Esta es la versión HTML de un fichero adjunto a una solicitud de acceso a la información 'Copyright trilogue'.

Version 4.1
30/11/2018
Proposal for a Directive of the European Parliament and of the Council
on copyright in the Digital Single Market
COM (2016) 593 final - 2016/0280 (COD)
PART 2: ARTICLES
Cell in green: The text can be deemed as already agreed
Cell in yellow: The issue needs further discussion at technical level
Cell in red: The issue needs further discussion in depth at the trilogue meetings
Note:
Differences between the EP's position and the Commission's proposal are highlighted in bold /italic. Deletions are marked with
strikethrough.
Differences between the Council's position and the Commission's proposal are highlighted in 
bold/underlined.
Deletions are marked with strikethrough.

1

Location
COMMISSION
EP TEXT
COUNCIL TEXT
POSSIBLE
PROPOSAL
COMPROMISE
doc. 9134/18
COM(2016)593
SOLUTION
105.
TITLE I
TITLE I
TITLE I
TITLE I
GENERAL PROVISIONS
GENERAL PROVISIONS
GENERAL PROVISIONS
GENERAL PROVISIONS
106.
Art.1,
Article 1
Article 1
Article 1
Article 1
Subject matter and scope
Subject matter and scope
Subject matter and scope
Subject matter and scope
title
107.
Art. 1, para
1.
This Directive lays
1. This Directive lays
1.
This Directive lays
GREEN
1
down rules which aim at
down rules which aim at
down rules which aim at
1. This Directive lays down
further harmonising the
further harmonising the
further harmonising the
rules which aim at further
Union law applicable to
Union law applicable to
Union law applicable to
harmonising the Union law
copyright and related
copyright and related
copyright and related
applicable to copyright and
rights in the framework of
rights in the framework of
rights in the framework of
related rights in the
the internal market, taking
the internal market, taking
the internal market, taking
framework of the internal
into account in particular
into account in particular
into account in particular
market, taking into account
digital and cross-border
digital and cross-border
digital and cross-border
in particular digital and
uses of protected content.
uses of protected content.
uses of protected content.
cross-border uses of
It also lays down rules on
It also lays down rules on
It also lays down rules on
protected content. It also lays
exceptions and limitations,
exceptions and limitations,
exceptions and limitations,
down rules on exceptions
on the facilitation of
on the facilitation of
on the facilitation of
and limitations, on the
licences as well as rules
licences as well as rules
licences as well as rules
facilitation of licences as
aiming at ensuring a well-
aiming at ensuring a well-
aiming at ensuring a well-
well as rules aiming at
functioning marketplace
functioning marketplace
functioning marketplace
ensuring a well-functioning
for the exploitation of
for the exploitation of
for the exploitation of
marketplace for the
works and other subject-
works and other subject-
works and other subject-
exploitation of works and
matter.
matter.
matter.
other subject-matter.
[identical text]
2

Location
COMMISSION
EP TEXT
COUNCIL TEXT
POSSIBLE
PROPOSAL
COMPROMISE
doc. 9134/18
COM(2016)593
SOLUTION
108.
Art. 1, para
2.
Except in the cases
2. Except in the cases
2.
Except in the cases
2.
Except in the cases
2
referred to in Article 6, this
referred to in Article 6, this
referred to in Article 617,
referred to in Article 617,
Directive shall leave intact
Directive shall leave intact
this Directive shall leave
this Directive shall leave
and shall in no way affect
and shall in no way affect
intact and shall in no way
intact and shall in no way
existing rules laid down in
existing rules laid down in
affect existing rules laid
affect existing rules laid
the Directives currently in
the Directives currently in
down in the Directives
down in the Directives
force in this area, in
force in this area, in
currently in force in this
currently in force in this
particular Directives
particular Directives
area, in particular
area, in particular Directives
96/9/EC, 2001/29/EC,
96/9/EC, 2000/31/EC,
Directives 96/9/EC,
96/9/EC, 2000/31/EC,
2006/115/EC, 2009/24/EC,
2001/29/EC, 2006/115/EC,
2000/31/EC, 2001/29/EC,
2001/29/EC, 2006/115/EC,
2012/28/EU and
2009/24/EC, 2012/28/EU
2006/115/EC, 2009/24/EC,
2009/24/EC, 2012/28/EU
2014/26/EU.
and 2014/26/EU.
2012/28/EU and
and 2014/26/EU.
2014/26/EU.
109.
Art. 2, title
Article 2
Article 2
Article 2
Article 2
Definitions
Definitions
Definitions
Definitions
110.
Art. 2,
For the purposes of this
For the purposes of this
For the purposes of this
GREEN
introductory
Directive, the following
Directive, the following
Directive, the following
For the purposes of this
part
definitions shall apply:
definitions shall apply:
definitions shall apply:
Directive, the following
definitions shall apply:
111.
Art. 2, para
(1)
‘research
(1) ‘research organisation’
(1)
‘research
GREEN
1,
organisation’ means a
means a university,
organisation’ means a
(1) ‘research organisation’
introductory
university, a research
including its libraries, a
university, a research
means a university,
part
institute or any other
research institute or any
institute or any other
including its libraries, a
organisation the primary
other organisation the
organisationan entity, the
research institute or any
3

Location
COMMISSION
EP TEXT
COUNCIL TEXT
POSSIBLE
PROPOSAL
COMPROMISE
doc. 9134/18
COM(2016)593
SOLUTION
goal of which is to conduct
primary goal of which is to
primary goal of which is to
other entity the primary goal
scientific research or to
conduct scientific research
conduct scientific research
of which is to conduct
conduct scientific research
or to conduct scientific
or to conduct scientific
scientific research or to
and provide educational
research and provide
research and provide
carry out educational
services:
educational services:
educational services:
activities involving also the
involving also the
conduct of scientific
conduct of scientific
research:
research:
[provisionally agreed at
Trilogue 25/10/2018]

112.
Art. 2, para
(a)
on a non-for-profit
(a)
on a non-for-profit
(a)
on a non-for-profit
GREEN
1, point (a)
basis or by reinvesting all
basis or by reinvesting all
basis or by reinvesting all
(a)
on a non-for-profit
the profits in its scientific
the profits in its scientific
the profits in its scientific
basis or by reinvesting all the
research; or
research; or
research; or
profits in its scientific
research; or
[provisionally agreed at
Trilogue 25/10/2018]

113.
Art. 2, para
(b)
pursuant to a public
(b)
pursuant to a public
(b)
pursuant to a public
GREEN
1, point (b)
interest mission recognised
interest mission recognised
interest mission recognised
(b)
pursuant to a public
by a Member State;
by a Member State;
by a Member State;
interest mission recognised
by a Member State;
[provisionally agreed at
Trilogue 25/10/2018]

4

Location
COMMISSION
EP TEXT
COUNCIL TEXT
POSSIBLE
PROPOSAL
COMPROMISE
doc. 9134/18
COM(2016)593
SOLUTION
114.
Art. 2, para
in such a way that the
in such a way that the
in such a way that the
GREEN
1, closing
access to the results
access to the results
access to the results
in such a way that the access
phrase
generated by the scientific
generated by the scientific
generated by the scientific
to the results generated by
research cannot be enjoyed
research cannot be enjoyed
research cannot be enjoyed
the scientific research cannot
on a preferential basis by
on a preferential basis by
on a preferential basis by
be enjoyed on a preferential
an undertaking exercising
an undertaking exercising
an undertaking exercising
basis by an undertaking
a decisive influence upon
significant influence
a decisive influence upon
exercising a significant
such organisation;
upon such organisation;
such organisation;
decisive influence upon
such organisation;
[provisionally agreed at
Trilogue 25/10/2018]

115.
Art. 2, para
(2)
‘text and data
(2) 'text and data mining'
(2)
‘text and data
GREEN
2
mining’ means any
means any automated
mining’ means any
(2) ‘text and data mining’
automated analytical
analytical technique which
automated analytical
means any automated
technique aiming to
analyses works and other
technique aiming to
analytical technique aiming
analyse text and data in
subject matter in digital
analyse text and data in
to analyse text and data in
digital form in order to
form in order to generate
digital form in order to
digital form in order to
generate information such
information, including, but
generate information such
generate information,
as patterns, trends and
not limited to, patterns,
as patterns, trends and
including, but not limited to,
correlations;
trends and correlations.
correlations;
patterns, trends and
correlations;
[provisionally agreed at
Trilogue 25/10/2018]

5

Location
COMMISSION
EP TEXT
COUNCIL TEXT
POSSIBLE
PROPOSAL
COMPROMISE
doc. 9134/18
COM(2016)593
SOLUTION
116.
Art. 2, para
(3)
‘cultural heritage
(3)
‘cultural heritage
(3)
‘cultural heritage
GREEN
3
institution’ means a
institution’ means a
institution’ means a
(3)
‘cultural heritage
publicly accessible library
publicly accessible library
publicly accessible library
institution’ means a publicly
or museum, an archive or a
or museum, an archive or a
or museum, an archive or a
accessible library or
film or audio heritage
film or audio heritage
film or audio heritage
museum, an archive or a film
institution;
institution;
institution;
or audio heritage institution;
[provisionally agreed at
Trilogue 25/10/2018]

117.
Art. 2, para
(4)
‘press publication’
(4) ‘press publication’
(4)
‘press publication’
4
means a fixation of a
means a fixation by
means a fixation of a
collection of literary works
publishers or news
collection composed
of a journalistic nature,
agencies of a collection of
mainly of literary works of
which may also comprise
literary works of a
a journalistic nature, which
other works or subject-
journalistic nature, which
:
matter and constitutes an
may also comprise other
[remaining part of this
individual item within a
works or subject-matter
pargraph was split up in
periodical or regularly-
and constitutes an
points (a) to (d) - see
updated publication under
individual item within a
following rows 118-121]
a single title, such as a
periodical or regularly-
newspaper or a general or
updated publication under
special interest
a single title, such as a
magazine, having the
newspaper or a general or
purpose of providing
special interest magazine,
information related to
having the purpose of
news or other topics and
providing information
published in any media
related to news or other
6

Location
COMMISSION
EP TEXT
COUNCIL TEXT
POSSIBLE
PROPOSAL
COMPROMISE
doc. 9134/18
COM(2016)593
SOLUTION
under the initiative,
topics and published in any
editorial responsibility and
media under the initiative,
control of a service
editorial responsibility and
provider.
control of a service
provider. Periodicals
which are published for
scientific or academic
purposes, such as
scientific journals, shall
not be covered by this
definition;

118.
Art. 2, para
(a)
may also
4, point (a)
compriseinclude other
works or subject-matter
and ;
[See Article 2(4) of COM
proposal and of EP text
(row 117)]

119.
Art. 2, para
(b)
constitutes an
4, point (b)
individual item within a
periodical or regularly-
updated publication under
a single title, such as a
newspaper or a general or
7

Location
COMMISSION
EP TEXT
COUNCIL TEXT
POSSIBLE
PROPOSAL
COMPROMISE
doc. 9134/18
COM(2016)593
SOLUTION
special interest
magazine, ;
[See Article 2(4) of COM
proposal and of EP text
(row 117)]

120.
Art. 2, para
(c)
has having the
4, point (c)
purpose of providing the
general public with
information related to
news or other topicsand
[See Article 2(4) of COM
proposal and of EP text
(row 117)]

121.
Art. 2, para
(d)
is published in any
4, point (d)
media under the initiative,
editorial responsibility and
control of a service
provider.;
[See Article 2(4) of COM
proposal and of EP text
(row 117)]

122.
Art. 2, para
(4a) ‘out of commerce
4a,
work’ means:
8

Location
COMMISSION
EP TEXT
COUNCIL TEXT
POSSIBLE
PROPOSAL
COMPROMISE
doc. 9134/18
COM(2016)593
SOLUTION
introductory
part
123.
Art. 2, para
(a) an entire work or
4a, point (a)
other subject matter in
any version or
manifestation that is no
longer available to the
public in a Member State
through customary
channels of commerce;

124.
Art. 2, para
(b) a work or other
4a, point (b)
subject matter that has
never been in commerce
in a Member State, unless,
from the circumstances of
that case, it is apparent
that its author objected to
making it available to the
public;

125.
Art. 2,
(4b) ‘online content
(5)
‘online content
para 4b
sharing service provider’
sharing service provider’
means a provider of an
means a provider of an
information society

9

Location
COMMISSION
EP TEXT
COUNCIL TEXT
POSSIBLE
PROPOSAL
COMPROMISE
doc. 9134/18
COM(2016)593
SOLUTION
(EP)/para 5
information society
service whose main or
(Council)
service one of the main
one of the main purposes
purposes of which is to
is to store and give the
public access to a large

store and give access to
amount of works or other
the public to a significant
subject-matter uploaded
amount of copyright
by its users which it
protected works or other
organises and promotes
protected subject-matter
for profit-making
uploaded by its users,
purposes.
which the service
Providers of services
optimises and promotes
such as non-for-profit
for profit making
online encyclopaedias,
purposes.
non-for-profit
educational and scientific

Microenterprises and
repositories, non-for-
small-sized enterprises
profit open source
within the meaning of
software developing
Title I of the Annex to
platforms, as well as
Commission
internet access service
Recommendation
providers, online
marketplaces and

2003/361/EC and services
providers of cloud
acting in a non-
services which allow
commercial purpose
users, including
capacity such as online
businesses for their
encyclopaedia, and
internal purposes, to
10

Location
COMMISSION
EP TEXT
COUNCIL TEXT
POSSIBLE
PROPOSAL
COMPROMISE
doc. 9134/18
COM(2016)593
SOLUTION
providers of online
upload content for their
services where the content
own use shall not be
is uploaded with the
considered online content
sharing service providers

authorisation of all right
within the meaning of
holders concerned, such
this Directive;
as educational or
scientific repositories,
shall not be considered
online content sharing
service providers within
the meaning of this
Directive. Providers of
cloud services for
individual use which do
not provide direct access
to the public, open source
software developing
platforms, and online
market places whose main
activity is online retail of
physical goods, should not
be considered online
content sharing service

11

Location
COMMISSION
EP TEXT
COUNCIL TEXT
POSSIBLE
PROPOSAL
COMPROMISE
doc. 9134/18
COM(2016)593
SOLUTION
providers within the
meaning of this Directive;

126.
Art. 2,
(4c) ‘information society
(6) ‘information society
para 4c
service’ means a service
service’ means a service
(EP)/para 6
within the meaning of
within the meaning of
(Council)
point (b) of Article 1(1) of
Article 1(1)(b) of
Directive (EU) 2015/1535
Directive (EU) 2015/1535.
of the European
Parliament and of the
Council1a;

___________
1a Directive (EU)
2015/1535 of the
European Parliament and
of the Council of 9
September 2015 laying
down a procedure for the
provision of information
in the field of technical
regulations and of rules
on Information Society
services (OJ L 241,
17.9.2015, p. 1).

12

Location
COMMISSION
EP TEXT
COUNCIL TEXT
POSSIBLE
PROPOSAL
COMPROMISE
doc. 9134/18
COM(2016)593
SOLUTION
127.
Art. 2, para
(4d) ‘automated image
4d
referencing service’
means any online service
which reproduces or
makes available to the
public for indexing and
referencing purposes
graphic or art works or
photographic works
collected by automated
means via a third-party
online service.

