Ferrandis, Brglez,
Pizarro, Gualmini,
Blinkevičiūtė,
Lalucq, Dobrev
Recital A
16 Kympouropoulos
Falls if CA A or 13
+
↓
adopted
Recital A
14 Sander
Falls if CA A or 16
+
↓
adopted
Recital A
15 Lexmann
Falls if CA A, 13 or 16
+
↓
adopted
Recital A
17 Rondinelli
Falls if CA A adopted
+
↓
Recital A a
18 Gálvez Muñoz,
+
+
(new)
Homs Ginel, Durá
46/0/6
Ferrandis, Brglez,
Pizarro, Gualmini,
Blinkevičiūtė,
Dobrev
Recital A a
19 Manders
Split vote (S&D)
+
+
(new)
Part 1
42/6/4
Whole AM without part 2
Part 2
-
+
Falls if 19 Part 1 NOT
25/23/4
adopted “to voluntarily work beyond
the regular pension age”
Recital F a
CA F a Rapporteur
If adopted, 20 and 53 fall
+
+
(new)
40/2/10
Recital A a
20 Vedrenne, Brunet,
Falls if CA F a adopted
+
↓
(new)
Ďuriš
Nicholsonová,
Pîslaru, Cañas,
Rafaela, Trillet-
Lenoir, Bijoux,
Cicurel
Recital A a
21 Cañas
Falls if CA A adopted
+
↓
(new)
Recital A b
22 Gálvez Muñoz,
+
+
(new)
Homs Ginel, Durá
49/0/3
Ferrandis, Brglez,
Pizarro, Gualmini,
Blinkevičiūtė,
Lalucq, Dobrev
Recital B
CA B Rapporteur
If adopted, 23, 27, 26, 25,
+
+
24, 28 and 29 fall
50/0/2
Recital B
23 Gálvez Muñoz,
Falls if CA B adopted
+
↓
Homs Ginel, Durá
Ferrandis, Brglez,
Pizarro, Gualmini,
Blinkevičiūtė,
Lalucq, Dobrev
Recital B
27 Kympouropoulos
Falls if CA B adopted
-
↓
Recital B
26 Lexmann
Falls if CA B or 27
-
↓
adopted
Recital B
25 Sander
Falls if CA B, 27 or 26
-
↓
adopted
Recital B
24 Rondinelli
Falls if CA B, 27, 26 or 25
+
↓
adopted
Recital B
28 Ždanoka
Falls if CA B, 27, 26 or 25
+
↓
adopted
Recital B a
29 Vedrenne, Brunet,
Falls if CA B adopted
+
↓
(new)
Ďuriš
Nicholsonová,
Pîslaru, Cañas,
Rafaela, Trillet-
Lenoir, Bijoux,
Cicurel
Recital D
CA D Rapporteur
If adopted, 30, 31, 32, 33,
+
+
34, 35, 36 and 37 fall
48/0/4
Recital D
30 Kympouropoulos
Falls if CA D adopted
+
↓
Recital D
31 Lexmann
Falls if CA D adopted
+
↓
Recital D
32 Arvanitis, Chaibi,
Falls if CA D adopted
+
↓
Villumsen,
Rodríguez Palop
Recital D
33 Ždanoka
Falls if CA D adopted
+
↓
Recital D
34 Gálvez Muñoz,
Falls if CA D adopted
+
↓
Homs Ginel, Durá
Ferrandis, Brglez,
Pizarro, Gualmini,
Blinkevičiūtė,
Lalucq, Dobrev
Recital D
35 Manders
Falls if CA D adopted
+
↓
Recital D
36 Sander
Falls if CA D adopted
+
↓
Recital D
37 Rondinelli
Falls if CA D or 33
+
↓
adopted
Recital D a
38 Kympouropoulos
+
+
(new)
42/6/3
Recital E
CA E Rapporteur
If adopted, 39, 40, 41 and
+
+
42 fall
50/1/1
Recital E
39 Gálvez Muñoz,
Falls if CA E adopted
+
↓
Homs Ginel, Durá
Ferrandis, Brglez,
Pizarro, Gualmini,
Blinkevičiūtė,
Lalucq, Dobrev
Recital E
40 Lexmann
Falls if CA E adopted
-
↓
Recital E
41 Kympouropoulos
Falls if CA E adopted
-
↓
Recital E
42 Skyttedal, Polfjärd
-
↓
43 Sander
Fall if CA E or 41 adopted
Identical
Recital E a
44 Gálvez Muñoz,
+
+
(new)
Homs Ginel, Durá
35/10/7
Ferrandis, Brglez,
Pizarro, Gualmini,
Blinkevičiūtė,
Lalucq, Dobrev
Recital F
CA F Rapporteur
If adopted, 49, 45, 46, 47
+
+
and 48 fall
52/0/0
Recital F
49 Lexmann
Falls if CA F adopted
-
↓
Recital F
45 Kympouropoulos
Falls if CA F or 49
+
↓
adopted
Recital F
46 de la Pisa Carrión
Falls if CA F or 49
-
↓
adopted
Recital F
47 Sander
Falls if CA F or 49
+
↓
adopted
Recital F
48 Ždanoka
Falls if CA F, 49 or 46
+
↓
adopted
Recital F a
50 Gálvez Muñoz,
+
+
(new)
Homs Ginel, Durá
44/8/0
Ferrandis, Brglez,
Pizarro, Gualmini,
Blinkevičiūtė,
Lalucq, Dobrev
Recital F a
51 Arvanitis, Chaibi,
+
+
(new)
Villumsen,
44/7/0
Rodríguez Palop
Recital F a
52 Pereira
0
-
(new)
10/26/16
Recital F b
53 Arvanitis, Chaibi,
Falls if CA F a adopted
+
↓
(new)
Villumsen
Recital F b
54 Gálvez Muñoz,
+
+
(new)
Homs Ginel, Durá
41/11/0
Ferrandis, Brglez,
Pizarro, Gualmini,
Blinkevičiūtė,
Dobrev
Recital F b
55 Pereira
0
-
(new)
4/25/23
Recital F c
56 Arvanitis, Chaibi,
+
+
(new)
Villumsen,
50/0/2
Rodríguez Palop
Recital E a
CA E a Rapporteur
If adopted, 57 and 58 fall
+
+
(new)
47/0/5
Recital F c
57 Gálvez Muñoz,
Falls if CA E a adopted
+
↓
(new)
Homs Ginel, Durá
Ferrandis, Brglez,
Pizarro, Gualmini,
Blinkevičiūtė,
Lalucq, Dobrev
Recital F d
58 Gálvez Muñoz,
Falls if CA E a adopted
+
↓
(new)
Homs Ginel, Durá
Ferrandis, Brglez,
Pizarro, Gualmini,
Blinkevičiūtė,
Lalucq, Dobrev
Asbestos Voting list (Nikolaj Villumsen)
Paragraphs 1
CA 15, Rapporteur
If adopted, 58, 59, 61, 62,
+
+
and 2
15a
80, ENVI 40, ENVI 44 and
53/0/0
ENVI 20 fall Para 1: Addition of
principle of Health in all
policies. Addition of
application precautionary
principle in treatment of
asbestos waste.
Para 2: addition of a
difficult and. Addition of
“points out ... main priority
“.
Vote in bloc CAs 15, 15a
Paragraph 1
58 Lundgren
Falls if CA 15, 15a adopted
-
↓
Deletion “Next Generation
EU and the Multiannual
Financial Framework”
Paragraph 1
59 Trillet-Lenoir,
Falls if CA 15, 15a or 58
+
↓
Vedrenne, Brunet,
adopted Cañas, Pîslaru
Addition “example of the
need to apply principle of
Health in all policies”.
Paragraphs
CA 19, Rapporteur
If adopted, 60, 64, 90, 91,
+
+
9,10,11
19a, 19b
92, 93, ENVI 36, ENVI 30,
48/0/5
annex ENVI 2 and ENVI
18 Part 1 fall
Para 9. Additions “taking
into account ... types ...
health effects, as well as”.
“and, in this context,
assess”; “in the list ...
covers”.
Para 10. Additions “calls ...
protective measures”.
Para 11. Additions “the ...
of”. “Is ... perpetuates the”.
“containing importance of”.
“and regular monitoring”.
Vote in bloc CAs 19, 19a,
19b
Paragraph 1 a
60 Lundgren
Falls if CA 19, 19a, 19b
-
↓
(new)
adopted Asbestos dangerous to
remove, better not to remove
asbestos
Paragraph 1 b
61 Lundgren
Falls if CA 15, 15a adopted
-
↓
(new)
Green deal and renovation
wave not be rushed
Paragraph 2
62 Lundgren
Falls if CA 15, 15a adopted
-
↓
Paragraphs
CA 16 Rapporteur
If adopted, 63, IMCO 9,
+
+
3a (new), 3b
65, 67, 68, 78, 80, 83,
50/1/2
(new), 3c
IMCO 7, 86, 89, 112, 127,
(new), 3d
IMCO 5, 142, ENVI A,
(new)
198, ENVI 33, ENVI 45,
ENVI 46, ENVI 47, annex
ENVI 11, annex ENVI 6,
IMCO 2, IMCO 6, ENVI
30, ENVI 26, ENVI 18
Part 1 and IMCO I fall 3a: Financial consequences
of removal, workload for
certifying bodies,
appropriate transition
period.
3b:Mobilisation of Funds,
R&D, IPCEIs.
3c: Safeguard for those who
comply. Compliance with
rules on asbestos.
3d: Strengthening of EU-
OSHA, EU platform
Paragraph 3 –
63 Kopcińska
Falls if CA 16 adopted
+
↓
point e a
Financial and
(new)
administrative burden
Paragraph
IMCO 9 IMCO
Falls if CA 16 adopted
+
↓
(new)
EU platform to report on
presence of asbestos,
exchange good practices
Covered in CA16 (3d)
Paragraph 3 –
64 Lundgren
Falls if CA 19, 19a, 19b
-
↓
point e a
adopted
(new)
Risk assessment removal
versus keeping intact
Paragraphs
CA 20, Rapporteur
If adopted, 65, 94, 95, 96,
+
+
12, 12a
20a
97, 98, 99, 100, annex
46/0/7
(new), 12b
ENVI 8, IMCO 2, ENVI
(new), 12c
30 and ENVI 18 Part 1 fall
(new), 12d
12a (new): updated
(new)
technical requirements,
robots, exchange, optical
microscopy, ATEM.
12b (new): sampling.
12c (new): Information in
notification.
12d (new): support to
employers, standardised
processes.
Vote in bloc CAs 20,20a
Paragraph 3 –
65 Zambelli, Lizzi
Falls if CA 16 or CA 20,
-
↓
point e a
20a adopted
(new)
Support for SMEs
Paragraph 3 –
66 Zambelli, Lizzi
Implementation of EU calls
-
-
point e b
for tender
10/41/2
(new)
Paragraph 3 a
67 Danielsson,
Falls if CA 16 adopted
+
↓
(new)
Fritzon,
Funds for OSH technology,
Blinkevičiūtė,
real-time measurement,
Vind, Brglez,
research on inertisation
Jongerius,
Gualmini,
Bischoff, Homs
Ginel, Durá
Ferrandis
Paragraph 3 b
68 Danielsson,
Falls if CA 16 adopted
+
↓
(new)
Fritzon,
(No) access to funding,
Blinkevičiūtė,
compliance
Vind, Brglez,
Jongerius,
Gualmini,
Bischoff, Homs
Ginel, Durá
Ferrandis
Paragraphs
CA 26, Rapporteur
If adopted, 69, 132, 133,
+
+
22c (new),
26a
87, 134, 135, 136, 137, 138,
51/0/2
22d (new)
139, IMCO 11, ENVI 42
Part 1, ENVI 48, ENVI 49,
ENVI 50, ENVI 51 Part 2,
ENVI 52, ENVI 53 and
annex ENVI 7 fall Subtitle: EU as global
leader
22c new: market
surveillance, control,
dismantling vessels,
mapping illegal import,
restrict access to docking
22d new: Rotterdam
Convention, toxic trade,
external policies, support
for global actors.
Vote in bloc CAs 26, 26a
Paragraph 3 d
69 Danielsson,
Falls if CA 26, 26a adopted
+
↓
(new)
Fritzon,
Study on mapping illegal
Blinkevičiūtė,
import
Vind, Brglez,
Jongerius,
Gualmini,
Bischoff, Homs
Ginel, Durá
Ferrandis
Paragraph 3e
CA 17 Rapporteur
If adopted, 70, 71, ENVI
+
+
(new)
31 and annex ENVI 4 fall
40/1/12
Information, labour
inspectorates, ILO
objectives, penalties
Paragraph 3 e
70 Danielsson,
Falls if CA 17 adopted
+
↓
(new)
Fritzon,
Labour inspectors
Blinkevičiūtė,
Vind, Brglez,
Jongerius,
Gualmini,
Bischoff, Homs
Ginel, Durá
Ferrandis
Paragraph 3 f
71 Franssen, Radtke
Falls if CA 17 or 70
+
↓
(new)
adopted Improve labour inspections
Paragraph 4
72 Lundgren
“ Takes note of” (instead
-
-
“welcomes”)
13/40/0
Paragraph 4
73 Villumsen,
Addition: “and intervening
+
+
Gusmão, Chaibi,
in emergency operations”.
