Ref. Ares(2022)4073243 - 01/06/2022
Limited
MINUTES OF THE FOURTH MEETING OF THE BOARD OF TRADE AND
SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT
ASSOCIATION AGREEMENT BETWEEN CENTRAL AMERICA
AND THE EUROPEAN UNION
Brussels, Belgium 11-12 June 2018
The Board on Trade and Sustainable Development (hereinafter the Board) of the Association
Agreement between Central America and the European Union (hereinafter the Agreement) met
on 11 and 12 June 2018 in order to review implementation of Title VIII on Trade and Sustainable
Development.
Recent events relevant to the Trade and Sustainable Development Title
The EU mentioned that increasing importance is being attached in Europe to Trade and
Sustainable Development chapters (TSD) in trade agreements. There had been an intense debate
on the effective implementation of these chapters, in particular on the effectiveness of their
dispute settlement mechanism. Some argued in favour of a mechanism with the possibility of
sanctions. After a few months the European Commission concluded that the current model
should be retained, but at the same time implementation of TSD chapters should be
strengthened. To this end it had published a 15-point Action Plan, which was presented to the
Board. Among these points is a more assertive use of the mechanisms of consultation and expert
panels in cases of serious non-compliance. .
For its part, Central America presented the contents of the Labour and Environment chapters of
its recently negotiated Free Trade Agreement with South Korea.
State of progress in the implementation of the articles of the Trade and Sustainable
Development Title relating to labour in the framework of the ILO
The EU reported on progress in the ratification by Member States of the 2014 Protocol to the
Forced Labour Convention and underlined its commitment to promote its ratification. The EU
made a presentation on informal work and on actions in the EU and the Member States to
combat this phenomenon. In this context it mentioned the importance of strengthening labour
inspection in order to ensure the proper application of labour law. The EU shared information
on the European Pillar of Social Rights, which was adopted in November 2017. The Pillar is one
of the EU’s most important policy initiatives in the field of employment and social policies and
has as its main objective to ensure that economic and social development go hand in hand.
In the context of commitments in Title VIII on Trade and Sustainable Development (TSD) on the
effective implementation of ILO Fundamental Conventions, the EU expressed its interest to
strengthening the bilateral dialogue and in a more regular follow-up between meetings of the
1From8
Limited
Limited
MINUTES OF THE FOURTH MEETING OF THE BOARD OF TRADE AND
SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT
ASSOCIATION AGREEMENT BETWEEN CENTRAL AMERICA
AND THE EUROPEAN UNION
Brussels, Belgium 11-12 June 2018
Board, taking into account the observations and recommendations identified by the ILO’s
mechanisms on serious cases in some countries.
Costa Rica underlined the important impact that its accession process to the Organisation for
Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) had had in strengthening policies on labour
and employment, encouraging it to adopt policies and regulations of the highest standards.
Costa Rica was positively assessed in the [OECD} Committee on Employment, Labour and
Social Affairs in 2017. In addition, Costa Rica highlighted progress in labour issues related to the
implementation of fundamental ILO conventions, highlighting the implementation of
procedural reforms in the labour sector [in order to ensure more effective application and
enforcement of its labour law], including the right of non-discrimination and collective rights; its
strategy for the transition from informality to formality; progress on corporate social
responsibility and the recent adoption of its National Policy on Social Responsibility.
EL Salvador stressed the government’s commitment to compliance with the provisions of
ratified ILO conventions. In this context it highlighted efforts to ratify Convention 189 on Decent
Work for Domestic Workers and its efforts to raise awareness through public meetings; as well
as the setting up of an Interinstitutional Committee for the ratification of this Convention.
With respect to Convention 182 on the Prohibition of the Worst Forms of Child Labour it
reported that in the period 2008 to 2017 the number of cases of child labour had decreased by
60,368. [?]
In relation to Convention 144 on Tripartite Consultation (international labour standards), El
Salvador stated that there is a political will at the highest level to reactivate the [High] Labour
Council. To this end, the government had facilitated conditions for trilogue and accepted
technical assistance by the ILO. In this context, it had received an ILO technical cooperation
mission to mediate with trade union organisations with the aim of achieving the necessary
consensus for the reactivation of the [High] Labour Council. Furthermore, it had received in July
2017 an [ILO] direct contacts mission.
On the other hand [?} El Salvador stated that it is making significant efforts to strengthen labour
inspection and to conduct more inspections. It also commented that it is working with over
20,000 companies on gender equality seals with the aim of promoting the incorporation of
women and youth in the labour market.