128.
TITLE II
TITLE II
TITLE II
TITLE II
MEASURES TO ADAPT
MEASURES TO ADAPT
MEASURES TO ADAPT
MEASURES TO ADAPT
EXCEPTIONS AND
EXCEPTIONS AND
EXCEPTIONS AND
EXCEPTIONS AND
LIMITATIONS TO THE
LIMITATIONS TO THE
LIMITATIONS TO THE
LIMITATIONS TO THE
DIGITAL AND CROSS-
DIGITAL AND CROSS-
DIGITAL AND CROSS-
DIGITAL AND CROSS-
BORDER
BORDER
BORDER
BORDER ENVIRONMENT
ENVIRONMENT
ENVIRONMENT
ENVIRONMENT
Article 3
129.
Art. 3,
Article 3
Article 3
GREEN
Text and data mining for
Text and data mining
Text and data mining
title
the purposes of scientific
Article 3
research
Text and data mining for the
purposes of scientific
research
13

Location
COMMISSION
EP TEXT
COUNCIL TEXT
POSSIBLE
PROPOSAL
COMPROMISE
doc. 9134/18
COM(2016)593
SOLUTION
[provisionally agreed at
Trilogue 25/10/2018]

130.
Art. 3, para
1.
Member States
1. Member States shall
1.
.Member States
GREEN
1
shall provide for an
provide for an exception to
shall provide for an
1. Member States shall
exception to the rights
the rights provided for in
exception to the rights
provide for an exception to
provided for in Article 2 of
Article 2 of Directive
provided for in Article 2 of
the rights provided for in
Directive 2001/29/EC,
2001/29/EC, Articles 5(a)
Directive 2001/29/EC,
Article 2 of Directive
Articles 5(a) and 7(1) of
and 7(1) of Directive
Articles 5(a) and 7(1) of
2001/29/EC, Articles 5(a)
Directive 96/9/EC and
96/9/EC and Article 11(1)
Directive 96/9/EC and
and 7(1) of Directive
Article 11(1) of this
of this Directive for
Article 11(1) of this
96/9/EC and Article 11(1) of
Directive for reproductions
reproductions and
Directive for reproductions
this Directive for
and extractions made by
extractions made by
and extractions made by
reproductions and
research organisations in
research organisations in
research organisations and
extractions made by research
order to carry out text and
order to carry out text and
cultural heritage
organisations and cultural
data mining of works or
data mining of works or
institutions in order to
heritage institutions in order
other subject-matter to
other subject-matter to
carry out text and data
to carry out text and data
which they have lawful
which they have lawful
mining of works or other
mining of works or other
access for the purposes of
access research
subject-matter to which
subject-matter to which they
scientific research.
organisations have lawful
they have lawful access,
have lawful access, for the
access and made in order
for the purposes of
purposes of scientific
to carry out text and data
scientific research.
research.
mining for the purposes of
scientific research by such
[provisionally agreed at
organisations.
Trilogue 25/10/2018]
Member States shall
provide for educational

14

Location
COMMISSION
EP TEXT
COUNCIL TEXT
POSSIBLE
PROPOSAL
COMPROMISE
doc. 9134/18
COM(2016)593
SOLUTION
establishments and
cultural heritage
institutions conducting
scientific research within
the meaning of point
(1)(a) or (1)(b) of Article
2, in such a way that the
access to the results
generated by the scientific
research cannot be
enjoyed on a preferential
basis by an undertaking
exercising a decisive
influence upon such
organisations, to also be
able to benefit from the
exception provided for in
this Article.

131.
Art. 3, para
1a.
Reproductions and
1a.Copies of works or
GREEN
1a
extractions made for text
other subject-matter
1a. Copies of works or other
and data mining purposes
made in compliance
subject-matter made in
shall be stored in a secure
with paragraph 1 shall
compliance with paragraph
manner, for example by
be stored with an
1 shall be stored with an
trusted bodies appointed
appropriate level of
appropriate level of security
for this purpose.
security and not be
and may be retained for the
retained for longer
purposes of scientific
than necessary for
15

Location
COMMISSION
EP TEXT
COUNCIL TEXT
POSSIBLE
PROPOSAL
COMPROMISE
doc. 9134/18
COM(2016)593
SOLUTION
achieving the purposes
research, including for the
of scientific research.
verification of research
results.

[provisionally agreed at
Trilogue 25/10/2018]

132.
Art. 3, para
2.
Any contractual
2.
Any contractual
2. [Moved to Article 6(1)]
GREEN
2
provision contrary to the
provision contrary to the
[Moved to Article 6(1)]
exception provided for in
exception provided for in
paragraph 1 shall be
paragraph 1 shall be
[provisionally agreed at
unenforceable.
unenforceable.
Trilogue 25/10/2018]
[See Council’s Article 6(1)
(row 155)]

133.
Art. 3, para
3.
Rightholders shall
3.
Rightholders shall
3.
Rightholders shall
GREEN
3
be allowed to apply
be allowed to apply
be allowed to apply
3.
Rightholders shall be
measures to ensure the
measures to ensure the
measures to ensure the
allowed to apply measures to
security and integrity of
security and integrity of
security and integrity of
ensure the security and
the networks and databases
the networks and databases
the networks and databases
integrity of the networks and
where the works or other
where the works or other
where the works or other
databases where the works
subject-matter are hosted.
subject-matter are hosted.
subject-matter are hosted.
or other subject-matter are
Such measures shall not go
Such measures shall not go
Such measures shall not go
hosted. Such measures shall
beyond what is necessary
beyond what is necessary
beyond what is necessary
not go beyond what is
to achieve that objective.
to achieve that objective.
to achieve that objective.
necessary to achieve that
objective.
16

Location
COMMISSION
EP TEXT
COUNCIL TEXT
POSSIBLE
PROPOSAL
COMPROMISE
doc. 9134/18
COM(2016)593
SOLUTION
[provisionally agreed at
Trilogue 25/10/2018]

134.
Art. 3, para
4.
Member States
4.
Member States
4.
Member States
GREEN
4
shall encourage
shall encourage
shall encourage
4.
Member States shall
rightholders and research
rightholders and research
rightholders andresearch
encourage rightholders and,
organisations and cultural
organisations to define
organisations to define
heritage institutions to
research organisations and
commonly-agreed best
commonly-agreed best
define commonly-agreed
cultural heritage institutions
practices concerning the
practices concerning the
best practices concerning
to define commonly-agreed
application of the measures
application of the measures
the application of the
best practices concerning the
referred to in paragraph 3.
referred to in paragraph
obligation and measures
application of the obligation
3.may continue to provide
referred to respectively in
and measures referred to
text and data mining
paragraphs 1a and 3.
respectively in paragraphs 1a
exceptions in accordance
and 3.
with point (a) of Article
[provisionally agreed at
5(3) of Directive
Trilogue 26 November]
2001/29/EC.
[the relation with existing
exceptions under InfoSoc
Directive under Article 17a
(see row 306)]

17

Location
COMMISSION
EP TEXT
COUNCIL TEXT
POSSIBLE
PROPOSAL
COMPROMISE
doc. 9134/18
COM(2016)593
SOLUTION
135.
Art. 3a, title
Article 3a
Article 3a
Article 3a
Optional exception or
Optional exception or
Optional exception or
limitation for text and
limitation for text and
limitation for text and data
data mining
data mining
mining
136.
Art. 3a, para
1.
Without prejudice
1.
Without prejudice
1. Without prejudice to
1
to Article 3 of this
to Article 3 of this
Article 3 of this Directive,
Directive, Member States
Directive Member States
Member States may/shall
may provide for an
may provide for an
provide for an exception or
exception or a limitation
exception or a limitation
a limitation to the rights
to the rights provided for
to the rights provided for
in Article 2 of Directive
provided for in Article 2 of
in Article 2 of Directive
2001/29/EC, Articles 5(a)
Directive 2001/29/EC,
2001/29/EC, Articles 5(a)
and 7(1) of Directive
Articles 5(a) and 7(1) of
and 7(1) of Directive
96/9/EC and Article 11(1)
Directive 96/9/EC, Article
96/9/EC and Article 11(1)
of this Directive for
4(1)(a) and (b) of Directive
temporary reproductions
of this Directive for
2009/24/EC and Article
and extractions of
reproductions and
lawfully accessible works
11(1) of this Directive for
extractions of lawfully
and other subject-matter
temporary reproductions
accessible works and
that form a part of the
and extractions of lawfully
other subject-matter that
process of text and data
accessible works and other
form a part of the process
mining.
subject-matter that form a
of text and data mining,
part of the process for the
provided that the use of
works and other subject

18

Location
COMMISSION
EP TEXT
COUNCIL TEXT
POSSIBLE
PROPOSAL
COMPROMISE
doc. 9134/18
COM(2016)593
SOLUTION
matter referred to therein
purposes of text and data
has not been expressly
mining.
reserved by their
[COM suggestion to turn the
rightholders, including by
optional exception into a
machine readable means.
mandatory one by replacing
“may provide” by “shall
provide” to be discussed
further at political level.

Apart from 'may' or 'shall',
text of Article 3a
provisionally agreed at
trilogue 26/11/2018 as set
out in rows 136, 137, 138
and 139]

137.
Art. 3a, para
2.
Reproductions
GREEN
2 (EP)
and extractions made
2.
Reproductions and
pursuant to paragraph 1
extractions made pursuant
shall not be used for
to paragraph 1 may be
purposes other than text
retained as long as
and data mining.
19

Location
COMMISSION
EP TEXT
COUNCIL TEXT
POSSIBLE
PROPOSAL
COMPROMISE
doc. 9134/18
COM(2016)593
SOLUTION
necessary for the purposes
of text and data mining.

[provisionally agreed at
Trilogue 25/10/2018 /
26/11/2018]

138.
Art. 3a, para
2.
The exception or
GREEN
2 (Council)
limitation provided for in
2.
The exception or
paragraph 1 shall apply
limitation provided for in
provided that the use of
paragraph 1 shall apply
works and other subject
provided that the use of
matter referred to
works and other subject
therein has not been
matter referred to therein
expressly reserved by
has not been expressly
their rightholders
reserved by their
including by technical
rightholders in an
means.
appropriate manner, such
[See para. 1 of EP text
as machine readable means
(row 136)]
for the content made
publicly available online
.
[provisionally agreed at
Trilogue 26/11/2018 in

20

Location
COMMISSION
EP TEXT
COUNCIL TEXT
POSSIBLE
PROPOSAL
COMPROMISE
doc. 9134/18
COM(2016)593
SOLUTION
conjunction with wording of
recital (13a) (row 28)]

139.
Art. 3a, para
3.
Member States
GREEN
3
may continue to provide
3. This Article shall not
text and data mining
affect the application of
exceptions in accordance
Article 3 of this Directive.
with point (a) of Article 5
(3) of Directive

[This phrase replaces the
2001/29/EC.
'Without prejudice'-
clarification previously
contained in paragraph 1.

[provisionaly agreed at
Trilogue 26/11/2018]

Agreed at Trilogue
25/10/2018 to introduce the
relation with existing
exceptions under InfoSoc
Directive under Article 17a
(see row 306)]

140.
Art. 4,
Article 4
Article 4
Article 4
Article 4
Use of works and other
Use of works and other
Use of works and other
Use of works and other
title
subject-matter in digital
subject-matter in digital
subject-matter in digital
subject-matter in digital and
21

Location
COMMISSION
EP TEXT
COUNCIL TEXT
POSSIBLE
PROPOSAL
COMPROMISE
doc. 9134/18
COM(2016)593
SOLUTION
and cross-border teaching
and cross-border teaching
and cross-border teaching
cross-border teaching
activities
activities
activities
activities
141.
Art. 4, para
1.
Member States
1.
Member States
1.
Member States
GREEN
1
shall provide for an
shall provide for an
shall provide for an
1. Member States shall
exception or limitation to
exception or limitation to
exception or limitation to
provide for an exception or
the rights provided for in
the rights provided for in
the rights provided for in
limitation to the rights
Articles 2 and 3 of
Articles 2 and 3 of
Articles 2 and 3 of
provided for in Articles 2
Directive 2001/29/EC,
Directive 2001/29/EC,
Directive 2001/29/EC,
and 3 of Directive
Articles 5(a) and 7(1) of
Articles 5(a) and 7(1) of
Articles 5(a), (b), (d) and
2001/29/EC, Articles 5(a),
Directive 96/9/EC, Article
Directive 96/9/EC, Article
(e) and Article 7(1) of
(b), (d) and (e) and 7(1) of
4(1) of Directive
4(1) of Directive
Directive 96/9/EC, Article
Directive 96/9/EC, Article
2009/24/EC and Article
2009/24/EC and Article
4(1)(a) and (b) of
4(1)(a), and (b) of Directive
11(1) of this Directive in
11(1) of this Directive in
Directive 2009/24/EC and
2009/24/EC and Article
order to allow for the
order to allow for the
Article 11(1) of this
11(1) of this Directive in
digital use of works and
digital use of works and
Directive in order to allow
order to allow the digital use
other subject-matter for the
other subject-matter for the
for the digital use of works
of works and other subject-
sole purpose of illustration
sole purpose of illustration
and other subject-matter
matter for the sole purpose
for teaching, to the extent
for teaching, to the extent
for the sole purpose of
of illustration for teaching, to
justified by the non-
justified by the non-
illustration for teaching, to
the extent justified by the
commercial purpose to be
commercial purpose to be
the extent justified by the
non-commercial purpose to
achieved, provided that the
achieved, provided that the
non-commercial purpose to
be achieved, provided that
use:
use:
be achieved, provided that
such use:
thesuch use:
[provisionally agreed at
Trilogue 26/11/2018;
reference to Directive
2009/24/EC agreed provided

22

Location
COMMISSION
EP TEXT
COUNCIL TEXT
POSSIBLE
PROPOSAL
COMPROMISE
doc. 9134/18
COM(2016)593
SOLUTION
that it is clarified in a recital
that distribution of software
allowed under the exception
is limited to digital
transmission of software]

142.
Art. 4, para
(a)
takes place on the
(a)
takes place on the
(a)
takes place
GREEN
1, point (a)
premises of an educational
premises of an educational
onunder the premises
(a) takes place under the
establishment or through a
establishment, or in any
responsibility of an
responsibility of an
secure electronic network
other venue in which the
educational establishment,
educational establishment,
accessible only by the
teaching activity takes
on its premises or other
on its premises or other
educational establishment's
place under the
venues, or through a
venues, or through a secure
pupils or students and
responsibility of the
secure electronic network
electronic environment
teaching staff;
educational establishment, accessible only by the
accessible only by the
or through a secure
educational establishment's
educational establishment's
electronic network
pupils or students and
pupils or students and
environment accessible
teaching staff; and
teaching staff; and
only by the educational
establishment's pupils or
[provisionally agreed at
students and teaching staff;
Trilogue 26/11/2018
together with text on recital
16a, row 33]

143.
Art. 4, para
(b)
is accompanied by
(b)
is accompanied by
(b)
is accompanied by
GREEN
1, point (b)
the indication of the
the indication of the
the indication of the
(b) is accompanied by the
source, including the
source, including the
source, including the
indication of the source,
author's name, unless this
author's name, unless this
author's name, unless this
including the author's name,
turns out to be impossible.
turns out to be impossible
turns out to be impossible.
23

Location
COMMISSION
EP TEXT
COUNCIL TEXT
POSSIBLE
PROPOSAL
COMPROMISE
doc. 9134/18
COM(2016)593
SOLUTION
for reasons of
unless this turns out to be
practicability.
impossible.
[provisionally agreed at
Trilogue 25/10/2018]

144.
Art. 4, para
2.
Member States may 2.
Member States may 2.
Notwithstanding
GREEN
2, sub-
provide that the exception
provide that the exception
Article 6(1), Member
2. Notwithstanding Article
para 1
adopted pursuant to
adopted pursuant to
States may provide that the
6(1), Member States may
paragraph 1 does not apply
paragraph 1 does not apply
exception adopted pursuant
provide that the exception
generally or as regards
generally or as regards
to paragraph 1 does not
adopted pursuant to
specific types of works or
specific types of works or
apply generally or as
paragraph 1 does not apply
other subject-matter, to the
other subject-matter, such
regards specific uses or
generally or as regards
extent that adequate
as material which is
types of works or other
specific uses or types of
licences authorising the
primarily intended for the
subject-matter, to the
works or other subject-
acts described in paragraph
educational market or
extent that adequate
matter, such as material
1 are easily available in the
sheet music, to the extent
licences covering the
which is primarily intended
market.
that adequate licences
needs of educational
for the educational market
licencing agreements
establishments and
or sheet music, to the extent
authorising the acts
authorising the acts
that suitable licences
described in paragraph 1
described in paragraph 1
authorising the acts
and tailored to the needs
are easily available in the
described in paragraph 1
and specificities of
market.
covering the needs and
educational
specificities of educational
establishments are easily
establishments are easily
available in the market.
available in the market.
[provisionally agreed at
Trilogue 25/10/2018 /

24

Location
COMMISSION
EP TEXT
COUNCIL TEXT
POSSIBLE
PROPOSAL
COMPROMISE
doc. 9134/18
COM(2016)593
SOLUTION
26/11/2018 together with
text on recitals (16) and
(17), rows 32 and 35 tbc by
trilogue]

145.
Art. 4, para
Member States availing
Member States availing
Member States availing
GREEN
2, sub-para
themselves of the
themselves of the
themselves of the
Member States availing
2
provision of the first
provision of the first
provision of the first
themselves of the provision
subparagraph shall take the
subparagraph shall take the
subparagraph shall take the
of the first subparagraph
necessary measures to
necessary measures to
necessary measures to
shall take the necessary
ensure appropriate
ensure appropriate
ensure appropriate
measures to ensure
availability and visibility
availability and visibility
availability and visibility
appropriate availability and
of the licences authorising
of the licences authorising
ofthat rightholders make
visibility of the licences
the acts described in
the acts described in
the licences authorising the
authorising the acts
paragraph 1 for
paragraph 1 for
acts described in paragraph
described in paragraph 1 for
educational establishments.
educational establishments.
available and visible for
educational establishments.
educational establishments.
[provisionally agreed at
Trilogue 26/11/2018
together with text on recital
(17) and (17a), rows 35 and
36]