49/0/4
Arvanitis,
Compatible with 72
Rodríguez Palop,
Botenga
Paragraph 4 a
74 Trillet-Lenoir,
Access to information. Link
+
+
(new)
Vedrenne, Brunet,
with CA 32, AM 119, AM
49/0/4
Cañas, Pîslaru
180, 181, ENVI 29
Paragraphs 5,
CA 18, Rapporteur
If adopted, 75, 76, 79, 81,
+
+
5a (new), 7,
18a,
82, 84, ENVI 16, 127, 141,
51/0/2
7a (new), 8
18b,
IMCO 8, ENVI 24, ENVI
18c, 18d
36, annex ENVI 3, annex
ENVI 5, annex ENVI 8,
annex ENVI 11, 24, ENVI
17, ENVI 21 and IMCO H
fall Addition in 5: “socially
fair”, “protection of health
... to enable the”
Addition 5a: “welcomes ...
ambitious plans ...,
including NL, PL,
Flanders”.
Addition in 7: “including
priorities”, “and SMEs”.
Addition 7a: surveillance,
mesothelioma as indicator,
reporting.
Addition in 8: “stresses that
registers ... GDPR”.
Vote in bloc CAs 18, 18a,
18b, 18c, 18d
Paragraph 5
75 Villumsen,
Falls if CA 18, 18a, 18b,
+
↓
Gusmão, Chaibi,
18c, 18d adopted
Arvanitis,
Addition (identification of
Rodríguez Palop,
buildings)
Botenga
Paragraph 5
76 Trillet-Lenoir,
Falls if CA 18, 18a, 18b,
+
↓
Vedrenne, Brunet,
18c, 18d adopted Cañas, Pîslaru
Addition (socially fair;
protection of health)
Compatible with 75
Paragraph 5 a
77 Matthieu
“Calls on ... access to ...
+
+
(new)
healthy housing a
27/24/2
cornerstone ... the Pillar.”
Link with CA 9 and CA 27.
Paragraph 5 b
78 Trillet-Lenoir,
Falls if CA 16 adopted
+
↓
(new)
Vedrenne, Brunet,
Support research and
Cañas, Pîslaru
development
Paragraph 5 c
79 Villumsen,
Falls if CA 18, 18a, 18b,
+
↓
(new)
Matthieu
18c, 18d adopted Removal plans in some MS
Paragraph 5 d
80 Trillet-Lenoir,
Falls if CA 15, 15a or CA
+
↓
(new)
Vedrenne, Brunet,
16 adopted Cañas, Pîslaru
Support investments, IPCEIs
Paragraph 7
81 Trillet-Lenoir,
Falls if CA 18, 18a, 18b,
+
↓
Vedrenne, Brunet,
18c, 18d adopted Cañas, Pîslaru
COMM “proposal ...
including priorities... and
support to .... and SMEs”
Paragraph 7 a
82 Trillet-Lenoir,
Falls if CA 18, 18a, 18b,
+
↓
(new)
Vedrenne, Brunet,
18c, 18d adopted Cañas, Pîslaru
Epidemiological
surveillance, mesothelioma
as indicator
Paragraph 7 b
83 Villumsen,
Falls if CA 16 adopted
+
↓
(new)
Matthieu,
Mobilise financial
Danielsson
mechanism
Paragraph
IMCO 7 IMCO
Falls if CA 16, 63, 67 or 83
+
↓
(new)
adopted Develop standardisation
process: covered in
CA16(3a).
call on COMM for umbrella
programme of all financial
programmes: covered in
CA16
Paragraph 8
84 Villumsen,
Falls if CA 18, 18a, 18b,
+
↓
Gusmão, Chaibi,
18c, 18d adopted
Arvanitis,
Addition (registers,
databases)
Rodríguez Palop,
Botenga
Point (new)
ENVI 8 ENVI
Addition: Non-occupational
+
+
exposure explains 20% of
53/0/0
mesothelioma:
Compatible with CA18c,
CA18d
Annex I
CA 28, Rapporteur
If adopted, 85, ENVI 16,
+
+
paragraphs 6,
28a, 28b
110, 119, IMCO 4, 155,
53/0/0
7, 8
156, 157, 158, IMCO 8,
annex ENVI 13, ENVI 19,
ENVI 1 part 2, annex
ENVI 2 and ENVI 43 fall Para 6: addition waste
facilities plan,
environmentally safe
storage
Para 7: addition awareness
campaigns, SMEs
Para 8: addition victims
associations
Vote in bloc CAs 28, 28a,
28b
Paragraph 8 a
85 Matthieu
Falls if CA 28, 28a, 28b
+
↓
(new)
adopted Environmental safe storage;
public health
Point (new)
ENVI ENVI
Falls if CA 18, 18a, 18b,
+
↓
16
18c, 18d, 81 or CA 28, 28a,
28b adopted EU strategy to eliminate
asbestos; MS action plans,
roadmaps; COMM to
coordinate; methodology for
risk assessment
Redundant as covered in
CA18, CA28, AM81
Paragraph 8 b
86 Zambelli, Lizzi
Falls if CA 16 adopted
-
↓
(new)
Simple practices for
disposal of asbestos-
containing waste.
Paragraph 8 d
88 Zambelli, Lizzi
Set up regional disposal and
-
-
(new)
recovery facilities
12/41/0
Paragraph 8 e
89 Zambelli, Lizzi
Falls if CA 16 adopted
-
↓
(new)
Costs of disposal, support
measures
Point (new)
ENVI ENVI
Addition: EU Environment
+
+
14
Agency to further research
50/0/3
on asbestos in rivers, effect
on vegetation and wildlife
Point (new)
ENVI ENVI
Addition: Asbestos in the
+
+
15
atmosphere to be monitored
53/0/0
and measured
Paragraph 9
90 Franssen, Radtke
Falls if CA 19, 19a, 19b
+
↓
adopted Addition (OELs,
assessment)
Paragraph 10
91 Danielsson,
Falls if CA 19, 19a, 19b
+
↓
Fritzon,
adopted
Blinkevičiūtė,
Addition (2008/148 scope)
Vind, Brglez,
Jongerius,
Gualmini,
Bischoff, Homs
Ginel, Durá
Ferrandis
Paragraph 10
92 Villumsen,
Falls if CA 19, 19a, 19b
+
↓
a (new)
Gusmão, Chaibi,
adopted
Arvanitis,
(Non-) friable asbestos-
Rodríguez Palop,
containing materials.
Botenga
Link with ENVI 10, IMCO F
Paragraph 11
93 Trillet-Lenoir,
Falls if CA 19, 19a, 19b
+
↓
Vedrenne, Brunet,
adopted Cañas, Pîslaru
Addition (removal is
priority, monitoring)
Paragraph 11
94 Villumsen,
Falls if CA 20, 20a adopted
+
↓
a (new)
Gusmão, Chaibi,
Notification
Arvanitis,
Rodríguez Palop,
Botenga
Paragraph 12
95 Franssen, Radtke
Falls if CA 20, 20a adopted
+
↓
Addition (support to
employers)
Paragraph 12
96 Danielsson,
Falls if CA 20, 20a adopted
+
↓
Fritzon,
Addition (updated
Blinkevičiūtė,
requirements); Compatible
Vind, Brglez,
with AM 95 (as addition)
Jongerius,
Gualmini,
Bischoff, Homs
Ginel, Durá
Ferrandis
Paragraph 12
97 Trillet-Lenoir,
Falls if CA 20, 20a or 95
+
↓
a (new)
Vedrenne, Brunet,
adopted Cañas, Pîslaru
Support to SMEs
Paragraph 12
98 Villumsen,
Falls if CA 20, 20a adopted
+
↓
b (new)
Danielsson
Use of robots
Paragraph 12
99 Villumsen,
Falls if CA 20, 20a adopted
+
↓
c (new)
Gusmão, Chaibi,
Sampling
Arvanitis,
Rodríguez Palop,
Botenga
Paragraph 12
100 Villumsen,
Falls if CA 20, 20a adopted
+
↓
d (new)
Gusmão, Chaibi,
Optical microscopy, ATEM
Arvanitis,
more sensitive
Rodríguez Palop,
Botenga
Paragraphs
CA 21, Rapporteur
If adopted, CA alt. 21A,
+
+
13 and 14
21a
57, 101, 102, 105, 104 and
39/11/3
103 fall Vote in bloc CAs 21, 21a
Paragraph 13
CA alt. EPP, ECR
Falls if CA 21, 21a adopted
-
↓
and
21A
If adopted, 57, 101, 102,
Paragraph 14
105, 104 and 103 fall Alternative compromise
proposal to paragraph 14
(Vote in bloc paras 13 and
14)
Paragraph -1
57 Trillet-Lenoir,
Falls if CA 21, 21a or CA
+
↓
(new)
Vedrenne, Brunet,
alt. 21A adopted Cañas, Pîslaru
COMM to present legal
proposal on asbestos
Paragraph 13
101 Franssen, Radtke
Falls if CA 21, 21a or CA
+
↓
alt. 21A adopted Addition (0,1 OELV)
Paragraph 13
102 Lundgren
Falls if CA 21, 21a, CA alt.
-
↓
21A or 101 adopted Addition “other MS ...like
Sweden ... apply current
standard”
Paragraph 14
105 Franssen, Radtke
Falls if CA 21, 21a or CA
+
↓
alt. 21A adopted Addition (legislative
proposal 31.12.2022)
Paragraph 14
104 Villumsen
Falls if CA 21, 21a, CA alt.
+
↓
21A or 105 adopted Addition (update OELV)
Paragraph 14
103 Kopcińska
Falls if CA 21, 21a or CA
+
↓
alt. 21A adopted Addition (transition period).
Compatible with 104, 105
Paragraph 14
106 Danielsson,
Scope of asbestos directive,
+
+
a (new)
Fritzon,
call for stronger provisions,
44/0/9
Blinkevičiūtė,
call for including all at-risk
Vind, Brglez,
professions
Jongerius,
Gualmini,
Bischoff, Homs
Ginel, Durá
Ferrandis
Paragraphs
CA 22, Rapporteur
If adopted, 107, 108, 109,
+
+
15 and 16
22a
111 and IMCO 2 fall
47/0/6
15: Screening of premises
built before 2005, training
in Annex, methodology for
risk assessment.
16: training included in
Annex.
Vote in bloc CAs 22, 22a
Paragraph 15
107 Trillet-Lenoir,
Falls if CA 22, 22a adopted
+
↓
Vedrenne, Brunet,
Switch in para 15 (owners
Cañas, Pîslaru
mentioned before
employers)
Paragraph 15
108 Villumsen,
Falls if CA 22, 22a adopted
+
↓
Gusmão, Chaibi,
Addition (screening before
Arvanitis,
work starts); Compatible
Rodríguez Palop,
with 107
Botenga
Paragraph 15
109 Franssen, Radtke
Falls if CA 22, 22a adopted
+
↓
Addition (coherent
methodology for risk
assessment); Compatible
with 107, 108
Paragraph 15
110 Trillet-Lenoir,
Falls if CA 28, 28a, 28b
+
↓
a (new)
Vedrenne, Brunet,
adopted Cañas, Pîslaru
Availability of waste
facilities
Paragraph 16
111 Villumsen,
Falls if CA 22, 22a adopted
+
↓
Gusmão, Chaibi,
Addition (minimum duration
Arvanitis,
of training in annex)
Rodríguez Palop,
Botenga
Paragraph 16
112 Matthieu
Falls if CA 16 adopted
+
↓
a (new)
Strengthening EU-OSHA
Paragraphs
CA 23, Rapporteur
If adopted, 113, 114, 115,
+
+
19, 19a
23a, 23b
116, ENVI 9, 117, 118,
44/0/9
(new), 19b
ENVI 4 part 2 and ENVI
(new)
19 fall Para 19: addition mobile
workers
Para 19a: Ombudsperson,
patients organisations, trade
union groups to assist
victims. Compensation. 19b:
Smoking cessation.