Guatemala stated that in relation to Convention 87 concerning Freedom of Association and
Protection of the Right to Organise, in the 333th meeting of the ILO Governing Body recognised
progress and called on the government and social partners, with the support of the International
2From8
Limited
Limited
MINUTES OF THE FOURTH MEETING OF THE BOARD OF TRADE AND
SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT
ASSOCIATION AGREEMENT BETWEEN CENTRAL AMERICA
AND THE EUROPEAN UNION
Brussels, Belgium 11-12 June 2018
Organisation of Employers (IOE) and the International Trade Union Confederation (ITUC) and
ILO technical assistance, to continue discussions so as to make progress on the national
agreements aimed at addressing [the points of] the complaint [made to the ILO]. It also stated
that it is working on the issues of child labour and informal work with the consensus of the
Tripartite Labour Committee. In addition, [Finally?] it stated that a presentation would be sent
subsequently providing an update on these issues.
Honduras emphasised aspects related to the implementation of Convention 81 on Labour
Inspection, highlighting the [recent] approval of the new Labour Inspection Law and the process
of development of regulations that will contribute to [facilitate?] the implementation of this law.
It noted positive results since the entry into force of the above-mentioned law in relation to the
number of inspections carried out and the penalties imposed for infringement of its labour law.
As regards Convention 87 on Freedom of Association and Protection of the Right to Organise,
Honduras stated that in 2015 it has adopted a Law for the Protection of Human Rights
Defenders, Journalists, Social Communicators and Operators in the field of Justice. Another
important aspect is the follow-up by the government of recommendations made by workers and
the private sector for reforms of the Labour Code in relation to Convention 87. In addition, it
indicated that the Ministry of Employment and Social Security will establish a round table
[mechanism?] to monitor information on cases of violence against trades union leaders [?] with
the technical assistance of the ILO.
In relation to Convention 169 on Indigenous and Tribal Peoples, the government of Honduras
has received support and technical assistance from the ILO. As a result it has submitted to its
National Congress a draft law on Consultation and Free, Prior Informed Consent (FPIC). It also
indicated that the dialogue had been a key element in the development of this draft law.
Nicaragua stated that it would present relevant developments at a later stage, since for reasons
of force majeure it was not possible to involve officials in charge of labour issues during the
meeting of the Board. In addition, it undertook to answer any written questions that may be
made by the European Union.
Panama presented progress in the implementation of ILO Conventions 138 and 182 on Child
Labour, indicating a continued reduction in the number of cases of child labour, with support of
technical assistance from the ILO and funding from the US Department of Labour.
In the case of Conventions 29 and 105 on Forced Labour, Panama stressed regulations related to
the National Policy for Combating Trafficking in Human Beings; approval of the construction of
3From8
Limited
Limited
MINUTES OF THE FOURTH MEETING OF THE BOARD OF TRADE AND
SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT
ASSOCIATION AGREEMENT BETWEEN CENTRAL AMERICA
AND THE EUROPEAN UNION
Brussels, Belgium 11-12 June 2018
a hostel for victims and the National Plan 2017-2022; and the creation of a unit for the
identification and care of victims.
Regarding Conventions 87 and 98 on Freedom of Association, Panama stressed the granting of
legal personality to trade unions in the public and private sector and the continued operation of
round tables for dialogue under Committees of the Tripartite Agreement.
With regard to Conventions 100 and 111 on Equal Remuneration, Panama stressed its
participation in the Equal Pay International Commission (EPIC). It also highlighted important
initiatives for gender equity led by the Ministry of Labour and Labour Development to
implement the Gender Equality Seal for companies and the work of the National Institute for
Women on the Equality Seal in the public sector and the Initiative on Gender Parity (IPG).
State of progress in the implementation of the articles of the Trade and Sustainable
Development Title relating to the environment
The EU presented its overall policy on climate change, emphasising its target of becoming the
economy with the lowest consumption of CO2 per unit of gross national product in the G20 and
its commitment to the Paris Agreement. In order to reach the targets set by the international
community is essential to mobilise private sector investments and develop public policies
favourable to such investments. The projections suggest major impacts on climate change in
agricultural production that will lead to changes in trade flows. At multilateral level, the
international community will have to take important decisions in the coming years to reach the
targets of the Paris Agreement.
The Euroclima + programme for Latin America was also presented. The programme supports
subregional activities or activities of groups of countries on climate change mitigation and
adaptation. These may be in the following areas: climate governance, forests, management and
reduction of risks of disasters, urban mobility, resilient food production, energy efficiency, water
management. The Board on Trade and Sustainable Development underlined the relevance of
this programme to the objectives of the TSD Title.