146.
Art. 4, para
3.
The use of works
3.
The use of works
3.
The use of works
GREEN
3
and other subject-matter
and other subject-matter
and other subject-matter
3. The use of works and
for the sole purpose of
for the sole purpose of
for the sole purpose of
other subject-matter for the
illustration for teaching
illustration for teaching
illustration for teaching
sole purpose of illustration
through secure electronic
through secure electronic
through secure electronic
for teaching through secure
25

Location
COMMISSION
EP TEXT
COUNCIL TEXT
POSSIBLE
PROPOSAL
COMPROMISE
doc. 9134/18
COM(2016)593
SOLUTION
networks undertaken in
networks environments
networks undertaken in
electronic environments
compliance with the
undertaken in compliance
compliance with the
undertaken in compliance
provisions of national law
with the provisions of
provisions of national law
with the provisions of
adopted pursuant to this
national law adopted
adopted pursuant to this
national law adopted
Article shall be deemed to
pursuant to this Article
Article shall be deemed to
pursuant to this Article shall
occur solely in the Member
shall be deemed to occur
occur solely in the
be deemed to occur solely in
State where the
solely in the Member State
Member State where the
the Member State where the
educational establishment
where the educational
educational establishment
educational establishment is
is established.
establishment is
is established.
established.
established.
[provisionally agreed at
Trilogue 25/10/2018 /
26/11/2018 together with
text on recital 16a, row 33]

147.
Art. 4, para
4.
Member States may 4.
Member States
4.
Member States may
GREEN
4
provide for fair
may provide for fair
provide for fair
4.
Member States may
compensation for the harm
compensation for the harm
compensation for the harm
provide for fair
incurred by the
incurred by the
incurred by theto
compensation for the harm
rightholders due to the use
rightholders due to the use
rightholders due to the use
incurred by the to
of their works or other
of their works or other
of their works or other
rightholders due to the use of
subject-matter pursuant to
subject-matter pursuant to
subject-matter pursuant to
their works or other subject-
paragraph 1.
paragraph 1.
paragraph 1.
matter pursuant to paragraph
1.
[provisionally agreed at
Trilogue 25/10/2018 /

26

Location
COMMISSION
EP TEXT
COUNCIL TEXT
POSSIBLE
PROPOSAL
COMPROMISE
doc. 9134/18
COM(2016)593
SOLUTION
26/11/2018 together with
text on recital (17a), row 36]

148.
Art. 4, para
4a.
Without prejudice
[provisionally agreed at
4a
to paragraph 2, any
trilogue 25/10/2018 to deal
contractual provision
with contractual override
contrary to the exception
under Article 6(1)]
or limitation adopted
[Issue of royalty-free
pursuant to paragraph 1
licences to be further
shall be unenforceable.
discussed in the context of
Member States shall
the remuneration chapter
ensure that rightholders
and recital (40) of the
have the right to grant
Council]
royalty-free licences
authorising the acts
described in paragraph 1,
generally or as regards
specific types of works or
other subject-matter that
they may choose.
[See Council’s Article 6(1)
(row 155)]

149.
Art. 5, title
Article 5
Article 5
Article 5
Article 5
Preservation of cultural
Preservation of cultural
Preservation of cultural
Preservation of cultural
heritage
heritage
heritage
heritage
27

Location
COMMISSION
EP TEXT
COUNCIL TEXT
POSSIBLE
PROPOSAL
COMPROMISE
doc. 9134/18
COM(2016)593
SOLUTION
150.
Art. 5, [para
Member States shall
1.
Member States
Member States shall
GREEN
1 (EP)]
provide for an exception to
shall provide for an
provide for an exception to
Member States shall provide
the rights provided for in
exception to the rights
the rights provided for in
for an exception to the rights
Article 2 of Directive
provided for in Article 2 of
Article 2 of Directive
provided for in Article 2 of
2001/29/EC, Articles 5(a)
Directive 2001/29/EC,
2001/29/EC, Articles 5(a)
Directive 2001/29/EC,
and 7(1) of Directive
Articles 5(a) and 7(1) of
and 7(1) of Directive
Articles 5(a) and 7(1) of
96/9/EC, Article 4(1)(a) of
Directive 96/9/EC, Article
96/9/EC, Article 4(1)(a) of
Directive 96/9/EC, Article
Directive 2009/24/EC and
4(1)(a) of Directive
Directive 2009/24/EC and
4(1)(a) of Directive
Article 11(1) of this
2009/24/EC and Article
Article 11(1) of this
2009/24/EC and Article
Directive, permitting
11(1) of this Directive,
Directive, permitting
11(1) of this Directive,
cultural heritage
permitting cultural heritage
cultural heritage
permitting cultural heritage
institutions, to make copies
institutions to make copies
institutions, to make copies
institutions to make copies
of any works or other
of any works or other
of any works or other
of any works or other
subject-matter that are
subject-matter that are
subject-matter that are
subject-matter that are
permanently in their
permanently in their
permanently in their
permanently in their
collections, in any format
collections, in any format
collections, in any format
collections, in any format or
or medium, for the sole
or medium, for the sole
or medium, for the sole
medium, for purposes of
purpose of the preservation
purpose purposes of
purpose of the preservation
preservation of such works
of such works or other
preservation of such works
of such works or other
or other subject-matter and
subject-matter and to the
or other subject-matter and
subject-matter and to the
to the extent necessary for
extent necessary for such
to the extent necessary for
extent necessary for such
such preservation.
preservation.
such preservation.
preservation.
[provisionally agreed at
trilogue 25/10/2018]
151.
Art. 5, para
1a.
Member States
[To be further discussed at
1a
shall ensure that any
political level; COM to
material resulting from an
provide drafting suggestion
28

Location
COMMISSION
EP TEXT
COUNCIL TEXT
POSSIBLE
PROPOSAL
COMPROMISE
doc. 9134/18
COM(2016)593
SOLUTION
act of reproduction of
for this EP issue, to be
material in the public
further discussed with
domain shall not be
Council; this suggestion
subject to copyright or
should cover only non-
related rights, provided
original reproduction of
that such reproduction is
works for which the term of
a faithful reproduction for
protection has elapsed; not
purposes of preservation
using the terms „public
of the original material.
domain“, „faithful
reproduction“; the recitals
to clarify that this does not
affect other rights, such as
property rights]

152.
Art. 5, para
1b. Any contractual
GREEN
1b
provision contrary to the
[provisionally agreed at
exception provided for in
trilogue 25/10/2018 to deal
paragraph 1 shall be
with contractual override
unenforceable.
under Article 6(1)]
[See Council’s Article 6(1)
(row 155)]

153.
Art. 6,
Article 6
Article 6
Article 6
Article 6
title
Common provisions
Common provisions
Common provisions
Common provisions
29

Location
COMMISSION
EP TEXT
COUNCIL TEXT
POSSIBLE
PROPOSAL
COMPROMISE
doc. 9134/18
COM(2016)593
SOLUTION
154.
Art. 6, para
1.
Accessing content
[To be discussed further at
1 (EP)
covered by an exception
political level; COM to
provided for in this
provide a technical note
Directive shall not confer
clarifying situation
on users any entitlement
according to jurisprudence,
to use it pursuant to
not restricting the notion of
another exception.
“lawful access”]
155.
Art. 6, para
1.
Any contractual
GREEN
1 (Council)
provision contrary to the
1. Any contractual provision
exceptions provided for in
contrary to the exceptions
Articles 3, 4(1) and 5
provided for in Articles 3, 4
shall be unenforceable.
and 5 shall be
[See Article 3(2) of the
unenforceable.
COM proposal and
Parliament’s Articles 3(2)
[provisionally agreed at
trilogue 25/10/2018]
and 4(4a) and 5(1b)]
156.
Art. 6, para
Article 5(5) and the first,
2.
Article 5(5) and the
2.
Article 5(5) and
2.  Article  5(5)  of  Directive
2
third and fifth
first, third, fourth and fifth
theof Directive
2001/29/EC  shall  apply  to  the
subparagraphs of Article
subparagraphs of Article
2001/29/EC shall apply to
exceptions  and  the  limitation
6(4) of Directive
6(4) of Directive
the exceptions and the
provided  for  under  this  Title.
2001/29/EC shall apply to
2001/29/EC shall apply to
The  first,  third  and  fifth
limitation provided for
subparagraphs of Article 6(4) of
the exceptions and the
the exceptions and the
under this Title. The first,
Directive 
2001/29/EC 
shall
third and fifth
30

Location
COMMISSION
EP TEXT
COUNCIL TEXT
POSSIBLE
PROPOSAL
COMPROMISE
doc. 9134/18
COM(2016)593
SOLUTION
limitation provided for
limitation provided for
subparagraphs of Article
apply  to  Articles  3,  4  and  5  of
under this Title.
under this Title.
6(4) of Directive
this Directive.
2001/29/EC shall apply to
[EP agrees to drop reference
the exceptionsArticles 3,
to the fourth subparagraph
4(1) and the limitation
of Article 6(4) of Directive
provided for under5 of this
2001/29/EC;
TitleDirective.
EP: second sentence to be
left open until discussions on
Article 7 finalised]

157.
TITLE III
TITLE III
TITLE III
TITLE III
MEASURES TO
MEASURES TO
MEASURES TO
MEASURES TO IMPROVE
IMPROVE LICENSING
IMPROVE LICENSING
IMPROVE LICENSING
LICENSING PRACTICES
PRACTICES AND
PRACTICES AND
PRACTICES AND
AND ENSURE WIDER
ENSURE WIDER
ENSURE WIDER
ENSURE WIDER
ACCESS TO CONTENT
ACCESS TO CONTENT
ACCESS TO CONTENT
ACCESS TO CONTENT
158.
CHAPTER 1
CHAPTER 1
CHAPTER 1
CHAPTER 1
Out-of-commerce works
Out-of-commerce works
Out-of-commerce works
Out-of-commerce works
159.
Art. 7, title
Article 7
Article 7
Article 7
Article 7
Use of out-of-commerce
Use of out-of-commerce
Use of out-of-commerce
Use of out-of-commerce
works by cultural heritage
works by cultural heritage
works by cultural heritage
works by cultural heritage
institutions
institutions
institutions
institutions
160.
Art. 7, para
1.
Member States
1.
Member States
1.
Member States
GREEN
1,
shall provide that when a
shall provide that when a
shall provide that when a
31

Location
COMMISSION
EP TEXT
COUNCIL TEXT
POSSIBLE
PROPOSAL
COMPROMISE
doc. 9134/18
COM(2016)593
SOLUTION
introductory
collective management
collective management
collective management
1.
Member States shall
part
organisation, on behalf of
organisation, on behalf of
organisation, on behalf of
provide that a collective
its members, concludes a
its members, concludes a
in accordance with its
management organisation, in
non-exclusive licence for
non-exclusive licence for
members,
accordance with its
non-commercial purposes
non-commercial purposes
concludesmandates, may
mandates, may conclude a
with a cultural heritage
with a cultural heritage
conclude a non-exclusive
non-exclusive licence for
institution for the
institution for the
licence for non-
non-commercial purposes
digitisation, distribution,
digitisation, distribution,
commercial purposes with
with a cultural heritage
communication to the
communication to the
a cultural heritage
institution for the
public or making available
public or making available
institution for the
reproduction, distribution,
of out-of-commerce works
of out-of-commerce works
digitisationreproduction,
communication to the public
or other subject-matter
or other subject-matter
distribution,
or making available to the
permanently in the
permanently in the
communication to the
public of out-of-commerce
collection of the
collection of the
public or making available
works or other subject-
institution, such a non-
institution, such a non-
to the public of out-of-
matter permanently in the
exclusive licence may be
exclusive licence may be
commerce works or other
collection of the institution,
extended or presumed to
extended or presumed to
subject-matter permanently
irrespective of whether all
apply to rightholders of the
apply to rightholders of the
in the collection of the
rightholders covered by the
same category as those
same category as those
institution, such a non-
licence have mandated the
covered by the licence who
covered by the licence who
exclusive licence may be
collective management
are not represented by the
are not represented by the
extended or presumed to
organisation, provided that:
collective management
collective management
apply to rightholders of the
organisation, provided
organisation, provided
same category as those
that:
that:
irrespective of whether
[provisionally agreed at
all rightholders covered
Trilogue 26/11/2018]
by the licence who are not
represented byhave
mandated 
the collective
32

Location
COMMISSION
EP TEXT
COUNCIL TEXT
POSSIBLE
PROPOSAL
COMPROMISE
doc. 9134/18
COM(2016)593
SOLUTION
management organisation,
provided that:
161.
Art. 7, para
(a)
the collective
(a)
the collective
(a)
the collective
GREEN
1, point (a)
management organisation
management organisation
management organisation
(a)
the collective
is, on the basis of mandates
is, on the basis of mandates
is, on the basis of
management organisation is,
from rightholders, broadly
from rightholders, broadly
mandates from
on the basis of mandates
representative of
representative of
rightholders,
from rightholders,
rightholders in the
rightholders in the
broadlysufficiently
sufficiently representative of
category of works or other
category of works or other
representative of
rightholders in the relevant
subject-matter and of the
subject-matter and of the
rightholders in the
type of works or other
rights which are the subject
rights which are the subject
categoryrelevant type of
subject-matter and of the
of the licence;
of the licence;
works or other subject-
rights which are the subject
matter and of the rights
of the licence;
which are the subject of
the licence;
[provisionaly agreed at
Trilogue 26/11/2018; to be
further discussed whether

the meaning of “sufficiently
representative” should be
further clarified in the
recitals]

162.
Art. 7, para
(b)
equal treatment is
(b)
equal treatment is
(b)
equal treatment is
(b)
equal treatment is
1, point (b)
guaranteed to all
guaranteed to all
guaranteed to all
guaranteed to all rightholders
rightholders in relation to
rightholders in relation to
rightholders in relation to
in relation to the terms of the
the terms of the licence;
the terms of the licence;
the terms of the licence;
licence.
33

Location
COMMISSION
EP TEXT
COUNCIL TEXT
POSSIBLE
PROPOSAL
COMPROMISE
doc. 9134/18
COM(2016)593
SOLUTION
163.
Art. 7, para
(c)
all rightholders
(c)
all rightholders
(c)
all rightholders
GREEN
1, point (c)
may at any time object to
may at any time object to
may at any time object
[This point is moved to new
their works or other
their works or other
toexclude the possibility
paragraph 1b below – row 167]
subject-matter being
subject-matter being
for collective
deemed to be out of
deemed to be out of
management
[provisionaly agreed at
commerce and exclude the
commerce and exclude the
organisations to license
Trilogue 26/11/2018]
application of the licence
application of the licence
their works or other
to their works or other
to their works or other
subject-matter being
subject-matter.
subject-matter.
deemed to be out of
commerce and in
accordance with this
Article, either in general
or in specific cases, or
exclude the application of
theany licence granted in
accordance with this
Article 
to their works or
other subject-matter.
164.
Art. 7, para
1a.
Member States
1a.
Member States shall
1a
shall provide for an
provide for an exception or
exception or limitation to
limitation to the rights
the rights provided for in
provided for in Articles 2
Articles 2 and 3 of
and 3 of Directive
Directive 2001/29/EC,
2001/29/EC, Articles 5(a),
Articles 5(a) and 7(1) of
(b), (d) and (e) and 7(1) of
Directive 96/9/EC, Article
Directive 96/9/EC, Article
34

Location
COMMISSION
EP TEXT
COUNCIL TEXT
POSSIBLE
PROPOSAL
COMPROMISE
doc. 9134/18
COM(2016)593
SOLUTION
4(1) of Directive
4(1) of Directive
2009/24/EC, and Article
2009/24/EC, and Article
11(1) of this Directive,
11(1) of this Directive, in
permitting cultural
order to allow cultural
heritage institutions to
heritage institutions to make
make copies available
available out-of-commerce
online of out-of-commerce
works or other subject-
works that are located
matter that are permanently
permanently in their
in their collections for non-
collections for not-for-
commercial purposes,
profit purposes, provided
provided that:
that:
[to be discussed further]
165.
Art. 7, para
(a)
the name of the
(a)
[the author or any
1a, point (a)
author or any other
other identifiable
identifiable rightholder is
rightholder was informed
indicated, unless this
individually at least six
turns out to be impossible;
months before the use,
unless this turns out to be
impossible, and
] the name
of the author or any other
identifiable rightholder is
indicated, unless this turns
out to be impossible;