Vote in bloc CAs 23, 23a,
23b
Paragraph 16
113 Trillet-Lenoir,
Falls if CA 23, 23a, 23b
+
↓
b (new)
Vedrenne, Brunet,
adopted Cañas, Pîslaru
Smoking cessation
Paragraph 17
114 Villumsen,
Falls if CA 23, 23a, 23b
+
↓
a (new)
Gusmão, Chaibi,
adopted
Arvanitis,
Proposal for ombudsperson
Rodríguez Palop,
Botenga
Paragraph 18
115 Trillet-Lenoir,
Falls if CA 23, 23a, 23b
+
↓
a (new)
Vedrenne, Brunet,
adopted Cañas, Pîslaru
Consultation victim
organisations
Paragraph 19
116 Trillet-Lenoir,
Falls if CA 23, 23a, 23b
+
↓
Vedrenne, Brunet,
adopted Cañas, Pîslaru
Addition (mobile workers)
Point (new)
ENVI 9 ENVI
Falls if CA 23, 23a, 23b or
+
↓
113 adopted WHO study co-exposure
tobacco and asbestos
(covered by CA23/19b)
Paragraphs
CA 24, Rapporteur
If adopted, 117, 120, 122,
+
+
19c (new),
24a
121, 123, 124, ENVI 6, 193,
40/4/9
19d (new)
ENVI 34, ENVI 19 and
IMCO C fall 19c: Second hand exposure
19d: gender perspective and
mainstreaming (ENVI 34
integrated in 19d); cleaning
Vote in bloc CAs 24, 24a
Paragraph 19
117 Villumsen,
Falls if CA 23, 23a, 23b or
+
↓
a (new)
Matthieu,
CA 24, 24a adopted
Danielsson
Compensation and
recognition of victims
Paragraph 19
118 Matthieu
Falls if CA 23, 23a, 23b
+
↓
b (new)
adopted Establishment of victims
associations
Paragraph 19
119 Matthieu
Falls if CA 28, 28a, 28b
+
↓
c (new)
adopted Call awareness raising
campaigns, understandable
information for posted,
mobile ... workers,
secondary and
environmental exposure
Paragraph 19
120 Matthieu
Falls if CA 24, 24a adopted
+
↓
d (new)
Evaluation of secondary
exposure risks
Paragraph 19
122 Matthieu
Falls if CA 24, 24a adopted
+
↓
f (new)
Gender differences in OSH
Paragraph 19
121 Villumsen,
Falls if CA 24, 24a or 122
+
↓
e (new)
Matthieu,
adopted
Danielsson
Gender mainstreaming,
gender perspectives
Paragraph 19
123 Villumsen,
Falls if CA 24, 24a adopted
+
↓
g (new)
Gusmão, Chaibi,
Women in cleaning jobs,
Arvanitis,
cleaning products
Rodríguez Palop,
Botenga
Paragraph 19
124 Matthieu
Falls if CA 24, 24a or 123
+
↓
h (new)
adopted Cleaning activities as risk
Point (new)
ENVI 6 ENVI
Falls if CA 24, 24a, 119 or
+
↓
120 adopted
Passiv occupational
exposure
(Covered in CA 24 (19c),
AM 119, AM 120)
Point (new)
ENVI 7 ENVI
Addition: Different types of
+
+
non-occupational exposure
53/0/0
(complementary to CA 24,
CA 33, AM 19)
Paragraph
IMCO 4 IMCO
Falls if CA 28, 28a, 28b or
+
↓
(new)
119 adopted Call on COMM and MS
information campaigns
Covered in CA28a, AM 119
Recitals I a
CA 9, Rapporteur
If adopted, 126, IMCO 5,
+
+
(new), I b
9b
IMCO 3, ENVI 40, IMCO
40/6/7
(new)
2, 32, 33, 34, 35, 36, ENVI
35, 37, IMCO 6 and IMCO
I fall Right to adequate housing,
quality housing for all.
Vote in bloc CAs 9, 9b
Recital I a
CA 9a Rapporteur
If adopted, 33 fall
+
+
(new)
Separate vote on CA9a
27/18/8
“whereas it should not be
used as a pretext for ...
eviction ... homes must be
renovated”
Paragraph 20
126 Trillet-Lenoir,
Falls if CA 9, 9b adopted
+
↓
a (new)
Vedrenne, Brunet,
Socially fair, support to
Cañas, Pîslaru
owners and SMEs
Paragraphs
CA 25, Rapporteur
If adopted, 128, 129, 130,
+
+
21, 22, 22a
25a, 25b
131 and ENVI 17 fall
47/0/6
(new)
Para 21: addition 153(1)(a)
TFEU
Para 22: addition “before
the year of an equivalent...
ban, whichever the earlier”.
Para 22a: protective
measures for tenants;
tenants to receive full
disclosure ... and ...
provided ... certificate”.
Vote in bloc CAs 25, 25a,
25b
Paragraph 21
127 Matthieu
Falls if CA 16 or CA 18,
+
↓
18a, 18b, 18c, 18d adopted Addition: financial support,
low-income households
Paragraph 21
128 Villumsen,
Falls if CA 25, 25a, 25b
+
↓
Gusmão, Chaibi,
adopted
Arvanitis,
Addition (reference to art.
Rodríguez Palop,
153(1)(a) TFEU).
Botenga
Compatible with 127
Paragraph
IMCO 5 IMCO
Falls if CA 16, 63, 80, 83,
+
↓
(new)
CA 9, 9b or 127 adopted Financial support
Covered CA9 (Ib), CA16
Point (new)
ENVI ENVI
Addition: More information
+
+
11
on naturally occurring
53/0/0
asbestos and risks for
population
Annex II –
CA 30, Rapporteur
If adopted, 129, 130, 166,
+
+
point 7
30a, 30b
169, 167, 168, 170, 171 and
52/0/1
Directive
172 fall
2009/148/EC
Article 10 (1) addition: ”...
Article 10 –
or there is reason to believe
paragraph 1.
... to generate dust,”
Article 11.
Article 11 additions “or
Article 12 –
equivalent... ban”;
paragraph 1
“authority”; “where
lit. a, lit. b,
complete absence of
lit. c, lit. ca
asbestos cannot be
(new)
guaranteed, ... is present”.
Article 12(1) addition: “all
possible “.
Article 12(c): spread of dust
... “and ventilation ... not be
allowed”.
Article 12 (ca) new: on
measurement of asbestos
fibre concentration
Vote in bloc CAs 30, 30a,
30b
Paragraph 22
129 Trillet-Lenoir,
Falls if CA 25, 25a, 25b or
+
↓
Vedrenne, Brunet,
CA 30, 30a, 30b adopted Cañas, Pîslaru
Addition (year of ban)
Paragraph 22
130 Danielsson,
Falls if CA 25, 25a, 25b,
+
↓
Fritzon,
CA 30, 30a, 30b or 129
Blinkevičiūtė,
adopted
Vind, Brglez,
Jongerius,
Addition (before equivalent
Gualmini,
ban)
Bischoff, Homs
Ginel, Durá
Ferrandis
Paragraph 22
131 Villumsen,
Falls if CA 25, 25a, 25b
+
↓
a (new)
Matthieu,
adopted
Danielsson
Protective measures for
tenants
Paragraph 22
132 Danielsson,
Falls if CA 26, 26a adopted
+
↓
b (new)
Fritzon,
Labelling of asbestos market
Blinkevičiūtė,
as toxic trade
Vind, Brglez,
Jongerius,
Gualmini,
Bischoff, Homs
Ginel, Durá
Ferrandis
Paragraph 22
133 Danielsson,
Falls if CA 26, 26a adopted
+
↓
c (new)
Fritzon,
Rotterdam Convention,
Blinkevičiūtė,
chysotile
Vind, Brglez,
Jongerius,
Gualmini,
Bischoff, Homs
Ginel, Durá
Ferrandis
Paragraph 8 c
87 Matthieu
Falls if CA 26, 26a adopted
+
↓
(new)
Rotterdam Convention,
chrysotile asbestos.
Paragraph 22
134 Villumsen,
Falls if CA 26, 26a adopted
+
↓
d (new)
Gusmão, Chaibi,
Global ban, market
Arvanitis,
surveillance, controls,
Rodríguez Palop
prevent entry)
Paragraph 22
135 Danielsson,
Falls if CA 26, 26a adopted
+
↓
e (new)
Fritzon,
EU partnership,
Blinkevičiūtė,
development and
Vind, Brglez,
neighbourhood policy
Jongerius,
Gualmini,
Bischoff, Homs
Ginel, Durá
Ferrandis
Paragraph 22
136 Danielsson,
Falls if CA 26, 26a adopted
+
↓
f (new)
Fritzon,
Trade agreements,
Blinkevičiūtė,
unacceptable dumping
Vind, Brglez,
Jongerius,
Gualmini,
Bischoff, Homs
Ginel, Durá
Ferrandis
Paragraph 22
137 Danielsson,
Falls if CA 26, 26a adopted
+
↓
g (new)
Fritzon,
Support for actors
Blinkevičiūtė,
Vind, Brglez,
Jongerius,
Gualmini,
Bischoff, Homs
Ginel, Durá
Ferrandis
Paragraph 22
138 Danielsson,
Falls if CA 26, 26a adopted
+
↓
h (new)
Fritzon,
No financial support to
Blinkevičiūtė,
asbestos industries
Vind, Brglez,
Jongerius,
Gualmini,
Bischoff, Homs
Ginel, Durá
Ferrandis
Paragraph 22
139 Danielsson,
Falls if CA 26, 26a adopted
+
↓
i (new)
Fritzon,
Vessels
Blinkevičiūtė,
Vind, Brglez,
Jongerius,
Gualmini,
Bischoff, Homs
Ginel, Durá
Ferrandis
Paragraph
IMCO IMCO
Falls if CA 26, 26a, 134,
+
↓
(new)
11
135 or 136 adopted Prevent illegal placement,
market surveillance
Covered in CA26
Recital Lb
CA 12 Rapporteur
If adopted, 140, 47, 48,
+
+
(new)
ENVI 43, 49 and 56 fall
47/6/0
Built environment, COMM
strategy, Circular Economy
Action Plan, EU skills
Agenda (upskilling
construction sector), Green
Deal Renovation Wave
(skilled workers)
Paragraph 23
140 Matthieu
Falls if CA 12 adopted
+
↓
a (new)
Circular economy in
construction
Paragraph 23
141 Matthieu
Falls if CA 18, 18a, 18b,
+
↓
b (new)
18c, 18d adopted EU level plan for total
removal, make housing
healthier
Paragraph 23
142 Matthieu
Falls if CA 16 adopted
+
↓
c (new)
Establish EU platform
Annex I
CA 27, Rapporteur
If adopted, 143, 144, 145,
+
+
paragraphs 2,
27a, 27b
146, 147, 148, 150, 149,
48/0/5
3 and 4 point
151, 152, 153, IMCO 10,
4 – points a,
ENVI A, IMCO 1 d, ENVI
d, da (new)
27, ENVI 41, annex ENVI
9, ENVI 32, ENVI 17 and
ENVI 35 fall Para 2: certain buildings
Para 3: funds
Para 4 lit.a: firefighters,
GDPR
Para 4 lit.d: parts of
buildings screened
Para 4 lit.da (new):
indication where work
performed
Vote in bloc CAs 27, 27a,
27b
Annex I –
143 Matthieu
Falls if CA 27, 27a, 27b
+
↓
paragraph 1 –
adopted
point 2
“Prioritising certain
buildings”
Annex I –
144 Danielsson,
Falls if CA 27, 27a, 27b
+
↓
paragraph 1 –
Fritzon,
adopted
point 2
Blinkevičiūtė,
“hospitals, sports centres or
Vind, Brglez,
public”.
Jongerius,
Compatible with 143
Gualmini,
Bischoff, Homs
Ginel, Durá
Ferrandis
Annex I –
145 Trillet-Lenoir,
Falls if CA 27, 27a, 27b
+
↓
paragraph 1 –
Vedrenne, Brunet,
adopted
point 2
Cañas, Pîslaru
“healthcare facilities”.
Compatible with 143 and
144
Annex I –
146 Franssen, Radtke
Falls if CA 27, 27a, 27b
+
↓
paragraph 1 –
adopted
point 3
Addition (ESI)
Annex I –
147 Trillet-Lenoir,
Falls if CA 27, 27a, 27b
+
↓
paragraph 1 –
Vedrenne, Brunet,
adopted
point 3
Cañas, Pîslaru
Addition (health
prevention); Compatible
with 146
Annex I –
148 Matthieu
Falls if CA 27, 27a, 27b
+
↓
paragraph 1 –
adopted
point 3
Addition (mandatory);
Compatible with 146, 147
Annex I –
150 Danielsson,
Falls if CA 27, 27a, 27b
↓
paragraph 1 –
Fritzon,
adopted
point 4 –
Blinkevičiūtė,
Addition (Public
point a
Vind, Brglez,
accessibility; emergency
Jongerius,
services.)
Gualmini,
Bischoff, Homs
Ginel, Durá
Ferrandis
Annex I –
149 Villumsen,
Falls if CA 27, 27a, 27b
+
↓
paragraph 1 –
Gusmão, Chaibi,
adopted
point 4 –
Arvanitis,
Addition (firefighters and
point a
Rodríguez Palop,
other emergency services).
Botenga
Compatible with 150
Annex I –
151 Franssen, Radtke
Falls if CA 27, 27a, 27b or
+
↓
paragraph 1 –
149 adopted
point 4 –
Addition (firefighters)
point a
Compatible with 150
Annex I –
152 Danielsson,
Falls if CA 27, 27a, 27b
+
↓
paragraph 1 –
Fritzon,
adopted
point 4 –
Blinkevičiūtė,
Deletion of last part in
point b
Vind, Brglez,
brackets
Jongerius,
(“before... ban”).
Gualmini,
Bischoff, Homs
Ginel, Durá
Ferrandis
Annex I –
153 Danielsson,
Fall if CA 27, 27a, 27b
+
↓
paragraph 1 –
Fritzon,
adopted
point 4 – lit.
Blinkevičiūtė,
Vote together
d
Vind, Brglez,
AM 153 covers first part of
Jongerius,
point 4 lit. d
Gualmini,
AM 154 covers second part
Bischoff, Homs
of point 4 lit. d
Ginel, Durá
Ferrandis
Annex I –
154 Danielsson,
paragraph 1 –
Fritzon,
point 4 – lit.