Costa Rica stated the importance that its accession process to the Organisation for Economic Co-
operation and Development (OECD) had had in the development of their environmental
policies; encouraging it to adopt policies and regulations of the highest standards. In addition,
Costa Rica highlighted the publication of the first report on the State of the Environment and the
strengthening of the environmental information system, through which the country has further
developed statistical information related to the state of the environment and natural resources.
4From8
Limited
Limited
MINUTES OF THE FOURTH MEETING OF THE BOARD OF TRADE AND
SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT
ASSOCIATION AGREEMENT BETWEEN CENTRAL AMERICA
AND THE EUROPEAN UNION
Brussels, Belgium 11-12 June 2018
Costa Rica stated that this will improve policy decision-making and environmental protection. It
reported on its Policy for Sustainable Consumption and Production and the national strategy for
the replacement of single use plastics by renewable and compostable alternatives. Finally, it
reported on the signature [earlier this year?] of the Regional Agreement on Access to
Information, Public Participation and Access to Justice in Environmental Affairs in Latin
America and the Caribbean.
EL Salvador noted progress in the following areas: legal and institutional framework,
infrastructure, water, energy, agriculture and forestry, which were notified on 15 November
2015 as priority areas in its nationally determined contribution under the Paris Agreement.
Regarding its institutional framework, it indicated that it is working on a draft Framework Law
on Climate Change for 2019. As regards the strategy of diversification of the energy matrix and
the promotion of renewable energy, it highlighted progress in tenders for procurement of non-
conventional renewable energy such as wind and solar energy. It also reported on progress in
the development and implementation of [climate change related?] policies and plans on
agriculture, livestock farming and forestry.
Guatemala presented the implementation of the UN Framework Convention on Climate Change
consistent with Paris Agreement commitments. In addition, it provided information on the
current legal framework in the country and on the National Climate Change Fund, which aims
to finance plans, programmes and projects on risk management, reducing vulnerability, forced
adaptation and compulsory mitigation as well as capacity building on climate change and
payments for environmental services.
Honduras reported on progress in the implementation of the Basel, Stockholm and Minamata
Conventions and the Montreal Protocol. In this context it highlighted the strengthening of
national capacities for the implementation of these international instruments. It also pointed out
that it has carried out actions to provide information, to raise awareness and provide training [of
the public] as well as scientific research and development and strengthening of the legal
framework. With regard to the Paris Agreement, it reported on the change of its energy matrix,
aimed at generation of 60 % from renewable energy and 40 % from fossil fuels. This change has
led to a reduction of emissions of 2,4 million tonnes of CO2 per year.
Honduras also provided information on National Programme for the Recovery of Ecosystem
Assets and Services, emphasising the restoration of one million hectares of forest over a period
of ten years. It also mentioned the Efficient Stoves NAMA initiative under the Better Life
Programme, with an average reduction of three tons of CO2 per stove per year.
5From8
Limited
Limited
MINUTES OF THE FOURTH MEETING OF THE BOARD OF TRADE AND
SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT
ASSOCIATION AGREEMENT BETWEEN CENTRAL AMERICA
AND THE EUROPEAN UNION
Brussels, Belgium 11-12 June 2018
Honduras highlighted the importance of the signature of the FLEGT Voluntary Partnership
Agreement (FLEGT VPA) [with the EU!] which provides for compliance with environmental
legislation for wood products both for domestic consumption and for export. The VPA will be
an important element in the fight against deforestation and to address the adverse effects of
climate change. It has facilitated the participation of the private sector and civil society in the
implementation of initiatives. This contributes to strengthening of the process and of forest
governance, through the inclusion of various working groups which include indigenous people
and Honduran communities of African descent.
Nicaragua stated that it would present relevant developments at a later stage, since for reasons
of force majeure it was not possible to involve officials in charge of environment issues during
the meeting of the Board. However, it pointed out that Nicaragua had acceded to the Paris
Agreement.
Panama provided information on its General Law on Environment which for the first time
includes a chapter on climate change. It reported on the five main axes of action in
environmental matters: New Model of Management, Ecotourism in Protected Areas, Water
Resources, the Alliance for Reforestation of One Million ha and Climate Change. It also
highlighted the development of a draft National Climate Change Strategy.