[Council to get back to
Member States on the

35

Location
COMMISSION
EP TEXT
COUNCIL TEXT
POSSIBLE
PROPOSAL
COMPROMISE
doc. 9134/18
COM(2016)593
SOLUTION
deletion of the part in
strikethrough]

166.
Art. 7, para
(b)
all rightholders
(b)
such works or other
1a, point (b)
may at any time object to
subject-matter are made
their works or other
available on dedicated non-
subject-matter being
commercial portals
deemed to be out of
websites [which are
commerce and exclude the
accessible on the premises
application of the
of cultural heritage
exception to their works or
institutions].
other subject-matter.
[Text of EP covered in new
paragraph 1b below – row
167; Council to get back to
Member States on the
deletion of the part in
strikethrough]

167.
Art. 7, para
1b.
Member States
GREEN
1b
shall provide that the
1b. Member States shall
exception adopted
provide that the exception or
pursuant to paragraph 1a
limitation referred to in the
does not apply in sectors
previous paragraph only
or for types of works
applies to types of works or
where appropriate
other subject-matter for
licensing-based solutions,
which no collective
including but not limited
management organisation
to solutions provided for
36

Location
COMMISSION
EP TEXT
COUNCIL TEXT
POSSIBLE
PROPOSAL
COMPROMISE
doc. 9134/18
COM(2016)593
SOLUTION
in paragraph 1, are
exists that fulfils the
available. Member States
conditions referred to in
shall, in consultation with
point (a) of paragraph 1.
authors, other
1c. Member States shall
rightholders, collective
provide that all rightholders
management
may at any time, easily and
organisations and cultural
effectively, exclude their
heritage institutions,
works or other subject-
determine the availability
matter from the licensing
of extended collective
mechanism referred to in
licensing-based solutions
paragraph 1 or from uses
for specific sectors or
under the exception or
types of works.
limitation referred to in
paragraph 1a, either in
general or in specific cases,
including after the
conclusion of a licence or the
beginning of the use
concerned.
[provisionaly agreed at
Trilogue 26/11/2018]

168.
Art. 7, para
2.
A work or other
2.
A work or other
2.
A work or other
GREEN
2, sub-
subject-matter shall be
subject-matter shall be
subject-matter shall be
2.
A work or other
para 1
deemed to be out of
deemed to be out of
deemed to be out-of-
subject-matter shall be
commerce when the whole
commerce when the whole
commerce when it can be
deemed to be out-of-
work or other subject-
work or other subject-
presumed in good faith
commerce when it can be
37

Location
COMMISSION
EP TEXT
COUNCIL TEXT
POSSIBLE
PROPOSAL
COMPROMISE
doc. 9134/18
COM(2016)593
SOLUTION
matter, in all its
matter, in all its
that the whole work or
presumed in good faith that
translations, versions and
translations, versions and
other subject-matter, in all
the whole work or other
manifestations, is not
manifestations, is not
its translations, versions
subject-matter is not
available to the public
available to the public
and manifestations, is not
available to the public
through customary
through customary
available to the public
through customary channels
channels of commerce and
channels of commerce and
through customary
of commerce after a
cannot be reasonably
cannot be reasonably
channels of commerce and
reasonable effort is made to
expected to become so.
expected to become so.
cannot be reasonably
determine such availability.
Member States may
expected to become so.
[provisionally agreed at
provide a cut-off date in
after a reasonable effort
Trilogue 26/11/2018]
relation to determining
is made to determine
whether a work previously
such availability.
commercialised is deemed
to be out of commerce.

[See definition of out-of-
commerce work in

Parliament’s Article 2(4a)
(rows 122-126)]

169.
Art. 7, para
Member States shall, in
Member States shall, in
Member States shall, in
GREEN
2, sub-
consultation with
consultation with
consultation with
Member States may provide
para 2
rightholders, collective
rightholders, collective
rightholders, collective
for specific requirements,
management organisations
management organisations
management organisations
such as a cut-off date, to
and cultural heritage
and cultural heritage
and cultural heritage
determine whether works
institutions, ensure that the
institutions, ensure that the
institutions, ensure that the
and other subject-matter can
requirements used to
requirements used to
may provide for specific
be licensed in accordance
determine whether works
determine whether works
requirements used to
with paragraph 1 or used
38

Location
COMMISSION
EP TEXT
COUNCIL TEXT
POSSIBLE
PROPOSAL
COMPROMISE
doc. 9134/18
COM(2016)593
SOLUTION
and other subject-matter
and other subject-matter
determine whether works
under the exception or
can be licensed in
can be licensed in
and other subject-matter
limitation referred to in
accordance with paragraph
accordance with paragraph
can be licensed in
paragraph 1a. Such
1 do not extend beyond
or used in accordance
accordance with paragraph
requirements shall not
what is necessary and
with paragraph 1a do not
1 do. Such requirements
extend beyond what is
reasonable and do not
extend beyond what is
shall not extend beyond
necessary and reasonable,
preclude the possibility to
necessary and reasonable
what is necessary and
and shall not preclude the
determine the out-of-
and do not preclude the
reasonableand doshall
possibility to determine the
commerce status of a
possibility to determine the
not preclude the possibility
out-of-commerce status of a
collection as a whole,
out-of-commerce status of
to determine the out-of-
set of works or other subject-
when it is reasonable to
a collection as a whole,
commerce status of a
matter as a whole, when it is
presume that all works or
when it is reasonable to
collection as set of works
reasonable to presume that
other subject-matter in the
presume that all works or
or other subject-matter
all works or other subject-
collection are out of
other subject-matter in the
as a whole, when it is
matter are out-of commerce.
commerce.
collection are out of
reasonable to presume that
[provisionaly agreed at
commerce.
all works or other subject-
Trilogue 26/11/2018]
matter in the collection are
out -of -commerce.
170.
Art. 7,
3.
Member States
3. Member States shall
3. [Moved to new Article
3. [Moved to new Article
para 3,
shall provide that
provide that appropriate
8a(2)]
8a(2)]
introductory
appropriate publicity
publicity measures are
part
measures are taken
taken regarding:
regarding:
171.
Art. 7, para
(a)
the deeming of
(a) the deeming of works
3, point (a)
works or other subject-
or other subject-matter as
matter as out of commerce;
out of commerce;
39

Location
COMMISSION
EP TEXT
COUNCIL TEXT
POSSIBLE
PROPOSAL
COMPROMISE
doc. 9134/18
COM(2016)593
SOLUTION
172.
Art. 7, para
(b)
the licence, and in
(b) the any licence, and in
3, point (b)
particular its application to
particular its application to
unrepresented rightholders;
unrepresented rightholders;
173.
Art. 7, para
(c)
the possibility of
(c) the possibility of
3, point (c)
rightholders to object,
rightholders to object,
referred to in point (c) of
referred to in point (c) of
paragraph 1;
paragraph 1 and point (b)
of paragraph 1a;

174.
Art. 7, para
including during a
including during a
3, closing
reasonable period of time
reasonable period of time
phrase
before the works or other
at least six months before
subject-matter are
the works or other subject-
digitised, distributed,
matter are digitised,
communicated to the
distributed, communicated
public or made available.
to the public or made
available.
175.
Art. 7,
4.
Member States
4.
Member States
4.
Member States
GREEN
para 4,
shall ensure that the
shall ensure that the
shall ensure that the
4.
Member States shall
introductory
licences referred to in
licences referred to in
licences referred to in
ensure that the licences
part / Art. 7,
paragraph 1 are sought
paragraph 1 are sought
paragraph 1 are sought
referred to in paragraph 1 are
para 4
from a collective
from a collective
from a collective
sought from a collective
(Council)
management organisation
management organisation
management organisation
management organisation
that is representative for
that is representative for
that is representative for
that is representative for the
the Member State where:
the Member State where:
the Member State where:
Member State where the
40

Location
COMMISSION
EP TEXT
COUNCIL TEXT
POSSIBLE
PROPOSAL
COMPROMISE
doc. 9134/18
COM(2016)593
SOLUTION
the cultural heritage
cultural heritage institution is
institution is established.
established.
[provisionally agreed at
Trilogue 26/11/2018; to be
discussed further whether
the meaning of

“representative” should be
further clarified in the
recitals]

176.
Art. 7,
5.
This Article shall
GREEN
para 5,
not apply to sets of out-
5.
This Article shall not
introductory
of-commerce if, following
apply to sets of out-of-
part
the reasonable effort to
commerce works if, on the
(Council)
determine commercial
basis of the reasonable effort
availability, there is
referred to in paragraph 2,
evidence that such sets
there is evidence that such
predominantly consist of:
sets predominantly consist
of:
[provisionally agreed at
Trilogue 26/11/2018]

177.
Art. 7,
(a)
the works or
(a)
the works or
(a)
the works or other
GREEN
para 4, point
phonograms were first
phonograms were first
subject-matter
(a)
works or other
(a) (EP)/
published or, in the
published or, in the
phonograms were first
subject-matter first published
Art. 7, para
absence of publication,
absence of publication,
published or, in the
or, in the absence of
where they were first
where they were first
absence of publication,
41

Location
COMMISSION
EP TEXT
COUNCIL TEXT
POSSIBLE
PROPOSAL
COMPROMISE
doc. 9134/18
COM(2016)593
SOLUTION
5, point (a)
broadcast, except for
broadcast, except for
where they were first
publication, first broadcast in
(Council)
cinematographic and
cinematographic and
broadcast in a third
a third country, except for
audiovisual works;
audiovisual works;
country, except for
cinematographic or
cinematographic andor
audiovisual works;
audiovisual works;
[provisionally agreed at
Trilogue 26/11/2018]

178.
Art. 7,
(b)
the producers of the
(b)
the producers of the
(b)
cinematographic
GREEN
para 4, point
works have their
works have their
or audiovisual works, the
(b)
cinematographic or
(b) (EP)/
headquarters or habitual
headquarters or habitual
producers of the
audiovisual works, the
Art. 7, para
residence, for
residence, for
workswhich have their
producers of which have
5, point (b)
cinematographic and
cinematographic and
headquarters or habitual
their headquarters or habitual
(Council)
audiovisual works; or
audiovisual works; or
residence, for
residence in a third country;
cinematographic and
or
audiovisual works in a
third country
; or
[provisionally agreed at
Trilogue 26/11/2018]

179.
Art. 7,
(c)
the cultural heritage
(c)
the cultural heritage
c)
the cultural heritage
GREEN
para 4, point
institution is established,
institution is established,
institution is established,
c)
works or other
(c) (EP)
when a Member State or a
when a Member State or a
works or other subject-
subject-matter of third
/Art. 7, para
third country could not be
third country could not be
matter of third country
country nationals when a
5, point (c)
determined, after
determined, after
nationals when a Member
Member State or a third
(Council)
reasonable efforts,
reasonable efforts,
State or a third country
country could not be
according to points (a) and
according to points (a) and
could not be determined,
determined, after a
(b).
(b).
after reasonable
reasonable effort, according
to points (a) and (b);
42

Location
COMMISSION
EP TEXT
COUNCIL TEXT
POSSIBLE
PROPOSAL
COMPROMISE
doc. 9134/18
COM(2016)593
SOLUTION
effortseffort, according to
points (a) and (b).);
[provisionally agreed at
Trilogue 26/11/2018]

180.
Art. 7, para
5.
Paragraphs 1, 2 and
5.
Paragraphs 1, 2 and
5.
Paragraphs 1, 2 and
GREEN
5 (EP)/
3 shall not apply to the
3 shall not apply to the
3 shall not apply tounless
unless the collective
Art. 7,
works or other subject-
works or other subject-
the works or other subject-
management organisation is
para 5,
matter of third country
matter of third country
mattercollective
sufficiently representative of
closing
nationals except where
nationals except where
management
rightholders of that third
phrase
points (a) and (b) of
points (a) and (b) of
organisation is
country in the meaning of
(Council)
paragraph 4 apply.
paragraph 4 apply.
sufficiently
point (a) of paragraph 1.
representative of
rightholders of that third
country nationals except
[provisionally agreed at
where pointsin the
Trilogue 26/11/2018]
meaning of point (a) and
(b) of paragraph 4 apply1.
181.
Art. 8, title
Article 8
Article 8
Article 8
Article 8
Cross-border uses
Cross-border uses
Cross-border uses
Cross-border uses
182.
Art. 8, para
1.
Works or other
1.
Works Out-of-
1.
Works or other
1.
A licence granted in
1
subject-matter covered by
commerce works or other
subject-matter covered by
accordance with Article 7
a licence granted in
subject-matter covered by
alicence granted in
may allow the use of out-of-
accordance with Article 7
a licence granted in
accordance with Article 7
commerce works or other
may be used by the
accordance with Article 7
may be used allow the use
subject-matter by the cultural
cultural heritage institution
may be used by the
of out-of-commerce
in accordance with the
cultural heritage institution
works or other subject-
43

Location
COMMISSION
EP TEXT
COUNCIL TEXT
POSSIBLE
PROPOSAL
COMPROMISE
doc. 9134/18
COM(2016)593
SOLUTION
terms of the licence in all
in accordance with the
matter by the cultural
heritage institution in any
Member States.
terms of the licence that
heritage institution in
Member State.
Article in all Member
accordance with the terms
2. The uses of works and
States.
of the licence in allany
other subject-matter under
Member StatesState.
the exception or limitation
referred to in Article 7(1a)
shall be deemed to occur
solely in the Member State
where the cultural heritage
institution undertaking that
use is established.

[paragraph 1 provisionally
agreed at Trilogue
26/11/2018; paragraph 2
depending on Article 7(1a)]

183.
Art. 8, para
2.
Member States
2.
Member States
2. [Moved to new Article
GREEN
2
shall ensure that
shall ensure that
8a(1)]
2. [Moved to new Article
information that allows the
information that allows the
8a(1)]
identification of the works
identification of the works
or other subject-matter
or other subject-matter
[provisionally agreed at
covered by a licence
covered by a licence
Trilogue 26/11/2018]
granted in accordance with
granted in accordance with
Article 7 and information
Article 7 and information
about the possibility of
about the possibility of
rightholders to object
rightholders to object
referred to in Article
referred to in point (c) of
44

Location
COMMISSION
EP TEXT
COUNCIL TEXT
POSSIBLE
PROPOSAL
COMPROMISE
doc. 9134/18
COM(2016)593
SOLUTION
7(1)(c) are made publicly
Article 7(1) and point (b)
accessible in a single
of Article 7(1a) are made
online portal for at least six
publicly permanently,
months before the works or
easily and effectively
other subject-matter are
accessible in a public
digitised, distributed,
single online portal for at
communicated to the
least six months before the
public or made available in
works or other subject-
Member States other than
matter are digitised,
the one where the licence
distributed, communicated
is granted, and for the
to the public or made
whole duration of the
available in Member States
licence.
other than the one where
the licence is granted, or in
the cases covered by
Article 7(1a), where the
cultural heritage
institution is established
and for the whole duration
of the licence.
184.
Art. 8, para
3.
The portal referred
3.
The portal referred
3. [Moved to new Article
GREEN
3
to in paragraph 2 shall be
to in paragraph 2 shall be
8a(1) second
3. [Moved to new Article
established and managed
established and managed
subparagraph]
8a(1) second subparagraph]
by the European Union
by the European Union
Intellectual Property Office
Intellectual Property Office
[provisionally agreed at
in accordance with
in accordance with
Trilogue 26/11/2018]
45

Location
COMMISSION
EP TEXT
COUNCIL TEXT
POSSIBLE
PROPOSAL
COMPROMISE
doc. 9134/18
COM(2016)593
SOLUTION
Regulation (EU) No
Regulation (EU) No
386/2012.
386/2012.
185.
Art. 8a, title
GREEN
Article 8a
Publicity measures
Article 8a
Publicity measures
[provisionally agreed at
Trilogue 26/11/2018]

186.
Art. 8a, para
1.
Member States
GREEN
1, sub-para
shall ensure that
1.
Member States shall
1
information that allowsfor
ensure that information from
the purposes of the
cultural heritage
identification of the out-
institutions, collective
of-commerce works or
management organisations
other subject-matter
or relevant public
covered by a licence
authorities for the purposes
granted in accordance with
of the identification of the
Article 7 andas well as
out-of-commerce works or
information about the
other subject-matter covered
possibilitypossibilities of
by a licence granted in
rightholders to object
accordance with Article
referred to in Article
7(1) or used under the
7(1)(c) are), and, as soon
exception or limitation
as it is available,
referred to in Article 7(1a)
information on the
as well as information about
parties to the licence, the
46