Blinkevičiūtė,
d a (new)
Vind, Brglez,
Jongerius,
Gualmini,
Bischoff, Homs
Ginel, Durá
Ferrandis
Paragraph
IMCO IMCO
Falls if 81, CA 27, 27a,
+
↓
(new)
10
27b, 143, 144 or 145
adopted Priority of some buildings
Covered in CA27
Recital A
ENVI A ENVI
Falls if CA 16 or CA 27,
+
↓
27a, 27b adopted Structural funds
Covered in CA 16, CA 27
Annex I –
155 Matthieu
Falls if CA 28, 28a, 28b
+
↓
paragraph 1 –
adopted
point 6
Zero asbestos contamination
Annex I –
156 Matthieu
Falls if CA 28, 28a, 28b
+
↓
paragraph 1 –
adopted
point 6 a
Safe storage
(new)
Annex I –
157 Trillet-Lenoir,
Falls if CA 28, 28a, 28b
+
↓
paragraph 1 –
Vedrenne, Brunet,
adopted
point 7
Cañas, Pîslaru
Awareness raising
campaigns
Annex I –
158 Villumsen,
Falls if CA 28, 28a, 28b
+
↓
paragraph 1 –
Matthieu,
adopted
point 8
Danielsson
Addition (victims
associations)
Annex II –
CA 29, Rapporteur
If adopted, 159, 160, 161,
+
+
point 1
29a, 29b
162, 164 and 163 fall
53/0/0
Article 3 –
New recital 2a (new): scope
paragraphs
directive
1,3,4
Art. 4(3)(a): addition “and
Article 4 –
the specific areas ...
paragraph 3
conducted”
Article 5 –
d: addition “the list of ...
paragraph 3
medical visits;
Art. 4(3)(d): addition “list
of workers on site ...”.
Art. 4(3)(e): addition
working hours
New lit. (g) - (ja)
New sub paragraph:
“notifications to be kept ...
minimum of 40 years”.
Art. 5(3): additions “safely”
removed; “when technically
feasible”; “asbestos-
containing materials ...”
Vote in bloc CAs 29, 29a,
29b
Annex II –
159 Danielsson,
Falls if CA 29, 29a, 29b
+
↓
paragraph 1 –
Fritzon,
adopted
point -1 b
Blinkevičiūtė,
Scope of directive
(new recital)
Vind, Brglez,
Jongerius,
Gualmini,
Bischoff, Homs
Ginel, Durá
Ferrandis
Annex II –
160 Franssen, Radtke
Falls if CA 29, 29a, 29b
+
↓
paragraph 1 –
adopted
point 2
Addition: “and planned
Directive
working hours”.
2009/148/EC
Article 4
paragraph 3
lit. e
Annex II –
161 Danielsson,
Falls if CA 29, 29a, 29b
+
↓
paragraph 1 –
Fritzon,
adopted
point 2
Blinkevičiūtė,
Strategy waste disposal
Directive
Vind, Brglez,
2009/148/EC
Jongerius,
Article 4 –
Gualmini,
paragraph 3 –
Bischoff, Homs
point j a
Ginel, Durá
(new)
Ferrandis
Annex II –
162 Danielsson,
Falls if CA 29, 29a, 29b
+
↓
paragraph 1 –
Fritzon,
adopted
point 2
Blinkevičiūtė,
Notifications stored 40
Directive
Vind, Brglez,
years
2009/148/EC
Jongerius,
Article 4
Gualmini,
paragraph 6
Bischoff, Homs
new
Ginel, Durá
Ferrandis
Annex II –
164 Lundgren
Falls if CA 29, 29a, 29b
-
↓
paragraph 1 –
adopted
point 3 –
Deletion “sealed or
Directive
covered”
2009/148/EC
Article 5
paragraph 3
Annex II –
163 Trillet-Lenoir,
Falls if CA 29, 29a, 29b or
+
↓
paragraph 1 –
Vedrenne, Brunet,
164 adopted
point 3 –
Cañas, Pîslaru
Priority of safe removal
paragraph 2
Directive
2009/148/EC
Article 5
paragraph –
new
paragraph
Annex II
CA 31, Rapporteur
If adopted, 165, 173, 174,
+
+
paragraph 1 –
31a, 31b
175 and annex ENVI 1 fall
48/0/5
point 12:
Art. 15(1): addition “before
Directive
the start of work”
2009/148/EC
Art. 15(3): addition “shall”
Article 15
Art. 16(1)(ca new) (point
paragraph 1
13): deletion “strenuous “.
and 3;
Point 15a (new): new
Article 16
Article 18c on Review every
paragraph 1 –
5 years and guidelines
point ca
Vote in bloc CAs 31, 31a,
And point
31b
15a – new for
new Article
18c
Annex II –
165 Danielsson,
Falls if CA 31, 31a, 31b
+
↓
point 5 –
Fritzon,
adopted
Directive
Blinkevičiūtė,
Review technological state
2009/148/EC
Vind, Brglez,
... of asbestos
Article 7 –
Jongerius,
identification...
Gualmini,
paragraph
Bischoff, Homs
(da)
Ginel, Durá
Ferrandis
Annex II –
166 Danielsson,
Falls if CA 30, 30a, 30b
+
↓
point 7 –
Fritzon,
adopted
Directive
Blinkevičiūtė,
Addition (reason to believe
2009/148/EC
Vind, Brglez,
...)
Article 10 –
Jongerius,
paragraph 1
Gualmini,
Bischoff, Homs
Ginel, Durá
Ferrandis
Annex II –
169 Trillet-Lenoir,
Falls if CA 30, 30a, 30b
+
↓
point 8
Vedrenne, Brunet,
adopted
Directive
Cañas, Pîslaru
Absence of asbestos not
2009/148/EC
guaranteed
Article 10 –
paragraph 2
Annex II –
167 Danielsson,
Falls if CA 30, 30a, 30b
+
↓
point 8 –
Fritzon,
adopted
Directive
Blinkevičiūtė,
Addition (equivalent... ban)
2009/148/EC
Vind, Brglez,
Article 11 –
Jongerius,
paragraph 1
Gualmini,
Bischoff, Homs
Ginel, Durá
Ferrandis
Annex II –
168 Villumsen,
Falls if CA 30, 30a, 30b
+
↓
point 8 –
Gusmão, Chaibi,
adopted
Directive
Arvanitis,
Addition (authority);
2009/148/EC
Rodríguez Palop,
Compatible with 167
Article 11 –
Botenga
paragraph 1
Annex II –
170 Franssen, Radtke
Falls if CA 30, 30a, 30b
+
↓
point 9
adopted
Directive
Addition (all possible)
2009/148/EC
Article 12 –
paragraph 1
Annex II –
171 Danielsson,
Falls if CA 30, 30a, 30b
+
↓
point 9 – 9a
Fritzon,
adopted
(new)
Blinkevičiūtė,
Spread of asbestos dust
Directive
Vind, Brglez,
2009/148/EC
Jongerius,
Article 12 –
Gualmini,
Bischoff, Homs
paragraph 1
Ginel, Durá
lit.c
Ferrandis
Annex II –
172 Danielsson,
Falls if CA 30, 30a, 30b
+
↓
paragraph 1
Fritzon,
adopted
Directive
Blinkevičiūtė,
Measurement of asbestos
2009/148/EC
Vind, Brglez,
fibres
Article 12 –
Jongerius,
paragraph 1
Gualmini,
lit. ca
Bischoff, Homs
Ginel, Durá
Ferrandis
Annex II –
173 Franssen, Radtke
Falls if CA 31, 31a, 31b
+
↓
paragraph 1 –
adopted
point 12
Addition (before start of
Directive
work)
2009/148/EC
Article 15 –
paragraph 1
Annex II –
174 Danielsson,
Falls if CA 31, 31a, 31b
+
↓
point 12 –
Fritzon,
adopted
paragraph 3
Blinkevičiūtė,
Addition (Shall)
Directive
Vind, Brglez,
2009/148/EC
Jongerius,
Article 15 –
Gualmini,
paragraph 3
Bischoff, Homs
Ginel, Durá
Ferrandis
Annex II –
175 Franssen, Radtke
Falls if CA 31, 31a, 31b
+
↓
point 13
adopted
Directive
Deletion (strenuous)
2009/148/EC
Article 16 –
paragraph 1 –
point ca
Annex II –
176 Danielsson,
Article 18 (2) to be
+
+
point 15 a
Fritzon,
replaced: health assessment
32/14/7
Directive
Blinkevičiūtė,
of worker; recommendations
2009/148/EC
Vind, Brglez,
in Annex I. Health records
Article 18 –
Jongerius,
kept for 40 years.
paragraph 2
Gualmini,
Bischoff, Homs
Ginel, Durá
Ferrandis
Annex II –
179 Trillet-Lenoir,
Addition (Register of all
+
+
point 17
Vedrenne, Brunet,
recognised cases; Annex 1b
46/0/7
Directive
Cañas, Pîslaru
indicative list)
2009/148/EC
Article 21 –
paragraph 3
Annex II –
CA 32 Rapporteur
If adopted, 180 and 181
+
+
point 17a
fall
53/0/0
(new)
Article 21a new:
Directive
information available to
2009/148/EC
firefighters and emergencies
Article 21 a
(new)
Annex II –
180 Villumsen,
Falls if CA 32 adopted
+
↓
point 17 a
Gusmão, Chaibi,
Information to firefighters
Directive
Arvanitis,
and emergency services
2009/148/EC
Rodríguez Palop,
Article 21 a
Botenga
(new)
Annex II –
181 Franssen, Radtke
Falls if CA 32 or 180
+
↓
point 17 b
adopted
Directive
Information to firefighters
2009/148/EC
Article 21 b
(new)
Annex II –
CA 33, Rapporteur
If adopted, 182, 183, 184,
+
+
point 18
33a, 33b
185 and 186 fall
50/0/3
Directive
Para 3: addition “and
2009/148/EC
certified”, “carried out ...
(new) Annex
body”, “laws ... practices”.
1a – point 3
Para 4 (new) point ca(new):
and 4
training certificate,
language.
Para 5 point b: addition “as
well ... exposure “.
Vote in bloc CAs 33, 33a,
33b
Annex II –
182 Danielsson,
Falls if CA 33, 33a, 33b
+
↓
point 18 –
Fritzon,
adopted
Directive
Blinkevičiūtė,
Addition (certification of
2009/148/EC
Vind, Brglez,
training providers)
(new) Annex
Jongerius,
1a – point 3
Gualmini,
Bischoff, Homs
Ginel, Durá
Ferrandis
Annex II –
183 Matthieu
Falls if CA 33, 33a, 33b
+
↓
point 18
adopted
Directive
Mandatory test)
2009/148/EC
(new) Annex
1a – point 3 a
(new)
Annex II –
184 Danielsson,
Falls if CA 33, 33a, 33b
+
↓
paragraph 1 –
Fritzon,
adopted
point 18 –
Blinkevičiūtė,
Language training
Directive
Vind, Brglez,
2009/148/EC
Jongerius,
(new) Annex
Gualmini,
1a – point 4 –
Bischoff, Homs
lit. c a (new)
Ginel, Durá
Ferrandis
Annex II –
185 Matthieu
Falls if CA 33, 33a, 33b,
+
↓
point 18
183 or 184 adopted
Directive
Confirmation that test
2009/148/EC
passed
(new) Annex
1a – point 4 –
lit. d a (new)
Annex II –
186 Matthieu
Falls if CA 33, 33a, 33b or
+
↓
point 18
184 adopted
Directive
Addition (secondary
2009/148/EC
exposure)
(new) Annex
1a – point 5 –
lit. b
Annex II –
CA 33A Rapporteur
If adopted, 177, 178, 187,
+
+
point 18
188, 189, 191 and 190 fall
42/0/11
Directive
Enumeration of Asbestos-
2009/148/EC
related diseases
(new) Annex
191 and 192 identical.
1b –
introductory
part
Annex II –
177 Trillet-Lenoir,
Falls if CA 33A adopted
+
↓
point 17
Vedrenne, Brunet,
“ ... all cases of
Directive
Pîslaru
mesothelioma;
2009/148/EC
Article 21 –
paragraph 1
Annex II –
178 Trillet-Lenoir,
Falls if CA 33A adopted
+
↓
point 17
Vedrenne, Brunet,
“ ... diagnosed
Directive
Pîslaru
mesothelioma” instead
2009/148/EC
asbestos-related diseases)
Article 21 –
paragraph 2
Annex II –
187 Trillet-Lenoir,
Falls if 184 or CA 33A
+
↓
point 18
Vedrenne, Brunet,
adopted
Directive
Cañas, Pîslaru
List of diseases
2009/148/EC
(new) Annex
1b –
introductory
part
Annex II –
188 Kopcińska
Falls if 184 or CA 33A
-
↓
point 18
adopted
Directive
“ovarian” deleted
2009/148/EC
(new) Annex
1b – indent 6
Annex II –
189 Kopcińska
Falls if CA 33A adopted
-
↓
point 18
“colorectal” deleted
Directive
2009/148/EC
(new) Annex
1b – indent 7
Annex II –
191 Kopcińska
Fall if CA 33A adopted
-
↓
point 18
Identical
192 Trillet-Lenoir,
Directive
“stomach” deleted
Vedrenne, Brunet,
2009/148/EC
Cañas, Pîslaru
(new) Annex
1b – indent 8
Annex II –
190 Trillet-Lenoir,
Falls if CA 33A adopted
+
↓
point 18
Vedrenne, Brunet,
Addition: Pharyngeal,
Directive
Cañas, Pîslaru
colorectal and stomach
2009/148/EC
cancer as an additional
(new) Annex
category of cancer with
1b – indent 7
positive associations
according to IARC.