It also described progress of the country as Presidency of the Coalition for The Tropical Forests,
achieving the inclusion of forests in the Paris Agreement. It was also the first country in the
Americas and third globally to submit its Nationally Determined Contribution (NDC). It
explained that the NDC of the energy generation subsector will be achieved through the
National Energy Plan and for Land Use and Land Use Change through the Alliance for
Reforestation of One Million ha.
It highlighted the creation of the International Centre for the Reduction of Emissions from
Deforestation and Forest Degradation (ICIREDD) in Panama, the establishment of forest
reference levels for measuring progress in reducing emissions and submission of its Third
National Communication to the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change.
Regarding the Cartagena Protocol it provided information on the reactivation of the National
Committee for Biosafety for Genetically Modified Organisms as well as work related to the
National Biodiversity Strategy and Action Plan 2018-2050. It also described progress in the
implementation of the Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species of Wild Fauna
and Flora (CITES).
6From8
Limited
Limited
MINUTES OF THE FOURTH MEETING OF THE BOARD OF TRADE AND
SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT
ASSOCIATION AGREEMENT BETWEEN CENTRAL AMERICA
AND THE EUROPEAN UNION
Brussels, Belgium 11-12 June 2018
Cooperation
The EU presented the broad lines of its development cooperation policies, with a focus on
intersections with trade policy and support to the private sector. It presented several EU
programmes in the social area that are open to the Central American countries such as
SOCIEUX+ and EUROsociAL. The Board recognised the relevance of these programmes to
support the implementation of the TSD Title and expressed its interest in exploring possibilities
under these programmes with the focal points established for these programmes.
Discussion of the written recommendations of the Advisory Groups
On this occasion the Advisory Groups of Central America and the European Union did not
submit written recommendations regarding the implementation of Title prior to the meeting of
the TSD Board. The Board received and took note of a letter sent by the Advisory Groups dated
8th June 2018. With regard to this letter the TSD Board underlined the importance of maintaining
an open channel of communication with the Advisory Groups and in turn highlighted the
importance of strengthening the work they carry out. To this end, it was agreed to include the
strengthening of these groups as one of the points in the work plan to be prepared by the TSD
Board.
Furthermore, it was agreed to ask the Advisory Groups to actively support the Civil Society
Dialogue Forum (CSDF). Taking into account that the participation and support of the Advisory
Groups is very important to strengthen the [opportunities] [spaces for] public participation
provided for in the Agreement, the TSD Board agreed to establish a permanent agenda item in
the Civil Society Dialogue Forum under which the advisory groups can present their
recommendations [if they so wish].
Work plan and priorities for implementation
The TSD Board discussed and evaluated the results of events undertaken as a follow-up to the
work priorities identified during the III meeting of the TSD Board in Tegucigalpa, namely an
event on “Global Value Chains and Sustainable Development” carried out in Costa Rica in May
7From8
Limited
Limited
MINUTES OF THE FOURTH MEETING OF THE BOARD OF TRADE AND
SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT
ASSOCIATION AGREEMENT BETWEEN CENTRAL AMERICA
AND THE EUROPEAN UNION
Brussels, Belgium 11-12 June 2018
2017” and on “Decent Work, Corporate Responsibility and the EU-Central America Association
Agreement Contributing to a Sustainable Economic Growth” held in May 2018 in Guatemala.
Overall it considered that these events had had a very positive impact on strengthening [of
work] on these issues in the region. Costa Rica mentioned the positive impact that it had had on
work and coordination of various sectors for discussion [and development of] of the National
Policy on Social Responsibility. The broad participation and interest of various sectors in the
event on decent work carried out in Guatemala was also noted. Based on these experiences it
was agreed to continue efforts to boost these issues in the region. The European Union’s efforts
to provide funding for the participation of some members of the Central American advisory
groups were appreciated. The importance was noted of clarifying procedures so as to ensure the
inclusive participation of members of the advisory groups.
The TSD Board agreed to continue to coordinate efforts to drive forward an agenda for the
promotion of trade and sustainable development. To that end, both regions will work on a plan
which includes areas of [joint] interest on the basis of which specific activities can be developed.
This work plan will cover regional activities and activities that can bring together the interests of
two or more countries. With this objective in mind the following areas of interest were
identified: corporate social responsibility, responsible supply chains, boosting employment that
takes into account the decent work agenda, gender [equality] and promotion of green
economies, sustainable agriculture including climate change and compliance with market
requirements, strengthening advisory groups. It was agreed to finalise this document by
December 2018.
Brussels, Belgium, 13 June 2018
8From8
Limited