Location
COMMISSION
EP TEXT
COUNCIL TEXT
POSSIBLE
PROPOSAL
COMPROMISE
doc. 9134/18
COM(2016)593
SOLUTION
covered territories and
the possibilities of
the allowed uses is made
rightholders referred to in
publicly accessible in a
Article 7(1c), and, as soon as
single online portal
it is available and where
forfrom at least six months
relevant, information on the
before the works or other
parties to the licence, the
subject-matter are
covered territories and the
digitised, distributed,
allowed uses is made
communicated to the
permanently, easily and
public or made available in
effectively accessible in a
Member States other than
public single online portal
the one where the licence
from at least six months
is granted, and for the
before the works or other
whole duration ofto the
subject-matter are
public in accordance
distributed, communicated to
with the licence.
the public or made available
to the public in accordance
[Article 8(2) of the COM
with the licence or under
proposal, amended]
the exception or limitation.
[Article 8(2) of the COM
proposal, amended]

[provisionally agreed at
Trilogue 26/11/2018,
including clarification in
recital (27) that the licence
may cover one, several or all
Member States; part in

47

Location
COMMISSION
EP TEXT
COUNCIL TEXT
POSSIBLE
PROPOSAL
COMPROMISE
doc. 9134/18
COM(2016)593
SOLUTION
yellow depending on Article
7(1a)]

187.
Art. 8a, para
3.
The portal referred
GREEN
1, sub-
to in paragraph 2 shall be
The portal shall be
para 2
established and managed
established and managed by
by the European Union
the European Union
Intellectual Property
Intellectual Property Office
Office in accordance with
in accordance with
Regulation (EU) No
Regulation (EU) No
386/2012.
386/2012.
[Article 8(3) of the COM
[Article 8(3) of the COM
proposal, amended]
proposal, amended]
[provisionally agreed at
Trilogue 26/11/2018]

188.
Art. 8a, para
2.
Member States
GREEN
2
shall provide that, if
2.
Member States shall
necessary for the general
provide that, if necessary for
awareness of
the general awareness of
rightholders, further
rightholders, further
appropriate publicity
appropriate publicity
measures are taken
measures are taken regarding
regarding: (a) the deeming
the possibility for collective
of works or other subject-
management organisations
matter as out of commerce;
to license works or other
(b) the licence, and in
48

Location
COMMISSION
EP TEXT
COUNCIL TEXT
POSSIBLE
PROPOSAL
COMPROMISE
doc. 9134/18
COM(2016)593
SOLUTION
particular its application to
subject-matter in accordance
unrepresented
with Article 7, the licences
rightholders; the
granted, the uses under the
possibility for collective
exception or limitation
management
referred to in Article 7(1a)
organisations to license
and the possibilities of
works or other subject-
rightholders referred to in
matter in accordance
Article 7(1c).
with Article 7, the
The additional appropriate
licences granted and (c)
publicity measures shall be
the possibilities to object
taken in the Member State
of rightholders referred to
where the licence is sought
in point (c) of paragraph 1
in accordance to Article
Article 7(1)(c) ;.
7(1) or, for uses under the
Including during a
exception or limitation
reasonable period of time
referred to in Article 7(1a),
before the works or other
where the cultural heritage
subject-matter are
institution is established. If
digitised, distributed,
there is evidence, such as the
communicated to the
origin of the works or other
public or made available.
subject-matter, to suggest
that the awareness of
The additional
rightholders could be more
appropriate publicity
efficiently raised in other
measures shall be taken
Member States or third
in the Member State
countries, such publicity
where the licence is
measures shall also cover
sought. If there is
49

Location
COMMISSION
EP TEXT
COUNCIL TEXT
POSSIBLE
PROPOSAL
COMPROMISE
doc. 9134/18
COM(2016)593
SOLUTION
evidence, such as the
those Member States and
origin of the works or
third countries.
other subject-matter, to
[Article 7(3) of the COM
suggest that the
proposal, amended]
awareness of rightholders
could be more efficiently
raised in other Member

[provisionally agreed at
States or third countries,
Trilogue 26/11/2018; part in
such publicity measures
yellow depending on Article
shall also cover those
7(1a)]
Member States and third
countries.

[Article 7(3) of the COM
proposal, amended]

189.
Art. 9, title
Article 9
Article 9
Article 9
Article 9
Stakeholder dialogue
Stakeholder dialogue
Stakeholder dialogue
Stakeholder dialogue
190.
Art 9
Member States shall
Member States shall
Member States shall
GREEN
ensure a regular dialogue
ensure a regular dialogue
ensure consult
Member States shall consult
between representative
between representative
rightholders, collective
rightholders, collective
users' and rightholders'
users' and rightholders'
management
management organisations
organisations, and any
organisations, and any
organisations and
and cultural heritage
other relevant stakeholder
other relevant stakeholder
cultural heritage
institutions in each sector
organisations, to, on a
organisations, to, on a
institutions in each sector
before establishing specific
sector-specific basis, foster
sector-specific basis, foster
before establishing
requirements pursuant to
the relevance and usability
the relevance and usability
specific requirements
Article 7(2), and encourage a
of the licensing
of the licensing
pursuant to Article 7(2),
50

Location
COMMISSION
EP TEXT
COUNCIL TEXT
POSSIBLE
PROPOSAL
COMPROMISE
doc. 9134/18
COM(2016)593
SOLUTION
mechanisms referred to in
mechanisms referred to in
and encourage a regular
regular dialogue between
Article 7(1), ensure the
Article 7(1) and the
dialogue between
representative users' and
effectiveness of the
exception referred to in
representative users' and
rightholders' organisations,
safeguards for rightholders
Article 7(1a), ensure the
rightholders' organisations,
including collective
referred to in this Chapter,
effectiveness of the
including collective
management organisations,
notably as regards
safeguards for rightholders
management
and any other relevant
publicity measures, and,
referred to in this Chapter,
organisations, and any
stakeholder organisations, on
where applicable, assist in
notably as regards
other relevant stakeholder
a sector-specific basis, to
the establishment of the
publicity measures, and,
organisations, to, on a
foster the relevance and
requirements referred to in
where applicable, assist in
sector-specific basis, to
usability of the licensing
the second subparagraph of
the establishment of the
foster the relevance and
mechanisms referred to in
Article 7(2).
requirements referred to in
usability of the licensing
Article 7(1) and to ensure the
the second subparagraph of
mechanisms referred to in
effectiveness of the
Article 7(2).
Article 7(1),) and to
safeguards for rightholders
ensure the effectiveness of
referred to in this Chapter.
the safeguards for
rightholders referred to in
this Chapter, notably as
[provisionally agreed at
regards publicity
Trilogue 26/11/2018]
measures, and, where
applicable, assist in the
establishment of the
requirements referred to in
the second subparagraph
of Article 7(2).
51

Location
COMMISSION
EP TEXT
COUNCIL TEXT
POSSIBLE
PROPOSAL
COMPROMISE
doc. 9134/18
COM(2016)593
SOLUTION
191.
CHAPTER 1a
CHAPTER 1a
Measures to facilitate
Measures to facilitate
collective licensing
collective licensing
192.
Art. 9a, title
Article 9a
Article 9a
Collective licensing with
Collective licensing with an
an extended effect
extended effect
[Article 9a in principle
provisionally agreed; final
agreement depending on
final wording with possible
technical clarifications from
COM]

193.
Art. 9a, para
1.
Member States
1.
Member States may
1
may provide, as far as
provide, as far as the use
the use within their
within their national territory
national territory is
is concerned and subject to
concerned and subject to
safeguards provided for in
safeguards provided for
this Article, that when a
in this Article, that when
collective management
a collective management
organisation, in accordance
organisation, in
with its mandates from
accordance with its
rightholders, enters into a
mandates from
licensing agreement for the
rightholders, enters into
exploitation of works or
52

Location
COMMISSION
EP TEXT
COUNCIL TEXT
POSSIBLE
PROPOSAL
COMPROMISE
doc. 9134/18
COM(2016)593
SOLUTION
a licensing agreement for
other subject-matter such an
the exploitation of works
agreement may be extended
or other subject-matter
to apply to the rights of
such an agreement may
rightholders who have not
be extended to apply to
authorised the organisation
the rights of rightholders
to represent them by way of
who have not authorised
assignment, licence or any
the organisation to
other contractual
represent them by way of
arrangement; or, with respect
assignment, licence or
to such an agreement, the
any other contractual
organisation has a legal
arrangement; or, with
mandate or is presumed to
respect to such an
represent rightholders who
agreement, the
have not authorised the
organisation has a legal
organisation accordingly.
mandate or is presumed
to represent rightholders
who have not authorised

[see comment in row 192]
the organisation
accordingly.

194.
Art. 9a, para
2.
Member States
2.
Member States shall
2
shall ensure that the
ensure that the licensing
licensing mechanism
mechanism referred to in
referred to in paragraph
paragraph 1 is only applied
1 is only applied within
within well-defined areas of
well-defined areas of use
use where obtaining
where obtaining
authorisations from
53

Location
COMMISSION
EP TEXT
COUNCIL TEXT
POSSIBLE
PROPOSAL
COMPROMISE
doc. 9134/18
COM(2016)593
SOLUTION
authorisations from
rightholders on an individual
rightholders on an
basis is typically onerous
individual basis is
and impractical to a degree
typically onerous and
that makes the required
impractical to a degree
licensing transaction
that makes the required
unlikely due to the nature of
licensing transaction
the use or of the types of
unlikely due to the
works or other subject-
nature of the use or of
matter concerned and that
the types of works or
such mechanism safeguards
other subject-matter
the legitimate interests of
concerned and that such
rightholders.
mechanism safeguards
[see comment in row 192]
the legitimate interests of
rightholders.

195.
Art. 9a, para
3.
The safeguards
3.
The safeguards
3
referred to in paragraph
referred to in paragraph 1
1 must ensure that:
must ensure that:
[see comment in row 192]
196.
Art. 9a, para
(a)
the organisation
(a)
the organisation is,
3, point (a)
is, on the basis of
on the basis of mandates
mandates from
from rightholders,
rightholders, sufficiently
sufficiently representative of
representative of
rightholders in the relevant
rightholders in the
type of works or other
relevant type of works or
subject-matter and of the
54

Location
COMMISSION
EP TEXT
COUNCIL TEXT
POSSIBLE
PROPOSAL
COMPROMISE
doc. 9134/18
COM(2016)593
SOLUTION
other subject-matter and
rights which are the subject
of the rights which are
of the licence for the relevant
the subject of the licence
Member State;
for the relevant Member
[see comment in row 192]
State;
197.
Art. 9a, para
(b)
equal treatment is
(b)
equal treatment is
3, point (b)
guaranteed to all
guaranteed to all rightholders
rightholders in relation
in relation to the terms of the
to the terms of the
licence;
licence;
[see comment in row 192]
198.
Art. 9a, para
(c)
rightholders who
(c)
rightholders who
3, point (c)
have not authorised the
have not authorised the
organisation operating
organisation operating the
the licence may at any
licence may at any time
time easily and
easily and effectively
effectively exclude their
exclude their works or other
works or other subject-
subject-matter from the
matter from the licensing
licensing mechanism
mechanism established in
established in accordance
accordance with this
with this Article;
Article;
[see comment in row 192]
199.
Art. 9a, para
(d)
appropriate
(d)
appropriate publicity
3, point (d)
publicity measures are
measures are taken to raise
taken to raise the
the awareness of rightholders
55

Location
COMMISSION
EP TEXT
COUNCIL TEXT
POSSIBLE
PROPOSAL
COMPROMISE
doc. 9134/18
COM(2016)593
SOLUTION
awareness of
regarding the possibility for
rightholders regarding
organisations to license
the possibility for
works or other subject-
organisations to license
matter and the licensing
works or other subject-
taking place in accordance
matter and the licensing
with this Article, and the
taking place in
possibilities of rightholders
accordance with this
referred to in point (c)
Article, and the
starting from a reasonable
possibilities of
period before the works or
rightholders referred to
other subject-matter are used
in point (c) starting from
under the licence. Publicity
a reasonable period
measures should be effective
before the works or other
without the need to inform
subject-matter are used
each rightholder
under the licence.
individually.
Publicity measures
[see comment in row 192]
should be effective
without the need to
inform each rightholder
individually.

200.
Art. 9a, para
4.
The rules
4.
The rules provided
4
provided for in this
for in this Article are without
Article are without
prejudice to the application
prejudice to the
of collective licensing
application of collective
mechanisms with an
licensing mechanisms
extended effect in
56

Location
COMMISSION
EP TEXT
COUNCIL TEXT
POSSIBLE
PROPOSAL
COMPROMISE
doc. 9134/18
COM(2016)593
SOLUTION
with an extended effect in
conformity with other
conformity with other
provisions of Union law,
provisions of Union law,
including those which allow
including those which
exceptions or limitations,
allow exceptions or
and shall not apply to
limitations, and shall not
mandatory collective
apply to mandatory
management of rights.
collective management of
[see comment in row 192]
rights.
201.
Art. 9a, para
5.
Where the law of
5.
Where the law of a
5
a Member State provides
Member State provides for a
for a licensing
licensing mechanism in
mechanism in
accordance with this Article,
accordance with this
the Member State concerned
Article, the Member
shall inform the Commission
State concerned shall
about the scope of that law,
inform the Commission
purposes and types of
about the scope of that
licences that may be
law, purposes and types
introduced under that law as
of licences that may be
well as contact details for
introduced under that
organisations issuing
law as well as contact
licences in accordance with
details for organisations
the mechanism in paragraph
issuing licences in
1. The Commission shall
accordance with the
publish this information.
mechanism in paragraph
[see comment in row 192]
57

Location
COMMISSION
EP TEXT
COUNCIL TEXT
POSSIBLE
PROPOSAL
COMPROMISE
doc. 9134/18
COM(2016)593
SOLUTION
1. The Commission shall
publish this information.

202.
Art. 9a, para
6.
Based on the
6. Based on the information
6
information received
received pursuant to
pursuant to paragraph 5
paragraph 5 and on the
and on the discussions in
discussions in the contact
the contact committee
committee referred to in
referred to in Article
Article 12(3) of Directive
12(3) of Directive
2001/29/EC, the
2001/29/EC, the
Commission shall, by 10
Commission shall, by 31
April 2021, submit to the
December 2020, submit
European Parliament and to
to the European
the Council a report on the
Parliament and to the
use of such mechanisms
Council a report on the
referred to in paragraph 1 in
use of such mechanisms
the EU and their impact on
referred to in paragraph
licensing and rightholders.
1 in the EU and their
The Commission’s report
impact on licensing and
shall be accompanied, if
rightholders. The
appropriate, by a legislative
Commission’s report
proposal, including as
shall be accompanied, if
regards the cross-border
appropriate, by a
effect of such national
legislative proposal,
schemes.
including as regards
[see comment in row 192]
publicity measures, and,
where applicable, assist in
58

Location
COMMISSION
EP TEXT
COUNCIL TEXT
POSSIBLE
PROPOSAL
COMPROMISE
doc. 9134/18
COM(2016)593
SOLUTION
the establishment of the
requirements referred to in
the second subparagraph
of Article 7(2).the cross-
border effect of such
national schemes.