Annex III –
193 Matthieu
Falls if CA 24, 24a adopted
0
↓
Paragraph 1 –
Addition “first and second-
point 1
hand exposure to asbestos “
Annex III
CA 34, Rapporteur
If adopted, 194, 196, 195,
+
+
Paragraph 1 –
34a
IMCO 8 and ENVI 19 fall
45/1/7
point 3 and 4
Point 3: additions “national
... ombudsperson”; “as well
... procedures”.
Point 4: “reversal of
burden”;addition “for
example ... presumed “.
Vote in bloc CAs 34, 34a
Annex III –
194 Danielsson,
Falls if CA 34, 34a adopted
+
↓
paragraph 1 –
Fritzon,
Support for exchange good
point 3
Blinkevičiūtė,
practices
Vind, Brglez,
Jongerius,
Gualmini,
Bischoff, Homs
Ginel, Durá
Ferrandis
Annex III –
196 Villumsen,
Falls if CA 34, 34a adopted
+
↓
paragraph 1 –
Gusmão, Chaibi,
“reversal” of burden
point 4
Arvanitis,
(instead revision)
Rodríguez Palop,
Botenga
Annex III –
195 Danielsson,
Falls if CA 34, 34a or 196
+
↓
paragraph 1 –
Fritzon,
adopted
point 4
Blinkevičiūtė,
Addition (“for example...
Vind, Brglez,
presumed).
Jongerius,
Compatible with 196
Gualmini,
Bischoff, Homs
Ginel, Durá
Ferrandis
Annex IV –
197 Trillet-Lenoir,
Result of screening in
+
+
Directive
Vedrenne, Brunet,
certificate
46/0/7
2010/31/EC
Cañas, Pîslaru
Article 7–
subparagraph
8
Paragraph
IMCO 8 IMCO
Falls if CA 18, 18a, 18b,
+
↓
(new)
18c, 18d, 79, 81, CA 28,
28a, 28b or CA 34, 34a
adopted establish guidance on
national asbestos removal
plans, one-stop-shop as
contact for victims
Covered in CA 18 (18a,
18b), CA28, CA34
Annex IV –
198 Matthieu
Falls if CA 16 adopted
+
↓
Directive
Public financial support
2010/31/EC
mechanism for owners
Article 7–
subparagraph
8 a (new)
Annex V –
CA 35 Rapporteur
If adopted, 199, 200, 201,
+
+
points 1, 2, 3,
202, 203, 204, 205, 206,
45/0/8
4, 5, 7
207, 208, IMCO 1, IMCO
1 a, IMCO 1 b, IMCO 1 c,
IMCO 1 d, IMCO 1 f,
IMCO 1 g and IMCO 1 h
fall Point 1: addition
“constructed before 2005 or
... ban “.
Point 2: addition “a list ...
body”.
Point 3: additions “certified
... results “; “the owner
and”; “This competent
body”; “of ... and”;
“including on”; “... ESI ...”.
Point 4: addition “their
current... occupants”; “and
... asbestos “.
Point 4a new: “the
certificate ... screenings”.
Point 5: addition “and ...
tenants”.
Point 7: reformulated.
Annex V –
199 Trillet-Lenoir,
Falls if CA 35 adopted
+
↓
Paragraph 1
Vedrenne, Brunet,
Addition (before 2005) Cañas, Pîslaru
Annex V –
200 Trillet-Lenoir,
Falls if CA 35 adopted
+
↓
paragraph 2
Vedrenne, Brunet,
Addition (list of certified
Cañas, Pîslaru
operators
Annex V –
201 Trillet-Lenoir,
Falls if CA 35 adopted
+
↓
paragraph 3
Vedrenne, Brunet,
Additions (operator,
Cañas, Pîslaru
competent bodies)
Annex V –
202 Franssen, Radtke
Falls if CA 35 adopted
+
↓
paragraph 3
Addition (EU funds);
Compatible with 201
Annex V –
203 Trillet-Lenoir,
Falls if CA 35 adopted
+
↓
paragraph 4
Vedrenne, Brunet,
Details on asbestos
Cañas, Pîslaru
certificates
Annex V –
204 Danielsson,
Falls if CA 35 adopted
+
↓
paragraphh 4
Fritzon,
Addition (Information on
Blinkevičiūtė,
areas); Compatible with 203
Vind, Brglez,
Jongerius,
Gualmini,
Bischoff, Homs
Ginel, Durá
Ferrandis
Annex V –
205 Trillet-Lenoir,
Falls if CA 35 adopted
+
↓
paragraph 4 a
Vedrenne, Brunet,
Investigation
(new)
Cañas, Pîslaru
Annex V –
206 Trillet-Lenoir,
Falls if CA 35 adopted
+
↓
paragraph 4 b
Vedrenne, Brunet,
Certificate 3 years valid
(new)
Cañas, Pîslaru
Annex V –
207 Trillet-Lenoir,
Falls if CA 35 adopted
+
↓
paragraph 4 c
Vedrenne, Brunet,
Certificate annexed to sales
(new)
Cañas, Pîslaru
agreement
Annex V –
208 Trillet-Lenoir,
Falls if CA 35 or 207
+
↓
paragraph 7
Vedrenne, Brunet,
adopted Cañas, Pîslaru
Liability in case of non-
compliance
Paragraph
IMCO 1 IMCO
Falls if CA 35 adopted
+
↓
(new)
Legislative proposal for
heading
mandatory screening,
minimum requirements for
locating, based on art.
169(3) and art. 114(1)
TFEU
Covered CA35
Paragraph
IMCO 1 IMCO
Falls if 108, 127, 128, 129,
+
↓
(new)
a
167, 168, CA 35, 200 or
201 adopted Detailed description of
screening
Covered CA35
Paragraph
IMCO 1 IMCO
Falls if CA 35 or 201
+
↓
(new)
b
adopted Validation by certificate
Covered CA35
Paragraph
IMCO 1 IMCO
Falls if CA 35 or 201
+
↓
(new)
c
adopted Communication to national
body
Covered CA35
Paragraph
IMCO 1 IMCO
Falls if CA 27, 27a, 27b or
+
↓
(new)
d
CA 35 adopted
Part 1 (guidance on
national registers) covered
in CA27.
Part 2 (access to registers
free of charge): integrated
in CA27 (27b)
Part 3 (certificate to be
annexed):
Covered in CA35
Paragraph
IMCO 1 IMCO
Split vote (S&D)
+
+
(new)
e
Part 1
53/0/0
Whole text except ”in the
short term”.
Compatible with CA35
Part 2
-
-
Falls if IMCO 1 e Part 1
23/30/0
NOT adopted addition of “in the short
term”
Paragraph
IMCO 1 IMCO
Falls if 197, CA 35, 202,
+
↓
(new)
f
203, 204, 205, 206 or 207
adopted Details on certificate
Covered CA35
Paragraph
IMCO 1 IMCO
Falls if CA 35 adopted
+
↓
(new)
g
Addition: Renewal of
certificate every 5 years.
In CA 35 (4a): no date
indicated
Paragraph
IMCO 1 IMCO
Falls if CA 35 adopted
+
↓
(new)
h
Fines: everything covered in
CA35
except addition “fines could
be allocated by MS to adhoc
funds to finance ...
problems”
Point (new)
ENVI 3 ENVI
Worldwide exposure of 125
+
+
million people but
45/6/2
Could be potentially
confusing as EMPL Recital
C only gives an EU
perspective (EU figures).
Point (new)
ENVI ENVI
Split vote (EPP)
-
-
22
Part 1
24/25/4
“Acknowledges ... for
health”
Addition: WHO on drinking
water, risks of water
containing asbestos, more
research, monitoring,
preventive measures
Part 2
+
+
“Recalls that ... to human
39/13/1
health;”
Point (new)
ENVI ENVI
Addition: State of drinking
+
+
23
water distribution network,
51/0/2
including a removal plan,
asbestos-cement pipes,
WHO recommendation
Point (new)
ENVI ENVI
Falls if CA 18, 18a, 18b,
+
↓
24
18c, 18d or 141 adopted Asbestos removal from
buildings
Covered in CA18, AM141
Point (new)
ENVI ENVI
Falls if 78 adopted
+
+
25 part 1
Addition Part 1: Increase in
47/0/6
construction work more
exposure (AM 78)
Point (new)
ENVI ENVI
Addition Part 2: substitution
+
+
25 part 2
with energy efficient
48/0/4
materials
Point (new)
ENVI ENVI
Falls if CA 27, 27a, 27b,
+
↓
27
143, 144 or 145 adopted Public schools, exposure for
childrens and students,
school buildings are a
priority
Covered in CA27
Point (new)
ENVI ENVI
Falls if 74 or 119 adopted
+
↓
29
More information on
population exposure-contact
with commercial products
containing asbestos.
Covered by AM74 and AM
119
Point (new)
ENVI ENVI
Falls if CA 17 or 71
+
↓
31
adopted Number of inspections, ILO
objectives
Covered in CA17, AM 71
Point (new)
ENVI ENVI
Falls if CA 16 or 142
+
↓
33
adopted MS to share best practices
on reporting.
Covered in CA16
Point (new)
ENVI ENVI
Falls if CA 24, 24a, 122,
+
↓
34
121 or 123 adopted Part 1: aspect on “Women
also exposed” integrated in
CA24 (24a, 19d).
Part 2: revise legislation to
protect women: covered
Point (new)
ENVI ENVI
Falls if CA 19, 19a, 19b,
+
↓
36
CA 18, 18a, 18b, 18c, 18d,
81 or 90 adopted Call for revision of asbestos
directive, substances in
detail listed.
covered in CA18b, CA19
Point (new)
ENVI ENVI
Split vote (S&D)
+
+
37
Part 1
45/6/2
Whole text without “when
they have failed to take all
appropriate measures ... to
prevent asbestos exposure;”
Part 2
-
-
Falls if ENVI 37 Part 1
22/25/6
NOT adopted addition “when they have
failed ... to prevent asbestos
exposure;”
Point (new)
ENVI ENVI
Addition: Call on COMM to
+
+
38
support dissemination of
52/1/0
information on safe removal
Point (new)
ENVI ENVI
Falls if CA 27, 27a, 27b
+
↓
41
adopted Synergies between a
strategy, circular economy,
existing initiatives.
Covered in CA27
Point (new)
ENVI ENVI
Falls if CA 26, 26a adopted
+
↓
42 Part
Part 1 (“recalls ... recovery
1
of waste”): covered partly
in CA26
Point (new)
ENVI ENVI
Part 2 addition:
+
+
42 Part
“encourages... synergies
51/0/2
2
with database set up ECHA
.... become waste “.
Point (new)
ENVI ENVI
Falls if CA 16 or 80
+
↓
45
adopted Waste management of
asbestos; precautionary
principle
Covered in CA16, AM80
Point (new)
ENVI ENVI
Falls if CA 16 or 67
+
↓
46
adopted Call on COMM to promote
centres for treatment and
inertisation; support of
R&D
Covered in CA16
Point (new)
ENVI ENVI
Falls if CA 16 or 83
+
↓
47
adopted Removal to be supported by
EU structural funds.
Covered in CA16
Point (new)
ENVI ENVI
Falls if CA 26, 26a or 136
+
↓
48
adopted Against dumping in
developing countries.
Covered in CA26
Point (new)
ENVI ENVI
Falls if CA 26, 26a or 87
+
↓
49
adopted Worldwide eradication.
Covered in CA26
Point (new)
ENVI ENVI
Falls if CA 26, 26a or 134
+
↓
50
adopted Global prohibition of
asbestos
Covered in CA26
Point (new)
ENVI ENVI
Part 1 addition: “recalls ...
+
+
51 Part
16 European countries use
53/0/0
1
asbestos ... export it”
Point (new)
ENVI ENVI
Falls if CA 26, 26a or 135
+
↓
51 Part
adopted
2
Part 2 addition: “urges
COMM ... neighbourhood
policy ... Sea”: covered in
CA26
Point (new)
ENVI ENVI
Falls if CA 26, 26a or 87
+
↓
52
adopted Chrysotile asbestos in
Annex III Rotterdam
Convention
Covered in CA26
Point (new)
ENVI ENVI
Falls if CA 26, 26a or 134
+
↓
53
adopted Asbestos not to be produced
in EU; global eradication;
mandate to COMM for
negotiations on UN Treaty
for Business and Human
Rights.
Partly in CA 26
Paragraph
annex ENVI
Falls if 84 or CA 31, 31a,
+
↓
annex (new)
ENVI 1
31b adopted Development of models to
detect, monitor ...