203.
CHAPTER 2
CHAPTER 2
CHAPTER 2
CHAPTER 2
Access to and availability
Access to and availability
Access to and availability
Access to and availability of
of audiovisual works on
of audiovisual works on
of audiovisual works on
audiovisual works on video-
video-on-demand
video-on-demand
video-on-demand
on-demand platforms
platforms
platforms
platforms
204.
Art. 10, title
Article 10
Article 10
Article 10
Article 10
Negotiation mechanism
Negotiation mechanism
Negotiation mechanism
Negotiation mechanism
205.
Art. 10, sub-
Member States shall
Member States shall
Member States shall
GREEN
para 1
ensure that where parties
ensure that where parties
ensure that where parties
Member States shall ensure
wishing to conclude an
wishing to conclude an
wishingfacing difficulties
that parties facing difficulties
agreement for the purpose
agreement for the purpose
related to the licensing of
related to the licensing of
of making available
of making available
rights when seeking to
rights when seeking to
audiovisual works on
audiovisual works on
conclude an agreement for
conclude an agreement for
video-on-demand
video-on-demand
the purpose of making
the purpose of making
platforms face difficulties
platforms face difficulties
available audiovisual
available audiovisual works
relating to the licensing of
relating to the licensing of
works on video-on-demand
on video-on-demand
rights, they may rely on the
audiovisual rights, they
platforms face difficulties
services, may rely on the
assistance of an impartial
may rely on the assistance
relating to the licensing of
assistance of an impartial
body with relevant
of an impartial body with
rights, theyservices, may
body or of mediators. The
59

Location
COMMISSION
EP TEXT
COUNCIL TEXT
POSSIBLE
PROPOSAL
COMPROMISE
doc. 9134/18
COM(2016)593
SOLUTION
experience. That body
relevant experience. That
rely on the assistance of an
impartial body created or
shall provide assistance
body The impartial body
impartial body with
designated by the Member
with negotiation and help
created or designated by
relevant experience.
State for the purpose of
reach agreements.
the Member State for the
Thator of mediators. The
this Article or mediators
purpose of this Article
body or mediators shall
shall provide assistance to
shall provide assistance to
provide assistance to the
the parties with their
the parties with
parties with
negotiationand help them
negotiation and help them
negotiationtheir
reach agreements, including,
to reach agreement.
negotiations and help
where appropriate, by
them reach agreements,
submitting proposals to the
including, where
parties.
appropriate, by
submitting proposals to
the parties
.
[provisionally agreed at
Trilogue 26/11/2018]

206.
Art. 10, sub-
No later than [date
No later than [date
No later than [date
GREEN
para 2
mentioned in Article
mentioned in Article
mentioned in Article
Member States shall notify
21(1)] Member States shall
21(1)] Member States shall
21(1)] Member States shall
to the Commission the body
notify to the Commission
notify to inform the
notify to the Commission
or mediators referred to in
the body referred to in
Commission of the body
the body or mediators
paragraph 1 no later than
paragraph 1.
referred to in paragraph 1.
referred to in paragraph 1
[date mentioned in Article
they create or designate
no later than [date
21(1)]. In cases where
pursuant to the first
mentioned in Article
Member States have chosen
paragraph.
21(1)]. In cases where
to rely on mediation, the
Member States have
notification to the
chosen to rely on
Commission shall at least
mediation, the
include, when available, the
60

Location
COMMISSION
EP TEXT
COUNCIL TEXT
POSSIBLE
PROPOSAL
COMPROMISE
doc. 9134/18
COM(2016)593
SOLUTION
notification to the
source where relevant
Commission shall at least
information on the entrusted
include, when available,
mediators can be found.
the source where relevant
information on the
entrusted mediators can

[provisionally agreed at
be found.
Trilogue 26/11/2018]
207.
Art. 10, sub-
To encourage the
GREEN
para 3
availability of audiovisual
[provisionally agreed at
works on video-on-
Trilogue on 26/11/2018 to
demand platforms,
insert part of the EP
Member States shall foster
mandate of this row into a
dialogue between
recital (not in Article) along
representative
the following lines: Member
organisations of authors,
States should encourage
producers, video-on-
dialogue between
demand platforms and
representative organisations,
other relevant
without it being an
stakeholders.
obligation for Member
States]

208.
CHAPTER 2a
Access to Union
publications
61

Location
COMMISSION
EP TEXT
COUNCIL TEXT
POSSIBLE
PROPOSAL
COMPROMISE
doc. 9134/18
COM(2016)593
SOLUTION
209.
Art. 10a,
Article 10 a
title
Union Legal Deposit
210.
Art. 10a,
1.
Any electronic
para 1
publication dealing with
Union-related matters
such as Union law, Union
history and integration,
Union policy and Union
democracy, institutional
and parliamentary affairs,
and politics, that is made
available to the public in
the Union shall be subject
to a Union Legal Deposit.

211.
Art. 10a,
2.
The European
para 2
Parliament Library shall
be entitled to delivery, free
of charge, of one copy of
every publication referred
to in paragraph 1.

212.
Art. 10a,
3.
The obligation set
para 3
out in paragraph 1 shall
apply to publishers,
printers and importers of
publications for the works

62

Location
COMMISSION
EP TEXT
COUNCIL TEXT
POSSIBLE
PROPOSAL
COMPROMISE
doc. 9134/18
COM(2016)593
SOLUTION
they publish, print or
import in the Union.

213.
Art. 10a,
4.
From the day of
para 4
the delivery to the
European Parliament
Library, the publications
referred to in paragraph 1
shall become part of the
European Parliament
Library permanent
collection. They shall be
made available to users at
the European Parliament

Library’s premises
exclusively for the
purpose of research or
study by accredited
researchers and under the
control of the European
Parliament Library.

214.
Art. 10a,
5.
The Commission
para 5
shall adopt acts to specify
the modalities relating to
the delivery to the
European Parliament
Library of publications

63

Location
COMMISSION
EP TEXT
COUNCIL TEXT
POSSIBLE
PROPOSAL
COMPROMISE
doc. 9134/18
COM(2016)593
SOLUTION
referred to in paragraph
1.

215.
TITLE IV
TITLE IV
TITLE IV
TITLE IV
MEASURES TO
MEASURES TO
MEASURES TO
MEASURES TO ACHIEVE
ACHIEVE A WELL-
ACHIEVE A WELL-
ACHIEVE A WELL-
A WELL-FUNCTIONING
FUNCTIONING
FUNCTIONING
FUNCTIONING
MARKETPLACE FOR
MARKETPLACE FOR
MARKETPLACE FOR
MARKETPLACE FOR
COPYRIGHT
COPYRIGHT
COPYRIGHT
COPYRIGHT
216.
CHAPTER 1
CHAPTER 1
CHAPTER 1
CHAPTER 1
Rights in publications
Rights in publications
Rights in publications
Rights in publications
217.
Art. 11, title
Article 11
Article 11
Article 11
[To be further discussed at
Protection of press
Protection of press
Protection of press
political level;
publications concerning
publications concerning
publications concerning
Preparatory work to be done
digital uses
digital uses
digitalonline uses
at technical level]
218.
Art. 11, para
1.
Member States
1.
Member States
1.
Member States
1
shall provide publishers of
shall provide publishers of
shall provide publishers of
press publications with the
press publications with the
press publications
rights provided for in
rights provided for in
established in a Member
Article 2 and Article 3(2)
Article 2 and Article 3(2)
State with the rights
of Directive 2001/29/EC
of Directive 2001/29/EC
provided for in Article 2
for the digital use of their
so that they may obtain
and Article 3(2) of
press publications.
fair and proportionate
Directive 2001/29/EC for
remuneration for the
the digitalonline use of
digital use of their press
their press publications by
64

Location
COMMISSION
EP TEXT
COUNCIL TEXT
POSSIBLE
PROPOSAL
COMPROMISE
doc. 9134/18
COM(2016)593
SOLUTION
publications by
information society
information society
service providers.
service providers.
219.
Art. 11, para
The rights referred to in
1, sub-
the first subparagraph
para 2
shall not apply in respect
of uses of insubstantial
parts of a press
publication. Member
States shall be free to
determine the
insubstantial nature of
parts of press
publications taking into
account whether these
parts are the expression
of the intellectual
creation of their authors,
or whether these parts
are individual words or
very short excerpts, or
both criteria.

220.
Art. 11, para
1a.
The rights referred
1a
to in paragraph 1 shall
not prevent legitimate
private and non-

65

Location
COMMISSION
EP TEXT
COUNCIL TEXT
POSSIBLE
PROPOSAL
COMPROMISE
doc. 9134/18
COM(2016)593
SOLUTION
commercial use of press
publications by individual
users.

221.
Art. 11, para
2.
The rights referred
2.
The rights referred
2.
The rights referred
2
to in paragraph 1 shall
to in paragraph 1shall
to in paragraph 1 shall
leave intact and shall in no
leave intact and shall in no
leave intact and shall in no
way affect any rights
way affect any rights
way affect any rights
provided for in Union law
provided for in Union law
provided for in Union law
to authors and other
to authors and other
to authors and other
rightholders, in respect of
rightholders, in respect of
rightholders, in respect of
the works and other
the works and other
the works and other
subject-matter
subject-matter
subject-matter
incorporated in a press
incorporated in a press
incorporated in a press
publication. Such rights
publication. Such rights
publication. SuchThe
may not be invoked against
may not be invoked against
rights referred to in
those authors and other
those authors and other
paragraph 1 may not be
rightholders and, in
rightholders and, in
invoked against those
particular, may not deprive
particular, may not deprive
authors and other
them of their right to
them of their right to
rightholders and, in
exploit their works and
exploit their works and
particular, may not deprive
other subject-matter
other subject-matter
them of their right to
independently from the
independently from the
exploit their works and
press publication in which
press publication in which
other subject-matter
they are incorporated.
they are incorporated.
independently from the
press publication in which
they are incorporated.
66

Location
COMMISSION
EP TEXT
COUNCIL TEXT
POSSIBLE
PROPOSAL
COMPROMISE
doc. 9134/18
COM(2016)593
SOLUTION
222.
Art. 11, para
When a work or other
2, sub-
subject-matter is
para 2
incorporated in a press
publication on the basis
of a non-exclusive licence,
the rights referred to in
paragraph 1 may not be
invoked to prohibit the
use by other authorised
users. The rights referred
to in paragraph 1 may
not be invoked to
prohibit the use of works
or other subject-matter
whose protection has
expired.

223.
Art. 11, para
2a.
The rights referred
2a
to in paragraph 1 shall
not extend to mere
hyperlinks which are
accompanied by
individual words.

224.
Art. 11, para
3.
Articles 5 to 8 of
3.
Articles 5 to 8 of
3.
Articles 5 to 8 of
3
Directive 2001/29/EC and
Directive 2001/29/EC and
Directive 2001/29/EC and
67

Location
COMMISSION
EP TEXT
COUNCIL TEXT
POSSIBLE
PROPOSAL
COMPROMISE
doc. 9134/18
COM(2016)593
SOLUTION
Directive 2012/28/EU shall
Directive 2012/28/EU shall
Directive 2012/28/EU shall
apply mutatis mutandis in
apply mutatis mutandis in
apply mutatis mutandis in
respect of the rights
respect of the rights
respect of the rights
referred to in paragraph 1.
referred to in paragraph 1.
referred to in paragraph 1.
225.
Art. 11, para
4.
The rights referred
4.
The rights referred
4.
The rights referred
4
to in paragraph 1 shall
to in paragraph 1 shall
to in paragraph 1 shall
expire 20 years after the
expire 20 years after the
expire 20 years1 year after
publication of the press
publication of the press
the publication of the press
publication. This term shall
publication. This term shall
publication. This term shall
be calculated from the first
be calculated from the first
be calculated from the first
day of January of the year
day of January of the year
day of January of the year
following the date of
following the date of
following the date o
publication.
publication. The right
publication.
referred to in paragraph 1
shall not apply with
retroactive effect.

226.
Art. 11, para
4a.
Member States
4a
shall ensure that authors
receive an appropriate
share of the additional
revenues press publishers
receive for the use of a
press publication by
information society
service providers

68

Location
COMMISSION
EP TEXT
COUNCIL TEXT
POSSIBLE
PROPOSAL
COMPROMISE
doc. 9134/18
COM(2016)593
SOLUTION
227.
Art. 11, para
5.  Paragraph 1 shall not
5
apply to press
publications first
published before [entry
into force of the
Directive]
.
228.
Art, 12, title
Article 12
Article 12
Article 12
Article 12
Claims to fair
Claims to fair
Claims to fair
Claims to fair compensation
compensation
compensation
compensation
229.
Art. 12, sub-
Member States may
Member States with
Member States may
[discussed at Trilogue 26/
para 1 (EP)/
provide that where an
compensation-sharing
provide that where an
11/2018; COM to provide
Art. 12,
author has transferred or
systems between authors
author has transferred or
recital language to address
introductory
licensed a right to a
and publishers for
licensed a right to a
EP's concerns regarding
part
publisher, such a transfer
exceptions and limitations
publisher, such a transfer
"cut off date"]
(Council)]
or a licence constitutes a
may provide that where an
or a licence constitutes a
[to be further discussed at
sufficient legal basis for
author has transferred or
sufficient legal basis for
political level]
the publisher to claim a
licensed a right to a
the publisher to claimbe
share of  the compensation
publisher, such a transfer
entitled to a share of :
for the uses of the work
or a licence constitutes a
[remaining part of this
made under an exception
sufficient legal basis for
paragraph of the COM
or limitation to the
the publisher to claim a
proposal was moved to
transferred or licensed
share of the compensation
new point (a) (see row
right.
for the uses of the work
230)]
made under an exception
or limitation to the
transferred or licensed
69

Location
COMMISSION
EP TEXT
COUNCIL TEXT
POSSIBLE
PROPOSAL
COMPROMISE
doc. 9134/18
COM(2016)593
SOLUTION
right, provided that an
equivalent compensation-
sharing system was in
operation in that Member
State before 12 November
2015
.
230.
Art. 12,
(a)
the compensation
point (a)
for the uses of the work
made under an exception
or limitation to the
transferred or licensed
right.; and
[See Parliament’s sub-
paragraph 1 of Article 12
(row 229)]

231.
Art. 12,
(b)
the remuneration
point (b)
for public lending
provided for in Article
6(1) of Directive
2006/115/EC.

232.
Art. 12, sub-
The first paragraph shall
para 2
be without prejudice to the
arrangements in Member
States concerning public
lending rights, the

70

Location
COMMISSION
EP TEXT
COUNCIL TEXT
POSSIBLE
PROPOSAL
COMPROMISE
doc. 9134/18
COM(2016)593
SOLUTION
management of rights not
based on exceptions or
limitations to copyright,
such as extended
collective licensing
schemes, or concerning
remuneration rights on
the basis of national law.

233.
CHAPTER 1a
Protection of sport event
organizers

234.
Art. 12a,
Article 12a
title
Protection of sport event
organizers
235.
Art. 12a
Member States shall
provide sport event
organizers with the rights
provided for in Article 2
and Article 3 (2) of
Directive 2001/29/EC and
Article 7 of Directive
2006/115/EC.

71

Location
COMMISSION
EP TEXT
COUNCIL TEXT
POSSIBLE
PROPOSAL
COMPROMISE
doc. 9134/18
COM(2016)593
SOLUTION
236.
CHAPTER 2
CHAPTER 2
CHAPTER 2
CHAPTER 2
Certain uses of protected
Certain uses of protected
Certain uses of protected
Certain uses of protected
content by online services
content by online services
content by online services
content by online services
237.
Art. 13, title
Article 13
Article 13
Article 13
[To be further discussed at
Use of protected content by
Use of protected content by
political level;
Use of protected content by
information society service
information society online
information societyonline
Preparatory work started at
providers storing and
content sharing service
content sharing service
technical level]
giving access to large
providers storing and
providers storing
amounts of works and
giving access to large
other subject-matter
amounts of works and
uploaded by their users
other subject-matter
uploaded by their users
238.
Art. 13, para
1.
Information society
1.
Without prejudice
1.
Member States
1
service providers that store
to Article 3(1) and (2) of
shall provide that an
and provide to the public
Directive 2001/29/EC,
online content sharing
access to large amounts of
online content sharing
service provider
works or other subject-
Information society service
performs an act of
matter uploaded by their
providers that store and
communication to the
users shall, in cooperation
provide perform an act of
public or an act of
with rightholders, take
communication to the
making available to the
measures to ensure the
public access to large
public when it gives the
functioning of agreements
amounts of works or other
public access to copyright
concluded with
subject-matter uploaded by
protected works or other
rightholders for the use of
their users. They shall in
protected subject matter
their works or other
cooperation with
uploaded by its users.
subject-matter or to
rightholders, take measures
72

Location
COMMISSION
EP TEXT
COUNCIL TEXT
POSSIBLE
PROPOSAL
COMPROMISE
doc. 9134/18
COM(2016)593
SOLUTION
prevent the availability on
to ensure the functioning
An online content
their services of works or
of agreements concluded
sharing service provider
other subject-matter
with rightholders for the
shall obtain an
identified by rightholders
use of their works or other
authorisation from the
through the cooperation
subject-matter or to
rightholders referred to
with the service providers.
prevent the availability on
in Article 3(1) and giving
Those measures, such as
their services of works or
access to large amounts
the use of effective content
other subject-matter
of(2) of Directive
recognition technologies,
identified by rightholders
2001/29/EC in order to
shall be appropriate and
through the cooperation
communicate or make
proportionate. The service
with the service providers.
available to the public
providers shall provide
Those measures, such as
works or other subject
rightholders with adequate
the use of effective content
matter. Where no such
information on the
recognition technologies,
authorisation has been
functioning and the
shall be therefore
obtained, the service
deployment of the
conclude fair and
provider shall prevent
measures, as well as, when
appropriate and
the availability on its
relevant, adequate
proportionate. The service
service of those works and
reporting on the
providers shall provide
other subject-matter
recognition and use of the
rightholders with adequate
uploaded by matter,
works and other subject-
information on the
including through the
matter.
functioning and the
application of measures
deployment of the
referred to in paragraph
measures, as well as, when
4. This subparagraph
relevant, adequate
shall apply without
reporting on the
prejudice to exceptions
recognition and use of the
works and other subject-
73

Location
COMMISSION
EP TEXT
COUNCIL TEXT
POSSIBLE
PROPOSAL
COMPROMISE
doc. 9134/18
COM(2016)593
SOLUTION
matter. licensing
and limitations provided
agreements with right
for in Union law.
holders.
Member States shall
provide that when an
authorisation has been
obtained, including via a
licensing agreement, by
an online content sharing
service provider, this
authorisation shall also
cover acts of uploading
by the users of the service
falling within Article 3 of
Directive 2001/29/EC
when they are not acting
on a commercial basis.

[Last two sentences of
COM proposal were
moved to Council’s
paragraphs 5 and 6
respectively]

239.
Art. 13, para
2. Member States shall
2 (EP)
ensure that the Licensing
agreements which are
concluded by online
content sharing 
service
74

Location
COMMISSION
EP TEXT
COUNCIL TEXT
POSSIBLE
PROPOSAL
COMPROMISE
doc. 9134/18
COM(2016)593
SOLUTION
providers with right
holders for the acts of
communication 
referred to
in paragraph 1 put in place
complaints and redress
mechanisms that are
available to users in case
of disputes over the
application of the measures
referred to in paragraph 1. ,
shall cover the liability for
works uploaded by the
users of such online
content sharing services
in line with the terms and
conditions set out in the
licensing agreement,
provided that such users
do not act for commercial
purposes
.
[See Council’s paragraph
1, subparagraph 3 (row
238)]

240.
Art. 13, para
2a.
Member States
2a (EP)
shall provide that where
right holders do not wish

75

Location
COMMISSION
EP TEXT
COUNCIL TEXT
POSSIBLE
PROPOSAL
COMPROMISE
doc. 9134/18
COM(2016)593
SOLUTION
to conclude licensing
agreements, online
content sharing service
providers and right
holders shall cooperate in
good faith in order to
ensure that unauthorised
protected works or other
subject matter are not
available on their services.
Cooperation between
online content service
providers and right
holders shall not lead to
preventing the availability
of non-infringing works
or other protected subject
matter, including those
covered by an exception or
limitation to copyright.

241.
Art. 13, para
2.
Member States
2b.
Members States
[Paragraph 2 of the COM
2 / para 2b
shall ensure that the
shall ensure that online
proposal was moved to
(EP)
service providers referred
content sharing service
new paragraph 7 of
to in paragraph 1 put in
providers referred to in
Council’s text]
place complaints and
paragraph 1 put in place
redress mechanisms that
effective and expeditious
are available to users in
complaints and redress
76

Location
COMMISSION
EP TEXT
COUNCIL TEXT
POSSIBLE
PROPOSAL
COMPROMISE
doc. 9134/18
COM(2016)593
SOLUTION
case of disputes over the
mechanisms that are
application of the measures
available to users in case
referred to in paragraph 1.
the cooperation referred
to in paragraph 2a leads
to unjustified removals of
their content. Any
complaint filed under
such mechanisms shall be
processed without undue
delay and be subject to
human review. Right
holders shall reasonably
justify their decisions to
avoid arbitrary dismissal
of complaints. Moreover,
in accordance with
Directive 95/46/EC,
Directive 2002/58/EC and
the General Data
Protection Regulation, the
cooperation shall not lead
to any identification of
individual users nor the
processing of their
personal data. Member
States shall also ensure
that users have access to
an independent body for

77

Location
COMMISSION
EP TEXT
COUNCIL TEXT
POSSIBLE
PROPOSAL
COMPROMISE
doc. 9134/18
COM(2016)593
SOLUTION
the resolution of disputes
as well as to a court or
another relevant judicial
authority to assert the use
of an exception or
limitation to copyright
rules.
[See Council’s Article
13(7) (row 252)]

242.
Art. 13, para
3.
Member States
3.
As of [date of entry
[See new paragraph 8 of
[to be further discussed]
3 (EP)
shall facilitate, where
into force of this
Council’s text]
appropriate, the
directive], the Commission
cooperation between the
and the Member States
information society service
shall facilitate where
providers and rightholders
appropriate, the
through stakeholder
cooperation organise
dialogues to define best
dialogues between the
practices, such as
information society service
appropriate and
providers and rightholders
proportionate content
through stakeholder
recognition technologies,
dialogues stakeholders to
taking into account, among
harmonise and to define
others, the nature of the
best practices, such as
services, the availability of
appropriate and
the technologies and their
proportionate content
effectiveness in light of
recognition technologies,
78

Location
COMMISSION
EP TEXT
COUNCIL TEXT
POSSIBLE
PROPOSAL
COMPROMISE
doc. 9134/18
COM(2016)593
SOLUTION
technological
taking into account, among
developments.
others, the nature of the
services, the availability of
the technologies and their
effectiveness in light of
technological
developments. and issue
guidance to ensure the
functioning of licensing
agreements and on
cooperation between
online content sharing
service providers and right
holders for the use of their
works or other subject
matter within the meaning
of this Directive. When
defining best practices,
special account shall be
taken of fundamental
rights, the use of
exceptions and limitations
as well as ensuring that
the burden on SMEs
remains appropriate and
that automated blocking
of content is avoided.

79

Location
COMMISSION
EP TEXT
COUNCIL TEXT
POSSIBLE
PROPOSAL
COMPROMISE
doc. 9134/18
COM(2016)593
SOLUTION
243.
Art. 13, para
3.
When an online
[to be further discussed at
3 (Council)
content sharing service
political level]
provider performs an act
of communication to the
public or an act of
making available to the
public, it shall not be
eligible for the exemption
of liability provided for
in Article 14 of Directive
2000/31/EC for
unauthorised acts of
communication to the
public and making
available to the public,
without prejudice to the
possible application of
Article 14 of Directive
2000/31/EC to those
services for purposes
other than copyright
relevant acts.

244.
Art. 13, para
4.
In the absence of
[to be further discussed at
4,
the authorisation
political level]
introductory
referred to in the second
part
subparagraph of
80

Location
COMMISSION
EP TEXT
COUNCIL TEXT
POSSIBLE
PROPOSAL
COMPROMISE
doc. 9134/18
COM(2016)593
SOLUTION
paragraph 1, Member
States shall provide that
an online content sharing
service provider shall not
be liable for acts of
communication to the
public or making
available to the public
within the meaning of
this Article when:

245.
Art. 13, para
(a)
it demonstrates
[to be further discussed at
4, point (a)
that it has made best
political level]
efforts to prevent the
availability of specific
works or other subject
matter by implementing
effective and
proportionate measures,
in accordance with
paragraph 5, to prevent
the availability on its
services of the specific
works or other subject
matter identified by
rightholders and for

81

Location
COMMISSION
EP TEXT
COUNCIL TEXT
POSSIBLE
PROPOSAL
COMPROMISE
doc. 9134/18
COM(2016)593
SOLUTION
which the rightholders
have provided the service
with relevant and
necessary information for
the application of these
measures; and

246.
Art. 13, para
(b)
upon notification
[to be further discussed at
4, point (b)
by rightholders of works
political level]
or other subject matter,
it has acted
expeditiously to remove
or disable access to these
works or other subject
matter and it
demonstrates that it has
made its best efforts to
prevent 
their usersfuture
availability through the
measures referred to in
point (a).

247.
Art. 13, para
5.
The measures
[to be further discussed at
5,
referred to in point (a) of
political level]
introductory
paragraph 4 shall be
part
effective and
proportionate, taking

82

Location
COMMISSION
EP TEXT
COUNCIL TEXT
POSSIBLE
PROPOSAL
COMPROMISE
doc. 9134/18
COM(2016)593
SOLUTION
into account, among
other factors:

248.
Art. 13, para
(a)
the nature and
[to be further discussed at
5, point (a)
size of the services, in
political level]
particular whether they
are provided by a
microenterprise or a
small-sized enterprise
within the meaning of
Title I of the Annex to
Commission
Recommendation
2003/361/EC, and their
audience;

249.
Art. 13, para
(b)
the amount and
[to be further discussed at
5, point (b)
the type of works or
political level]
other subject matter
uploaded by the users of
the services;

250.
Art. 13, para
(c)
the availability
[to be further discussed at
5, point (c)
and costs of the measures
political level]
as well as their
effectiveness in light of
technological
developments in line with

83

Location
COMMISSION
EP TEXT
COUNCIL TEXT
POSSIBLE
PROPOSAL
COMPROMISE
doc. 9134/18
COM(2016)593
SOLUTION
the industry best practice
referred to in paragraph
8.

251.
Art. 13, para
6.
Member States
[to be further discussed at
6
shall ensure that online
political level]
content sharing service
providers and
rightholders cooperate
with each other in a
diligent manner to
ensure the effective
functioning of the
measures referred to in
point (a) of paragraph 4
over time. Online content
sharing service providers
shall provide
rightholders, at their
request, with adequate
information on the
deployment and
functioning of these
measures to allow the
assessment of their
effectiveness, in
particular information
on the type of measures

84

Location
COMMISSION
EP TEXT
COUNCIL TEXT
POSSIBLE
PROPOSAL
COMPROMISE
doc. 9134/18
COM(2016)593
SOLUTION
used and, where licensing
agreements are
concluded between
service providers and
rightholders, information
on the use of content
covered by the
agreements.

252.
Art. 13, para
7.
Member States
[to be further discussed at
7
shall ensure that the
political level]
measures referred to in
paragraph 4 are
implemented by the
online content sharing
service provider without
prejudice to the
possibility for their users
to benefit from
exceptions or limitations
to copyright. For that
purpose, 
the service
providers referred to in
paragraph 1 shall put in
place complaints and
redress mechanisms that
are is available to users of
the service in case of
85

Location
COMMISSION
EP TEXT
COUNCIL TEXT
POSSIBLE
PROPOSAL
COMPROMISE
doc. 9134/18
COM(2016)593
SOLUTION
disputes over the
application of the
measures reffered to in
paragraph 1 to their
content. Complaints
submitted under this
mechanism shall be
processed by the online
content sharing service
provider in cooperation
with relevant
rightholders within a
reasonable period of
time. Rightholders shall
duly justify the reasons
for their requests to
remove or block access to
their specific works or
other subject matter.
Member States shall
endeavour to put in place
independent bodies to
assess complaints related
to the application of the
measures.

[Paragraph 2 of the COM
proposal, amended]
86

Location
COMMISSION
EP TEXT
COUNCIL TEXT
POSSIBLE
PROPOSAL
COMPROMISE
doc. 9134/18
COM(2016)593
SOLUTION
253.
Art. 13, para
8.
The Commission
[to be further discussed at
8
and the Member States
political level]
shall encourage
stakeholder dialogues to
define best practices for
the measures referred to
in point (a) of paragraph
4. Member States shall
also endeavour to
establish mechanisms to
facilitate the assessment
of the effectiveness and
proportionality of these
measures and provide
the Commission
regularly with
information on those
mechanisms. The
Commission shall, in
consultation with online
content sharing service
providers, rightholders
and other relevant
stakeholders and taking
into account the results
of the stakeholder
dialogues and the

87

Location
COMMISSION
EP TEXT
COUNCIL TEXT
POSSIBLE
PROPOSAL
COMPROMISE
doc. 9134/18
COM(2016)593
SOLUTION
national mechanisms,
issue guidance on the
application of the
measures referred to in
point (a) of paragraph 4.

[Paragraph 3 of the COM
proposal, reworded]
254.
Art. 13a,
Article 13a
title
255.
Art. 13a,
Member States shall
sub-para 1
provide that disputes
between successors in title
and information society
services regarding the
application of Article
13(1) may be subject to an
alternative dispute
resolution system.

256.
Art. 13a,
Member States shall
sub-para 2
establish or designate an
impartial body with the
necessary expertise, with
the aim of helping the

88

Location
COMMISSION
EP TEXT
COUNCIL TEXT
POSSIBLE
PROPOSAL
COMPROMISE
doc. 9134/18
COM(2016)593
SOLUTION
parties to settle their
disputes under this system.

257.
Art. 13a,
The Member States shall
sub-para 3
inform the Commission of
the establishment of this
body no later than (date
mentioned in Article
21(1)).

258.
Art. 13b,
Article 13b
title
Use of protected content
by information society
services providing
automated image
referencing
259.
Art. 13b
Member States shall
ensure that information
society service providers
that automatically
reproduce or refer to
significant amounts of
copyright-protected visual
works and make them
available to the public for
the purpose of indexing
and referencing conclude

89

Location
COMMISSION
EP TEXT
COUNCIL TEXT
POSSIBLE
PROPOSAL
COMPROMISE
doc. 9134/18
COM(2016)593
SOLUTION
fair and balanced
licensing agreements with
any requesting
rightholders in order to
ensure their fair
remuneration. Such
remuneration may be
managed by the collective
management organisation
of the rightholders
concerned.

260.
TITLE IV
MEASURES TO
ACHIEVE A WELL-
FUNCTIONING
MARKETPLACE FOR
COPYRIGHT
261.
CHAPTER 3
CHAPTER 3
CHAPTER 3
[to be discussed at political
Fair remuneration in
Fair remuneration in
Fair remuneration in
level]
contracts of authors and
contracts of authors and
exploitation contracts of
performers
performers
authors and performers
262.
Art. -14,
Article -14
[Article -14 to be further
title
discussed at political level]
90

Location
COMMISSION
EP TEXT
COUNCIL TEXT
POSSIBLE
PROPOSAL
COMPROMISE
doc. 9134/18
COM(2016)593
SOLUTION
Principle of fair and
proportionate
remuneration

263.
Art. -14,
1.
Member States
para 1
shall ensure that authors
and performers receive
fair and proportionate
remuneration for the
exploitation of their works
and other subject matter,
including for their online
exploitation. This may be
achieved in each sector
through a combination of
agreements, including
collective bargaining
agreements, and statutory
remuneration
mechanisms.

264.
Art. -14,
2.
Paragraph 1 shall
para 2
not apply where an author
or performer grants a
non-exclusive usage right
for the benefit of all users
free of charge.

91

Location
COMMISSION
EP TEXT
COUNCIL TEXT
POSSIBLE
PROPOSAL
COMPROMISE
doc. 9134/18
COM(2016)593
SOLUTION
265.
Art. -14,
3.
Member States
para 3
shall take account of the
specificities of each sector
in encouraging the
proportionate
remuneration for rights
granted by authors and
performers.

266.
Art. -14,
4.
Contracts shall
para 4
specify the remuneration
applicable to each mode of
exploitation.

267.
Art. 14, title
Article 14
Article 14
Article 14
Article 14
Transparency obligation
Transparency obligation
Transparency obligation
Transparency obligation
268.
Art. 14, para
1.
Member States
1.
Member States
1.
Member States
1. Member States shall
1
shall ensure that authors
shall ensure that authors
shall ensure that authors
ensure that authors and
and performers receive on
and performers receive on
and performers receive on
performers receive on a
a regular basis and taking
a regular basis, not less
a regular basis, at least
regular basis, at least once a
into account the
than once a year , and
once a year, and taking
year, and taking into account
specificities of each sector,
taking into account the
into account the
the specificities of each
timely, adequate and
specificities of each sector
specificities of each sector,
sector [and the relative
sufficient information on
and the relative
timely, adequate and
importance of each
the exploitation of their
importance of each
sufficient information on
individual contribution],
works and performances
individual contribution,
the exploitation of their
timely, [adequate and
from those to whom they
timely adequate and
works and performances
sufficient/ up to date,
92

Location
COMMISSION
EP TEXT
COUNCIL TEXT
POSSIBLE
PROPOSAL
COMPROMISE
doc. 9134/18
COM(2016)593
SOLUTION
have licensed or
sufficient, accurate,
from those to whom they
relevant and comprehensive
transferred their rights,
relevant and
have licensed or
information on the
notably as regards modes
comprehensive
transferred their rights or
exploitation of their works
of exploitation, revenues
information on the
their successors in title,
and performances from those
generated and
exploitation of their works
notably as regards modes
to whom they have licensed
remuneration due.
and performances from
of exploitation, revenues
or transferred their rights or
those to whom they have
generated and
their successors in title,
licensed or transferred
remuneration due.
notably as regards modes of
their rights, notably as
exploitation, direct and
regards modes of
indirect all(*) revenues
exploitation, direct and
generated and remuneration
indirect revenues
due.
generated, and
[(*) subject to explicit
remuneration due.
reference to 'merchandising'
as example of a possible
form of covered revenues in
the recitals (see recital
(40a), row 92, and recital
(42), row 95]

[yellow part depending
agreement on Article 14(3)]

269.
Art. 14, para
1a.
Member States
1a.
Member States
[To  be further discussed  at
1a
shall ensure that where
shall ensure that where
political level, to be prepared
the licensee or transferee
the rights referred to in
at TM]
of rights of authors and
paragraph 1 have
performers subsequently
subsequently been
93

Location
COMMISSION
EP TEXT
COUNCIL TEXT
POSSIBLE
PROPOSAL
COMPROMISE
doc. 9134/18
COM(2016)593
SOLUTION
licenses those rights to
licensed to another party,
another party, such party
authors and performers
shall share all
may, at their request,
information referred to in
receive from those third
paragraph 1 with the
parties additional
licensee or transferee.
information if their first
contractual counterpart
does not hold all the
information that would
be necessary for the
purposes of the
information provision set
out in paragraph 1.
Member States may
provide that such request
to those third parties is
made directly by the
author or performer or
indirectly through the
contractual counterpart
of the author or the
performer.