Covered in CA8, CA31
(31a)
Paragraph
annex ENVI
Falls if CA 18, 18a, 18b,
+
↓
annex (new)
ENVI 3
18c, 18d or 82 adopted Registration of
mesothelioma
Covered in CA18
Paragraph
annex ENVI
Falls if CA 18, 18a, 18b,
+
↓
annex (new)
ENVI 5
18c, 18d adopted Research and integration of
EU wide plan
Covered in CA18 (18b)
Paragraph
annex ENVI
Falls if CA 26, 26a, 136 or
+
↓
annex (new)
ENVI 7
137 adopted EU strategic plan to
increase influence at global
level, fight against asbestos
Covered in CA26
Paragraph
annex ENVI
Falls if CA 20, 20a, CA 18,
+
↓
annex (new)
ENVI 8
18a, 18b, 18c, 18d, 81 or 84
adopted EU framework for national
asbestos removal strategies,
registers, certificates,
screening, landfills, ...
Covered in CA18, CA20,
AMs 81 and 84
Paragraph
annex ENVI
Falls if CA 27, 27a, 27b,
+
↓
annex (new)
ENVI 9
143, 144 or 145 adopted Roadmap to asbestos free
workplaces
Covered in CA27 (2)
Paragraph
annex ENVI
Addition: Monitoring...of
+
+
annex (new)
ENVI
asbestos in atmosphere
40/13/0
10
Paragraph
annex ENVI
Falls if CA 16, 67, CA 18,
+
↓
annex (new)
ENVI
18a, 18b, 18c, 18d, 83, 146
11
or 147 adopted Funding instruments
Covered in CA16, CA18
Paragraph
annex ENVI
Falls if CA 28, 28a, 28b or
+
↓
annex (new)
ENVI
158 adopted
13
Involvement of social
partners and other
stakeholders
Covered in CA28 (28b)
Citation 6 b
2 Danielsson,
“having ...Article 168
+
+
(new)
Fritzon,
TFEU”
46/6/1
Blinkevičiūtė,
Vind, Brglez,
Jongerius,
Gualmini,
Bischoff, Homs
Ginel, Durá
Ferrandis
Citation 6 a
1 Trillet-Lenoir,
Falls if 2 adopted
+
↓
(new)
Vedrenne, Brunet,
“having ...Article 168(1)
Cañas, Pîslaru
TFEU”
Citation 12
3 Lundgren
Deletion
-
-
11/42/0
Citation 13
4 Lundgren
Deletion
-
-
11/42/0
Citation 20 a
5 Villumsen,
Addition resolution 2020
+
+
(new)
Gusmão, Chaibi,
chemical strategy
47/4/2
Arvanitis,
Rodríguez Palop,
Botenga
Citation 29 a
6 Danielsson,
Addition “conquering
+
+
(new)
Fritzon,
cancer ...”
51/0/2
Blinkevičiūtė,
Vind, Brglez,
Jongerius,
Gualmini,
Bischoff, Homs
Ginel, Durá
Ferrandis
Citation 29 b
7 Danielsson,
Addition “WHO...”
+
+
(new)
Fritzon,
51/0/2
Blinkevičiūtė,
Vind, Brglez,
Jongerius,
Gualmini,
Bischoff, Homs
Ginel, Durá
Ferrandis
Citation 29 c
8 Danielsson,
Addition “SDG goal 3...”
+
+
(new)
Fritzon,
49/1/2
Blinkevičiūtė,
Vind, Brglez,
Jongerius,
Gualmini,
Bischoff, Homs
Ginel, Durá
Ferrandis
Recital -A
9 Trillet-Lenoir,
Addition high level human
+
+
(new)
Vedrenne, Brunet,
health protection
51/0/2
Cañas, Pîslaru
Point (new)
ENVI 2 ENVI
Falls if 9 adopted
+
↓
Addition “High level health
protection“;
Covered in substance
Recital B
CA 1 Rapporteur
If adopted, 10 and annex
+
+
ENVI 4 fall
53/0/0
AM 10 incorporated;
asbestos +tobacco higher
risk lung cancer
Recital C a
10 Trillet-Lenoir,
Falls if CA 1 adopted
+
↓
(new)
Vedrenne, Brunet,
Addition combination with
Cañas, Pîslaru
tobacco
Paragraph
annex ENVI
Falls if CA 17, 119, CA 1
+
↓
annex (new)
ENVI 4
or 10 adopted EU wide information
campaigns to inform on
asbestos; tobacco and
asbestos.
covered in AM 119
Recital D
CA 2 Rapporteur
If adopted, 11, 12, 17,
+
+
ENVI 5 and IMCO C fall
53/0/0
IARC; carcinogenity of
asbestos
Recital D
11 Trillet-Lenoir,
Falls if CA 2 adopted
+
↓
Vedrenne, Brunet,
IARC: asbestos
Cañas, Pîslaru
carcinogenic
Recital D a
12 Danielsson,
Falls if CA 2 adopted
+
↓
(new)
Fritzon,
Cancer risk, low level of
Blinkevičiūtė,
exposure
Vind, Brglez,
Jongerius,
Gualmini,
Bischoff, Homs
Ginel, Durá
Ferrandis
Recital E
CA 3, Rapporteur
If adopted, 13, 14, ENVI
+
+
(new), E
3a
13, ENVI 32, ENVI 5,
53/0/0
IMCO 2, 27, ENVI 28,
ENVI 18 Part 1, IMCO A,
IMCO B part 1 and IMCO
F fall New paragraph in recital E
on EU ban since 2005.
Worldwide use, different
groups affected, long
latency
Vote in bloc CAs 3, 3a
Recital D b
13 Danielsson,
Falls if CA 3, 3a adopted
+
↓
(new)
Fritzon,
Groups at risk
Blinkevičiūtė,
Vind, Brglez,
Jongerius,
Gualmini,
Bischoff, Homs
Ginel, Durá
Ferrandis
Recital E a
14 Trillet-Lenoir,
Falls if CA 3, 3a adopted
+
↓
(new)
Vedrenne, Brunet,
Long latency Cañas, Pîslaru
Point (new)
ENVI 4 ENVI
Part 1: Worldwide 250.000
+
+
Part 1
deaths (IMCO B
51/0/2
redundant); in EMPL recital
A only the EU perspective
(EU figures) covered;
death rate accelerates.
Point (new)
ENVI 4 ENVI
Falls if CA 23, 23a, 23b or
+
↓
part 2
13 adopted Part 2: vulnerable groups
have limited access: covered
in CA 23
Point (new)
ENVI ENVI
Falls if CA 3, 3a or 13
+
↓
13
adopted Addition: environmental and
health inequality, left behind
among vulnerable groups.
Covered in AM 13, CA3,
CA18 (5)
Point (new)
ENVI ENVI
Falls if 116, 119, CA 27,
+
↓
32
27a, 27b, 181, CA 3, 3a or
13 adopted Some groups of workers
more exposed;
information to firefighters.
Covered in CA3, CA27, AMs
13, 116, 119, 181
Recital F
CA 4 Rapporteur
If adopted, 16, 18, 15 and
+
+
IMCO C fall
52/0/1
Not recognised as
occupational disease; role
of trade unions and victims’
organisations in recognition
Recital F
16 Danielsson,
Falls if CA 4 adopted
+
↓
Fritzon,
“Many cases”
Blinkevičiūtė,
Vind, Brglez,
Jongerius,
Gualmini,
Bischoff, Homs
Ginel, Durá
Ferrandis
Recital F a
17 Villumsen, Chaibi,
Falls if CA 2 adopted
+
↓
(new)
Gusmão, Arvanitis,
Airborne fibres Rodríguez Palop,
Botenga
Point (new)
ENVI 5 ENVI
Falls if 91, CA 2, CA 3, 3a
+
↓
or 17 adopted Carcinogen group 1;
inhalation of fibres ...
recognised as health
hazard; A non-threshold
carcinogen
(covered in CA 2, AM 17,
CA3, AM91)
Recital F b
18 Danielsson,
Falls if CA 4 adopted
+
↓
(new)
Fritzon,
Victims associations
Blinkevičiūtė,
Vind, Brglez,
Jongerius,
Gualmini,
Bischoff, Homs
Ginel, Durá
Ferrandis
Point (new)
ENVI ENVI
Falls if CA 28, 28a, 28b,
+
↓
19
CA 23, 23a, 23b, CA 24,
24a, 118, 158, CA 34, 34a,
194 or 18 adopted Involvement social partners,
victims organisations
Covered in CA23, CA24,
CA28, CA34
Recital F
15 Trillet-Lenoir,
Falls if CA 4, 16 or 18
+
↓
Vedrenne, Brunet,
adopted Cañas, Pîslaru
Addition (physical suffering,
victims associations,
recognition of occupational
diseases)
Recital G
CA 5 Rapporteur
If adopted, 19, 20, 21, 125,
+
+
ENVI 10, IMCO 3, ENVI
53/0/0
12, ENVI 40, IMCO F and
IMCO G fall Asbestos in (abandoned)
buildings, and it’s safe
removal, renovation, more
mesothelioma, vincinity, old
building stock in EU,
environmental exposure
levels can reach
occupational, support
research to environmental
exposure:
COMP with elements of
ENVI, IMCO
Recital G
19 Trillet-Lenoir,
Falls if CA 5 adopted
+
↓
Vedrenne, Brunet,
Cañas, Pîslaru
Recital G a
20 Matthieu
Falls if CA 5 adopted
+
↓
(new)
Handling materials such as
roofs, ...
Recital G b
21 Matthieu
Falls if CA 5 adopted
+
↓
(new)
Health effects due to more
environmental exposure
Paragraph 19
125 Matthieu
Falls if CA 5 adopted
+
↓
i (new)
Addition: “call for localised
approach to prevention,
registers ..., of diseases, ...”
Point (new)
ENVI ENVI
Falls if CA 5 or 21 adopted
+
↓
10
Part 1: population living in
vicinity of industrial sites;
deterioration of building
stock in EU - covered by
addition to CA5.
Part 2: stresses ....
mesothelioma” covered by
CA5, AM21
Paragraph
IMCO 3 IMCO
Falls if CA 9, 9b or CA 5
+
↓
(new)
adopted Part: Call on COMM for
legal procedure for asbestos
removal; campaigns; social
fair transition: covered
CA9b (Ic)
Part: CA 5 enlarged with
addition abandoned
buildings.
Point (new)
ENVI ENVI
Falls if CA 5 or 21 adopted
+
↓
12
Part 1: Underestimation of
environmental exposure:
covered CA5, AM 21: falls
Part 2: CA 5 enlarged with
ENVI element
Point (new)
ENVI ENVI
Falls if CA 15, 15a, 58, 59,
+
↓
40
CA 9, 9b or CA 5 adopted Safe handling, removal ... in
waste stream to be
developed by COMM in
CA5, CA6a, CA15(15a)
Recital new
ENVI B ENVI
Addition: Fundamental
+
+
Rights Charta
47/6/0
Recitals Ga
CA 6, Rapporteur
If adopted, 22, 23, ENVI
+
+
(new), Gb (
6a
39, annex ENVI 6, IMCO
53/0/0
new)
2, ENVI 44, 29 and 44 fall Ga: Landfills, avoid
releasing in environment,
methods for inertisation.
Gb: foster research and
innovation.
Vote in bloc CAs 6, 6a
Recital G c
22 Trillet-Lenoir,
Falls if CA 6, 6a adopted
+
↓
(new)
Vedrenne, Brunet,
Landfill Cañas, Pîslaru
Recital G d
23 Danielsson,
Falls if CA 6, 6a or 22
+
↓
(new)
Fritzon,
adopted
Blinkevičiūtė,
Landfill, next generation,
Vind, Brglez,
cost-effective methods
Jongerius,
Gualmini,
Bischoff, Homs
Ginel, Durá
Ferrandis
Point (new)
ENVI ENVI
Falls if CA 6, 6a, 22 or 23
+
↓
39
adopted Asbestos in landfills.
Covered in CA6
Paragraph
annex ENVI
Falls if CA 16, CA 6, 6a or
+
↓
annex (new)
ENVI 6
23 adopted Establish centres for
treatment and inertisation
Covered CA6, CA16 (3b)
Paragraph
IMCO 2 IMCO
Falls if CA 16, CA 20, 20a,
+
↓
(new)
CA 22, 22a, CA 9, 9b, CA
3, 3a or CA 6, 6a adopted Call on COMM for details
on impact assessment
No reference to IA but
details covered in CA6a,
CA16, CA20+20a (12d),
CA22 +22a and CA3 (3a),
CA9b(Ic)
Recital G e
24 Danielsson,
Falls if CA 18, 18a, 18b,
+
↓
(new)
Fritzon,
18c, 18d adopted
Blinkevičiūtė,
Certification of buildings,
Vind, Brglez,
public register in Poland
Jongerius,
Gualmini,
Bischoff, Homs
Ginel, Durá
Ferrandis
Point (new)
ENVI ENVI
Falls if CA 18, 18a, 18b,
+
↓
17
18c, 18d, 84, 98, CA 25,
25a, 25b, 142, CA 27, 27a,
27b, 174 or 24 adopted EU framework public
registers.
Covered in CA 18, CA 25,
CA 27
Point (new)
ENVI ENVI
Falls if CA 15, 15a or CA
+
↓
44
6, 6a adopted Asbestos waste to be made
inert in CA6, CA16.
ENVI Call on COMM to
propose revision of EU
waste legislation in CA 15
included
Recital H
CA 7 Rapporteur
If adopted, 25 and 26 fall
+
+
ECHA, RAC opinion to
51/0/2
reduce OEL
Recital H
25 Trillet-Lenoir,
Falls if CA 7 adopted
+
↓
Vedrenne, Brunet,
Addition RAC opinion Cañas, Pîslaru
Recital H a
26 Lundgren
Falls if CA 7 or 25 adopted
+
↓
(new)
RAC opinion
Recital H b
27 Villumsen,
Falls if CA 3, 3a adopted
+
↓
(new)
Gusmão, Chaibi,
Asbestos used worldwide
Arvanitis,
and in daily life
Rodríguez Palop,
Botenga
Point (new)
ENVI ENVI
Falls if CA 3, 3a or 27
+
↓
28
adopted Asbestos in many everyday
products (detailed aspects)
Covered (less detailed) in
CA3, AM27
Recital K
CA 10 Rapporteur
If adopted, 28, ENVI 20,
+
+
38, 52 and IMCO K fall
53/0/0
Beating Cancer Plan.
Recital H c
28 Trillet-Lenoir,
Falls if ENVI 28 or CA 10
+
↓
(new)
Vedrenne, Brunet,
adopted Cañas, Pîslaru
Improving early diagnosis,
..., priorities of Cancer
Plan.
Identical with 52)
Recital H d
29 Danielsson,
Falls if CA 6, 6a adopted
+
↓
(new)
Fritzon,
Lack of real-time alert and
Blinkevičiūtė,
measurement technology
Vind, Brglez,
Jongerius,
Gualmini,
Bischoff, Homs
Ginel, Durá
Ferrandis
Point (new)
ENVI ENVI
Falls if CA 15, 15a or CA
+
↓
20
10 adopted Health in all policies, EU
initiatives
Covered in CA10, CA15
Recital I
CA 8 Rapporteur
If adopted, 30 and 31 fall
+
+
Asbestos related cancer;
53/0/0
prevention
Recital I
30 Villumsen,
Falls if CA 8 adopted
+
↓
Gusmão, Chaibi,
80% of diseases is asbestos
Arvanitis,
related
Rodríguez Palop,
Botenga
Recital I
31 Trillet-Lenoir,
Falls if CA 8 or 30 adopted
+
↓
Vedrenne, Brunet,
Addition (public health
Cañas, Pîslaru
investments). Compatible
with 30.
Recital I a
32 Matthieu
Falls if CA 9, 9b adopted
+
↓
(new)
EP Resolution affordable
housing
Recital I b
33 Danielsson,
Falls if CA 9, 9b or CA 9a
+
↓
(new)
Fritzon,
adopted
Blinkevičiūtė,
UN Special Rapporteur on
Vind, Brglez,
Right to adequate housing
Jongerius,
Gualmini,
Bischoff, Homs
Ginel, Durá
Ferrandis
Recital I c
34 Danielsson,
Falls if CA 9, 9b adopted
+
↓
(new)
Fritzon,
EU funds and (non-)
Blinkevičiūtė,
compliance
Vind, Brglez,
Jongerius,
Gualmini,
Bischoff, Homs
Ginel, Durá
Ferrandis
Recital I d
35 Matthieu
Falls if CA 9, 9b adopted
+
↓
(new)
WHO
Recital I e
36 Matthieu
Falls if CA 9, 9b adopted
+
↓
(new)
Mandatory removal for
quality housing
Point (new)
ENVI ENVI
Falls if 77, CA 9, 9b, 141,
+
↓
35
CA 27, 27a, 27b, 32 or 36
adopted Citizens to receive
protection in living spaces,
COMM to introduce
screening.
Covered in CA9, CA 27;
AMs 32,36,77,141
Recital I f
37 Trillet-Lenoir,
Falls if CA 9, 9b adopted
+
↓
(new)
Vedrenne, Brunet,
Financial burden for owners Cañas, Pîslaru
Paragraph
IMCO 6 IMCO
Falls if CA 16, 67, 83, 117,
+
↓
(new)
CA 9, 9b, 126 or 37
adopted EU structural and
investment funds,
Access to financial support:
covered in CA9 (Ic), CA16
Recital K
38 Trillet-Lenoir,
Falls if CA 10 adopted
+
↓
Vedrenne, Brunet,
“annual” occupational
Cañas, Pîslaru
deaths.
“further” reduce
Recital L
39 Lundgren
Deletion (Pillar)
-
-
12/40/0
Recital L a
40 Matthieu
Withdrawn
0
↓
(new)
Social Pillar
Point (new)
ENVI 1 ENVI
Part 1 “recalls that the
+
no vote
part 1
Social Pillar ... at the
workplace;”:
Redundant and inadmissible
as Pillar already covered by
recital L
Point (new)
ENVI 1 ENVI
Falls if CA 28, 28a, 28b or
+
↓
part 2
155 adopted Part 2 “stresses ...; .... zero
pollution ...; .... toxic-free
environment”:
covered in CA 28
Recital L b
41 Zambelli, Lizzi
Asbestos difficult to dispose,
-
-
(new)
costly, trained staff
11/40/0
Point (new)
ENVI ENVI
Falls if CA 19, 19a, 19b,
+
↓
30
CA 16, CA 20, 20a, 65, 94,
175 or 41 adopted Unsafe workers’ working
conditions impact society to
risk of asbestos exposure;
ensure high level protection
of workers, by providing
PPE.
Covered in CA16, CA19,
CA20
Recital La
CA 11 Rapporteur
If adopted, 42, 43, 45, 46,
+
+
(new)
annex ENVI 12 and ENVI
46/0/7
18 Part 1 fall
Recital L c
42 Danielsson,
Falls if CA 11 adopted
+
↓
(new)
Fritzon,
Inspections; labour
Blinkevičiūtė,
inspectorates
Vind, Brglez,
Jongerius,
Gualmini,
Bischoff, Homs
Ginel, Durá
Ferrandis
Recital L d
43 Danielsson,
Falls if CA 11 adopted
+
↓
(new)
Fritzon,
Sanctions
Blinkevičiūtė,
Vind, Brglez,
Jongerius,
Gualmini,
Bischoff, Homs
Ginel, Durá
Ferrandis
Recital L e
44 Trillet-Lenoir,
Falls if CA 6, 6a adopted
+
↓
(new)
Vedrenne, Brunet,
Fostering research and
Cañas, Pîslaru
innovation
Point (new)
ENVI ENVI
Falls if CA 16, 98 or 44
+
↓
26
adopted
R&D to ensure highest
possible worker protection
and of local population,
improve reliability of
asbestos screening
Covered in CA16
Paragraph
annex ENVI
Falls if CA 19, 19a, 19b,
+
↓
annex (new)
ENVI 2
78, CA 28, 28a, 28b, 108 or
44 adopted Definition of models for
monitoring asbestos fibres
Covered in CA19 (19b),
CA28
Recital L f
45 Villumsen,
Falls if CA 11 adopted
+
↓
(new)
Danielsson
COVID, OSH, public health
Recital L g
46 Matthieu
Falls if CA 11 or 45
+
↓
(new)
adopted COVID, OSH, public health
Paragraph
annex ENVI
Falls if 85, CA 11, 45 or 46
+
↓
annex (new)
ENVI
adopted
12
Asbestos diseases in
preventive public health:
Covered partly in CA11
Point (new)
ENVI ENVI
Falls if CA 19, 19a, 19b,
+
↓
18 Part
CA 16, CA 20, 20a, CA 3,
1
3a or CA 11 adopted Part 1:
“Transition to be socially
fair ... compliance”:
covered in CA20.;
“notes ... of vulnerable
people”: covered in CA3,
CA 19;
“recalls ... detected”:
covered in CA16
“highlights... system”:
covered in CA11
Point (new)
ENVI ENVI
part 2 addition: polluter
+
+
18 Part
pays principle
45/6/1
2
Recital L h
47 Matthieu
Falls if CA 12 adopted
+
↓
(new)
Built environment
Recital L i
48 Matthieu
Falls if CA 12 adopted
+
↓
(new)
Sustainable built
environment strategy
Point (new)
ENVI ENVI
Falls if 58, CA 28, 28a,
+
↓
43
28b, CA 12 or 48 adopted Circularity in construction
sector; availability of waste
facilities.
Covered in CA12, CA15,
CA28
Recital L j
49 Matthieu
Falls if CA 12 adopted
+
↓
(new)
Circular economy action
plan
Recital Lc
CA 13 Rapporteur
If adopted, 50 and 51 fall
+
+
(new)
Asbestos worldwide.
53/0/0
Regulation 649/2012 to
implement Rotterdam
Convention. Keep non-
compliant products outside
EU. Asbestos entering the
single market.
Recital L k
50 Villumsen,
Falls if CA 13 adopted
+
↓
(new)
Gusmão, Chaibi,
Export of asbestos, non-
Arvanitis,
compliant products not into
Rodríguez Palop
EU, market surveillance
Recital L l
51 Danielsson,
Falls if CA 13 adopted
+
↓
(new)
Fritzon,
Legally sold, illegal import
Blinkevičiūtė,
Vind, Brglez,
Jongerius,
Gualmini,
Bischoff, Homs
Ginel, Durá
Ferrandis
Recital L m
52 Trillet-Lenoir,
Falls if CA 10 or 28
+
↓
(new)
Vedrenne, Brunet,
adopted Cañas, Pîslaru
EU Beating Cancer Plan,
(identical with 28)
Recital L n
53 Villumsen,
EESC opinion (register,
+
+
(new)
Gusmão, Chaibi,
mapping). Link with CA18,
52/0/0
Arvanitis,
CA 27
Rodríguez Palop,
Botenga
Point (new)
ENVI ENVI
Falls if CA 18, 18a, 18b,
+
↓
21
18c, 18d, 82, 176, 177 or 53
adopted Surveillance, mesothelioma,
declaration to authorities
Covered in CA18
Recital Ld
CA 14 Rapporteur
If adopted, 54 and 55 fall
+
+
(new)
Registries, MS have
52/0/0
different social insurance
schemes, autonomy of social
partners
Recital L o
54 Trillet-Lenoir,
Falls if CA 14 adopted
+
↓
(new)
Vedrenne, Brunet,
Registries Cañas, Pîslaru
Recital L p
55 Danielsson,
Falls if CA 14 adopted
+
↓
(new)
Fritzon,
Social insurance schemes
Blinkevičiūtė,
Vind, Brglez,
Jongerius,
Gualmini,
Bischoff, Homs
Ginel, Durá
Ferrandis
Recital L q
56 Matthieu
Falls if CA 12 adopted
+
↓
(new)
EU Skills Agenda
Recital (new)
IMCO IMCO
Falls if CA 3, 3a adopted
+
↓
A
Addition: Prohibition as of
2025.
Covered in CA3
Recital (new) IMCO B IMCO
Falls if CA 3, 3a adopted
+
↓
part 1
Latency period: covered in
CA3.
Recital (new) IMCO B IMCO
Falls if ENVI 4 Part 1
+
↓
part 2
adopted Addition: worldwide
250.000 dying: (IMCO B
redundant if ENVI 4 part 1
adopted; in EMPL recital A
only the EU perspective (EU
figures).
Recital (new) IMCO C IMCO
Falls if CA 24, 24a, CA 2
+
↓
or CA 4 adopted Asbestos number 1 for
mesothelioma; asbestos
related diseases not
recognised
Covered in CA2, CA4, CA24
Recital (new)
IMCO IMCO
Addition:
+
+
D
Reference to REACH
52/0/0
(manufacturing, selling, use
forbidden);
Reference to regulation
(EU) 2016/1005 (Annex
XVII) Phase out of asbestos
by 01/07/2025
Recital (new) IMCO E IMCO
Addition: Asbestos present
+
+
in many buildings;
52/0/0
knowledge dwindling over
time; presence of asbestos
and absence of knowledge is
danger
Recital (new) IMCO F IMCO
Falls if CA 3, 3a or CA 5
+
↓
adopted Building stock older than 50
years, different groups of
population:
CA3 (3a) and CA5 enlarged
with IMCO elements
Recital (new)
IMCO IMCO
Falls if CA 5 adopted
+
↓
G
Deterioration of materials,
complex renovation process
with risk for persons:
CA5 enlarged with IMCO
elements
Recital (new)
IMCO IMCO
Falls if CA 18, 18a, 18b,
+
↓
H
18c, 18d adopted Certificate, registers
Covered in CA18 (18d)
Recital (new) IMCO I IMCO
Falls if CA 16 or CA 9, 9b
+
↓
adopted Financial support
Covered in CA9 (Ic), CA16
Recital (new) IMCO J IMCO
Addition: in some MS
+
+
legislation only when
48/0/5
starting using buildings or
demolition starts, but not
when selling
Recital (new)
IMCO IMCO
Falls if CA 10 adopted
+
↓
K
Welcome asbestos revision
in 2022 and prevention of
victims, modernising houses
in the safest way.
Covered in CA10
Recital new
ENVI C ENVI
Addition: Article 191(1)
+
+
TFEU
47/6/0
environment
Recital new
ENVI D ENVI
Addition: Article 191(2)
+
+
TFEU
47/6/0
precautionary principle,
prevention
Recital new
ENVI E ENVI
Addition: right to safe,
+
+
healthy environment
34/6/13
becomes universally
recognised
EMPL budget opinion Voting List (Lucia Ďuriš Nicholsonová)
Paragraph 1
CA 1 Rapporteur
If adopted, 8, 10, 13, 11, 12
+
+
and 9 fall
31/13/8
Paragraph 1
8 Kanev
Falls if CA 1 adopted
+
↓
Paragraph 1
10 Agius Saliba,
Falls if CA 1 or 8 adopted
+
↓
Lalucq, Brglez,
Homs Ginel
Paragraph 1
13 Pereira, Chaibi
Falls if CA 1 or 10 adopted
-
↓
Paragraph 1
11 Rafaela
Falls if CA 1, 8, 10 or 13
+
↓
adopted
Paragraph 1
12 Langensiepen
Falls if CA 1, 8, 10, 13 or
+
↓
11 adopted
Paragraph 1
9 Lexmann
Falls if CA 1, 10, 13 or 11
+
↓
adopted
Paragraph 2
CA 2 Rapporteur
If adopted, 20, 16, 14, 18,
+
+
15, 17 and 19 fall
45/4/3
Paragraph 2
Addition
Falls if CA 2 NOT adopted
+
+
1 to CA
If adopted, the words “and
28/24/0
2
economically sustainable”
will be added in paragraph
2, so that paragraph 2 reads
“2. Highlights that the
budget with a strong social
and economically
sustainable dimension…”
Paragraph 2
Addition
Falls if CA 2 NOT adopted
+
+
2 to CA
If adopted, the word
30/20/2
2
“intersectional” will be
added so that paragraph 2b
reads “insists on the need to
tackle economic, social,
intersectional, territorial,
generational and regional
disparities and
inequalities…”
Paragraph 2
20 Pereira, Chaibi
Falls if CA 2 adopted
+
↓
Paragraph 2
16 Agius Saliba,
Falls if CA 2 or 20 adopted
+
↓
Lalucq, Brglez,
Homs Ginel
Paragraph 2
14 Kanev
Falls if CA 2, 20 or 16
+
↓
adopted
Paragraph 2
18 Langensiepen
Falls if CA 2, 20, 16 or 14
+
↓
adopted
Paragraph 2
15 Lexmann
Falls if CA 2, 20, 16 or 14
+
↓
adopted
Paragraph 2
17 Rafaela
Falls if CA 2, 20, 16 or 18
+
↓
adopted
Paragraph 2
19 Szydło, Rafalska,
Falls if CA 2, 16 or 17
+
↓
de la Pisa Carrión
adopted
Paragraph 2 a
21 Agius Saliba,
+
+
(new)
Lalucq, Brglez,
50/2/0
Homs Ginel
Paragraph 2 a
22 Pereira, Chaibi
-
-
(new)
14/32/6
Paragraph 2 b
23 Pereira, Chaibi
-
-
(new)
8/27/17
Paragraph 3
CA 3 Rapporteur
If adopted, 25, 27, 26, 24,
+
+
29, 28 and 30 fall
45/3/4
Paragraph 3
25 Lexmann
Falls if CA 3 adopted
+
↓
Paragraph 3
27 Rafaela
Falls if CA 3 adopted
+
↓
Paragraph 3
26 Agius Saliba,
Falls if CA 3, 25 or 27
+
↓
Lalucq, Brglez,
adopted
Homs Ginel
Paragraph 3
24 Kanev
Falls if CA 3 adopted
+
↓
Paragraph 3
29 Szydło, Rafalska,
Falls if CA 3 adopted
+
↓
de la Pisa Carrión
Paragraph 3
28 Langensiepen
Falls if CA 3 or 26 adopted
+
↓
Paragraph 3
30 Pereira, Chaibi
Falls if CA 3 or 25 adopted
+
↓
Paragraph 3 a
31 Pereira, Chaibi
-
-
(new)
21/29/2
Paragraph 3 b
32 Pereira, Botenga,
-
-
(new)
Chaibi
21/31/0
Paragraph 4
CA 4 Rapporteur
If adopted, 37, 34, 36, 35
+
+
and 33 fall
46/5/1
Paragraph 4
37 Pereira, Chaibi
Falls if CA 4 adopted
+
↓
Paragraph 4
34 Agius Saliba,
Falls if CA 4 or 37 adopted
+
↓
Lalucq, Brglez,
Homs Ginel
Paragraph 4
36 Langensiepen
Falls if CA 4, 37 or 34
+
↓
adopted
Paragraph 4
35 Rafaela
Falls if CA 4, 37 or 34
+
↓
adopted
Paragraph 4
33 Lexmann
Falls if CA 4 or 37 adopted
+
↓
Paragraph 4 a
38 Agius Saliba,
Split vote (EPP, Renew)
+
+
(new)
Brglez, Homs
Part 1
40/3/9
Ginel
Recalls that
implementation…social and
economic aspects;
Part 2
-
-
Stresses that adequate
19/28/5
resources…and worker’s
protection;
Paragraph 4 a
39 Pereira, Chaibi
-
-
(new)
17/30/5
Paragraph 4 b
40 Agius Saliba,
Split vote (EPP)
+
+
(new)
Lalucq, Brglez,
Part 1
47/2/3
Homs Ginel
Reiterates that the Recovery
and Resilience
Facility…and inclusion
Part 2
0
-
And stresses that social
25/25/2
objectives…Next Generation
EU;
Part 3
+
+
Stresses that the
39/7/6
reforms…European Pillar of
Social Rights
Part 4
+
+
And that the Member
31/20/1
States… within the CSRs
Paragraph 4 c
41 Agius Saliba,
Split vote (Renew)
+
+
(new)
Lalucq, Brglez,
Part 1
46/5/1
Homs Ginel
Text without the words “at
least 0.25% of ESF+
resources under shared
management in each
programme”
Part 2
0
-
Falls if 41 Part 1 NOT
18/32/2
adopted These words “at least
0.25% of ESF+ resources
under shared management
in each programme”
Paragraph 5
CA 5A S&D, Greens
If adopted, CA 5, 43, 42,
0
-
44 and 45 fall
20/31/1
Paragraph 5
CA 5 Rapporteur
Falls if CA 5A adopted
+
+
If adopted, 43, 42, 44 and
38/4/10
45 fall
Paragraph 5
43 Lexmann
Falls if CA 5A or CA 5
+
↓
adopted
Paragraph 5
42 Agius Saliba,
Falls if CA 5A or CA 5
+
↓
Lalucq, Brglez,
adopted
Homs Ginel
Paragraph 5
44 Rafaela
Falls if CA 5A or CA 5
+
↓
adopted
Paragraph 5
45 Langensiepen
Falls if CA 5A, CA 5 or 44
+
↓
adopted
Paragraph 6
CA 6A S&D, Greens
If adopted, CA 6, 47, 48,
0
-
46 and 49 fall
20/30/2
Paragraph 6
CA 6 Rapporteur
Falls if CA 6A adopted
+
+
If adopted, 47, 48, 46 and
40/6/6
49 fall
Paragraph 6
47 Lexmann
Falls if CA 6A or CA 6
+
↓
adopted
Paragraph 6
48 Rafaela
Falls if CA 6A or CA 6
+
↓
adopted
Paragraph 6
46 Agius Saliba,
Falls if CA 6A or CA 6
+
↓
Lalucq, Brglez,
adopted
Homs Ginel
Paragraph 6
49 Langensiepen
Falls if CA 6A or CA 6
+
↓
adopted
Paragraph 7
CA 7 Rapporteur
If adopted, 50, 54, 52, 53,
+
+
51, 55 and 56 A fall
50/2/0
Paragraph 7
50 Kanev
Falls if CA 7 adopted
+
↓
Paragraph 7
54 Langensiepen
Falls if CA 7 or 50 adopted
+
↓
Paragraph 7
52 Agius Saliba,
Falls if CA 7 adopted
+
↓
Lalucq, Brglez,
Homs Ginel
Paragraph 7
53 Rafaela
Falls if CA 7, 50 or 54
+
↓
adopted
Paragraph 7
51 Lexmann
Falls if CA 7 adopted
-
↓
Paragraph 7
55 de la Pisa Carrión
Falls if CA 7, 50 or 52
-
↓
adopted If adopted, will be changed
as follows : " Underlines the
importance of the revised
application requirements
and eligibility criteria in the
EGF Regulation, and asks
for further lowering the
minimum threshold of
workers made redundant or
of self-employed persons
from 500 to 50;"
Paragraph 7 a
56 A Rafaela
Falls if CA 7 adopted
+
↓
(new)
Technical split :
1st part :
“Recalls the important
role…COVID-19 crisis”
Paragraph 7 a
56 B Rafaela
Technical split :
+
+
(new)
2nd part:
48/1/3
“Believes Member
States…their
representatives”
Paragraph 8
57 Langensiepen
+
+
35/16/1
Paragraph 8 a
58 Pereira, Chaibi
-
-
(new)
5/33/14
Paragraph 9
CA 8 Rapporteur
If adopted, 62, 59, 60, 61
+
+
and 63 fall
47/3/2
Paragraph 9
62 Langensiepen
Falls if CA 8 adopted
+
↓
Paragraph 9
59 Kanev
Falls if CA 8 adopted
+
↓
Paragraph 9
60 Lexmann
Falls if CA 8 adopted
+
↓
Paragraph 9
61 Agius Saliba,
Falls if CA 8 adopted
+
↓
Lalucq, Brglez,
Homs Ginel
Paragraph 9
63 Szydło, Rafalska,
Falls if CA 8 adopted
+
↓
de la Pisa Carrión
Paragraph 10
64 Agius Saliba,
+
+
Lalucq, Brglez,
47/0/5
Homs Ginel
Paragraph 10
65 Agius Saliba,
Split vote (EPP)
+
+
a (new)
Brglez, Homs
Part 1
49/3/0
Ginel
Acknowledges that the
EU…and economies
Part 2
-
-
That the wealth
25/27/0
distribution…are also
consolidated
Paragraph 10
66 Agius Saliba,
+
+
b (new)
Lalucq, Brglez,
27/22/3
Homs Ginel
Paragraph 10
67 Agius Saliba,
-
-
c (new)
Lalucq, Brglez,
20/28/4
Homs Ginel
Paragraph 10
68 Agius Saliba,
Split vote (Renew)
+
+
d (new)
Brglez, Homs
Part 1
42/2/8
Ginel
Highlights that
addressing…virtuous circles
Part 2
-
-
Rather than negative
21/27/4
feedback loops
Part 3
+
+
Believes that …to be added
41/0/11
Part 4
-
-
Demands that, in
20/32/0
order…agreement coverage
Paragraph 10
69 Agius Saliba,
-
-
e (new)
Lalucq, Brglez,
19/30/3
Homs Ginel
Paragraph 10
70 Agius Saliba,
+
+
f (new)
Lalucq, Brglez,
43/0/9
Homs Ginel
Paragraph 10
71 Agius Saliba,
+
+
g (new)
Lalucq, Brglez,
44/0/8
Homs Ginel
Paragraph 11
73 Agius Saliba,
+
+
Lalucq, Brglez,
42/7/3
Homs Ginel
Paragraph 11
74 Langensiepen
0
+
37/12/3
Paragraph 11
72 Lexmann
+
+
37/11/4
Paragraph 11
75 Rafaela
+
+
a (new)
26/19/7
Paragraph 11
76 de la Pisa Carrión
+
+
a (new)
34/17/1
Paragraph 12
77 Agius Saliba,
+
+
Lalucq, Brglez,
48/0/4
Homs Ginel
Paragraph 12
78 Langensiepen
+
+
34/17/1
Paragraph 13
80 Agius Saliba,
+
+
Lalucq, Brglez,
44/7/1
Homs Ginel
Paragraph 13
79 Kanev
Consistent with budgetary
+
+
AM EMPL/5560 which was
45/6/1
adopted on 01.09
Paragraph 13
81 Agius Saliba,
Consistent with budgetary
+
+
a (new)
Lalucq, Brglez,
AM EMPL/5558 which was
44/7/1
Homs Ginel
adopted on 01.09
Paragraph 13
82 Agius Saliba,
+
+
b (new)
Lalucq, Brglez,
50/0/2
Homs Ginel
Paragraph 13
83 Agius Saliba,
+
+
c (new)
Lalucq, Brglez,
30/5/17
Homs Ginel
Recital A
1 Agius Saliba,
-
-
(new)
Brglez, Homs
17/33/2
Ginel
Recital B
2 Agius Saliba,
-
-
(new)
Lalucq, Brglez,
20/32/0
Homs Ginel
Recital C
3 Agius Saliba,
+
+
(new)
Lalucq, Brglez,
48/3/1
Homs Ginel
Recital D
4 Agius Saliba,
+
+
(new)
Lalucq, Brglez,
45/3/4
Homs Ginel
Recital E
5 Agius Saliba,
Consistent with budgetary
+
+
(new)
Lalucq, Brglez,
AM EMPL/5562 and 5563
49/3/0
Homs Ginel
which were adopted on
01/09
Recital F
6 Agius Saliba,
+
+
(new)
Lalucq, Brglez,
49/1/2
Homs Ginel
Recital G
7 Agius Saliba,
+
+
(new)
Lalucq, Brglez,
45/4/3
Homs Ginel