270.
Art. 14, para
The main licensee or
[to be discussed at Trilogue]
1a, sub-
transferee shall pass all
para 2
the information referred
to in the first
subparagraph on to the

94

Location
COMMISSION
EP TEXT
COUNCIL TEXT
POSSIBLE
PROPOSAL
COMPROMISE
doc. 9134/18
COM(2016)593
SOLUTION
author or performer. That
information shall be
unchanged, except in the
case of commercially
sensitive information as
defined by Union or
national law, which,
without prejudice to
Articles 15 and 16a, may
be subject to a non-
disclosure agreement, for
the purpose of preserving
fair competition. Where
the main licensee or
transferee does not
provide the information as
referred to in this
subparagraph in a timely
manner, the author or
performer shall be entitled
to request that
information directly from
the sub-licensee.
[See Council’s Article
14(1a) (row 269)]

95

Location
COMMISSION
EP TEXT
COUNCIL TEXT
POSSIBLE
PROPOSAL
COMPROMISE
doc. 9134/18
COM(2016)593
SOLUTION
271.
Art. 14, para
2.
The obligation in
2.
The obligation in
2.
The obligation in
GREEN
2
paragraph 1 shall be
paragraph 1 shall be
paragraph 1 shall be
2.
The obligation in
proportionate and effective
proportionate and effective
proportionate and effective
paragraph 1 shall be
and shall ensure an
and shall ensure an
and shall ensure an
proportionate and effective
appropriate level of
appropriate a high level of
appropriate level of
and shall to ensure an
transparency in every
transparency in every
transparency in every
appropriate a high level of
sector. However, in those
sector. However, in those
sector. However, in
transparency in every sector.
cases where the
cases where the
thoseMember States may
Member States may
administrative burden
administrative burden
provide that in duly
provide that in duly
resulting from the
resulting from the
justified cases where the
justified cases where the
obligation would be
obligation would be
administrative burden
administrative burden
disproportionate in view of
disproportionate in view of
resulting from the
resulting from the obligation
the revenues generated by
the revenues generated by
obligation in paragraph 1
in paragraph 1 would
the exploitation of the
the exploitation of the
would bebecome
bebecome disproportionate
work or performance,
work or performance,
disproportionate in view of
in view of the revenues
Member States may adjust
Member States may adjust
the revenues generated by
generated by the exploitation
the obligation in paragraph
the obligation in paragraph
the exploitation of the
of the work or performance,
1, provided that the
1, provided that the
work or performance,
the obligation is limited to
obligation remains
obligation remains
Member States may adjust
the types and level of
effective and ensures an
effective and ensures an
the obligation in paragraph
information that can
appropriate level of
appropriate a high level of
1, provided that is limited
reasonably be expected in
transparency.
transparency.
to the obligation remains
such cases.
effectivetypes and ensures
an appropriate level of
[provisionally agreed at
transparency.information
TTrilogue 26/11/2018]
that can reasonably be
expected in such cases.

96

Location
COMMISSION
EP TEXT
COUNCIL TEXT
POSSIBLE
PROPOSAL
COMPROMISE
doc. 9134/18
COM(2016)593
SOLUTION
272.
Art. 14, para
3.
Member States may Deleted
3.
Member States may
3.
[Council preference:
3
decide that the obligation
decide that the obligation
Member States may decide
in paragraph 1 does not
in paragraph 1 does not
that the obligation in
apply when the
apply when the
paragraph 1 does not apply
contribution of the author
contribution of the author
when the contribution of the
or performer is not
or performer is not
author or performer is not
significant having regard
significant having regard
significant having regard to
to the overall work or
to the overall work or
the overall work or
performance.
performance.
performance.]
[EP 
compromise 
proposal:
Member States may decide that
in  the  case  of  authors  and
performers whose contribution
is 

not 
significant 
having
regard  to  the  overall  work  or
performance the  obligation  in
paragraph  1  apply  only  on
request  of  the  author  or
performer.
]
[to be discussed at political
level]

273.
Art. 14, para
3a.
Members States
GREEN
3a
may provide that for
3a. Members States may
agreements subject to or
provide that for agreements
based on collective
subject to or based on
bargaining agreements
collective bargaining
97

Location
COMMISSION
EP TEXT
COUNCIL TEXT
POSSIBLE
PROPOSAL
COMPROMISE
doc. 9134/18
COM(2016)593
SOLUTION
the transparency rules of
agreements the
the relevant collective
transparency rules of the
bargaining agreement
relevant collective
are applicable provided
bargaining agreement are
that they meet the
applicable provided that
minimum criteria laid
they are comparable to the
down in the national
obligations / meet the
provisions adopted in
minimum criteria laid down
conformity with the
in the national provisions
requirements of
adopted in conformity with
paragraphs 1 to 3.
the requirements of
paragraphs 1 to 3.

[provisionally agreed at
rilogue 26/11/2018]

274.
Art. 14, para
4.
Paragraph 1 shall
4.
Paragraph 1 shall
4.
Paragraph 1 shall
GREEN
4
not be applicable to entities
not be applicable to entities
not be applicable to
4. Paragraph 1 shall not be
subject to the transparency
subject to the transparency
agreements concluded by
applicable to a Agreements
obligations established by
obligations established by
entities subject to the
concluded by entities defined
Directive 2014/26/EU.
Directive 2014/26/EU or
transparency obligations
in Article 3(a) and (b) of
to collective bargaining
established by defined in
Directive 2014/26/EU or by
agreements, where those
Article 3(a) and (b) of
other entities subject to the
obligations or agreements
Directive 2014/26/EU. or
national rules implementing
provide for transparency
by other entities subject
Directive 2014/26/EU shall
requirements comparable
to the national rules
not be subject to the
to those referred to in
implementing Directive
obligation laid down in
paragraph 2.
2014/26/EU.
paragraph 1 when Article
98

Location
COMMISSION
EP TEXT
COUNCIL TEXT
POSSIBLE
PROPOSAL
COMPROMISE
doc. 9134/18
COM(2016)593
SOLUTION
18 of Directive 2014/26/EU
is applicable.
[ aim of the
paragraph provisionally
agreed at Trilogue
26/11/2018/; actual text
provisionally agreed at TM
29/11/2018, together with
wording of recital 41, row
94 tbc at trilogue]

275.
Art. 15, title
Article 15
Article 15
Article 15
Article 15
Contract adjustment
Contract adjustment
Contract adjustment
Contract adjustment
mechanism
mechanism
mechanism
mechanism
276.
Art. 15,
Member States shall
Member States shall
1.
Member States
1. Member States shall
[para 1
ensure that authors and
ensure, in the absence of
shall ensure that authors
ensure, in the absence of an
(Council)]
performers are entitled to
collective bargaining
and performers are entitled
applicable collective
request additional,
agreements providing for
to request additional,
bargaining agreement
appropriate remuneration
a comparable mechanism,
appropriate remuneration
providing for a comparable
from the party with whom
that authors and
from the party with whom
mechanism, that authors and
they entered into a contract
performers or any
they entered into a contract
performers or any
for the exploitation of the
representative
for the exploitation of the
[representatives]
rights when the
organisation acting on
rights or their successors
[representative organisation
remuneration originally
their behalf are entitled to
in title, when the
acting [at the specific
agreed is
request claim additional,
remuneration originally
request / on behalf] of one
disproportionately low
appropriate and fair
agreed isturns out to be
or more authors or
compared to the
remuneration from the
disproportionately low
performers] are entitled to
subsequent relevant
party with whom they
compared to the
claim additional, appropriate
99

Location
COMMISSION
EP TEXT
COUNCIL TEXT
POSSIBLE
PROPOSAL
COMPROMISE
doc. 9134/18
COM(2016)593
SOLUTION
revenues and benefits
entered into a contract for
subsequent relevant
and fair remuneration from
derived from the
the exploitation of the
revenues and benefits
the party with whom they
exploitation of the works
rights when the
derived from the actual
entered into a contract for
or performances.
remuneration originally
exploitation of the works
the exploitation of the rights
agreed is
or performances.
or their successors in title,
disproportionately low
when the remuneration
compared to the
originally agreed turns out to
subsequent relevant direct
be disproportionately low
or indirect revenues and
compared to all the
benefits derived from the
subsequent relevant [direct
exploitation of the works
or indirectrevenues and
or performances.
benefits derived from the
exploitation of the works or
[See Council’s Article
performances.
15(1a) (row277)]
[to be discussed further at
political level;

Deletion of 'direct or
indirect' provisionally
agreed at Trilogue
26/11/2018: see comment on
Article 14(1), row 268]

277.
Art. 15, para
1a.
Members States
[Article 15(1a) Council’s
1a
may provide that for
text deleted/incorporated
agreements subject to or
into paragraph 1]
based on collective
bargaining agreements

100

Location
COMMISSION
EP TEXT
COUNCIL TEXT
POSSIBLE
PROPOSAL
COMPROMISE
doc. 9134/18
COM(2016)593
SOLUTION
the rules of the relevant
[provisionally agreed at TM
collective bargaining
tbc by trilogue]
agreement for the
adjustment of
remuneration are
applicable instead of the
national provisions
implementing the
contract adjustment
mechanism.

278.
Art. 15, para
2.
Paragraph 1 shall
[to be discussed at trilogue]
2
not be applicable to
agreements concluded by
entities defined in Article
3(a) and (b) of Directive
2014/26/EU or by other
entities subject to the
national rules
implementing Directive
2014/26/EU.

279.
Art. 16, title
Article 16
Article 16
Article 16
GREEN
Dispute resolution
Dispute resolution
Dispute resolution
Article 16
mechanism
mechanism
mechanismprocedure
Dispute resolution
procedure
101

Location
COMMISSION
EP TEXT
COUNCIL TEXT
POSSIBLE
PROPOSAL
COMPROMISE
doc. 9134/18
COM(2016)593
SOLUTION
[provisionally agreed at
Trilogue 26/11/2018]

280.
Art. 16,
Member States shall
Member States shall
1.
Member States
GREEN
[para 1
provide that disputes
provide that disputes
shall provide that disputes
Member States shall provide
(Council)]
concerning the
concerning the
concerning the
that disputes concerning the
transparency obligation
transparency obligation
transparency obligation
transparency obligation
under Article 14 and the
under Article 14 and the
under Article 14 and the
under Article 14 and the
contract adjustment
contract adjustment
contract adjustment
contract adjustment
mechanism under Article
mechanism under Article
mechanism under Article
mechanism under Article 15
15 may be submitted to a
15 may be submitted to a
15 may be submitted to a
may be submitted to a
voluntary, alternative
voluntary, alternative
voluntary, alternative
voluntary, alternative dispute
dispute resolution
dispute resolution
dispute resolution
resolution procedure.
procedure.
procedure. Member States
procedure.
Member States shall ensure
shall ensure that
that representative
representative
organisations of authors
organisations of authors
and performers may initiate
and performers may
such procedures at the
initiate such procedures at
specific request of one or
the request of one or more
more authors and
authors and performers.
performers.
[See Council’s Article
16(2) (row 281)]

[provisionally agreed at
Trilogue 26/11/2018]

102

Location
COMMISSION
EP TEXT
COUNCIL TEXT
POSSIBLE
PROPOSAL
COMPROMISE
doc. 9134/18
COM(2016)593
SOLUTION
281.
Art. 16, para
[See Parliament’s Article
2.
Member States
[Article 16(2) Council’s text
2
16 last phrase (row 280)]
shall ensure that
deleted/incorporated into
representative
paragraph 1]
organisations of authors
[provisionally agreed at
and performers,
Trilogue 26/11/2018]
including collective
management
organisations, may
initiate such disputes on
behalf of one or more
authors and performers
at their request.

282.
Art. 16a
Article 16a
GREEN
(Council),
Contractual provisions
Article 16a
title
Contractual Common
provisions
[provisionally agreed at
Trilogue 26/11/2018]

283.
Art. 16a
Member States shall
GREEN
(Council)
ensure that any
Member States shall
contractual provision
ensure that any contractual
which prevents the
provision which prevents
compliance with the
the compliance with the
provisions in Articles 14
provisions in Articles 14
103

Location
COMMISSION
EP TEXT
COUNCIL TEXT
POSSIBLE
PROPOSAL
COMPROMISE
doc. 9134/18
COM(2016)593
SOLUTION
and 15 of this Directive
and 15 of this Chapter(*)
shall be unenforceable in
Directive shall be
relation to authors and
unenforceable in relation
performers.
to authors and performers.
[(*) 'Chapter' refers to
Articles 14,15 and 16, ie the
provisions of the initial
Commission proposal]

[provisionally agreed at
Trilogue 26/11/2018]

284.
Art. 16a
Article 16 a
[Article 16a to be further
(EP), title
discussed at political level;
Right of revocation
Preparatory work to be done
at technical level]

285.
Art. 16a
1.
Member States
(EP),
shall ensure that where an
para 1
author or a performer has
licensed or transferred her
or his rights concerning a
work or other protected
subject-matter on an
exclusive basis, the author
or performer has a right
of revocation where there
is an absence of

104

Location
COMMISSION
EP TEXT
COUNCIL TEXT
POSSIBLE
PROPOSAL
COMPROMISE
doc. 9134/18
COM(2016)593
SOLUTION
exploitation of the work or
other protected subject
matter or where there is a
continuous lack of regular
reporting in accordance
with Article 14. Member
States may provide for
specific provisions taking
into account the
specificities of different
sectors and works and
anticipated exploitation
period, notably provide for
time limits for the right of
revocation.

286.
Art. 16a
2.
The right of
(EP),
revocation provided for in
para 2
paragraph 1 may be
exercised only after a
reasonable time from the
conclusion of the licence
or transfer agreement,
and only upon written
notification setting an
appropriate deadline by
which the exploitation of
the licensed or transferred

105

Location
COMMISSION
EP TEXT
COUNCIL TEXT
POSSIBLE
PROPOSAL
COMPROMISE
doc. 9134/18
COM(2016)593
SOLUTION
rights is to take place.
After the expiration of
that deadline, the author
or performer may choose
to terminate the
exclusivity of the contract
instead of revoking the
rights. Where a work or
other subject-matter
contains the contribution
of a plurality of authors or
performers, the exercise of
the individual right of
revocation of such
authors or performers
shall be regulated by
national law, laying down
the rules on the right of
revocation for collective
works, taking into account
the relative importance of
the individual
contributions.

287.
Art. 16a
3.
Paragraphs 1 and
(EP),
2 shall not apply if the
para 3
non-exercise of the rights
is predominantly due to

106

Location
COMMISSION
EP TEXT
COUNCIL TEXT
POSSIBLE
PROPOSAL
COMPROMISE
doc. 9134/18
COM(2016)593
SOLUTION
circumstances which the
author or the performer
can be reasonably
expected to remedy.

288.
Art. 16a
4.
Contractual or
(EP),
other arrangements
para 4
derogating from the right
of revocation shall be
lawful only if concluded
by means of an agreement
which is based on a
collective bargaining
agreement.

289.
TITLE V
TITLE V
TITLE V
TITLE V
FINAL PROVISIONS
FINAL PROVISIONS
FINAL PROVISIONS
FINAL PROVISIONS
290.
Art. 17,
Article 17
Article 17
Article 17
Article 17
title
Amendments to other
Amendments to other
Amendments to other
Amendments to other
directives
directives
directives
directives
291.
Art. 17, para
1.
Directive 96/9/EC
1.
Directive 96/9/EC
1.
Directive 96/9/EC
1.
Directive 96/9/EC is
1
is amended as follows:
is amended as follows:
is amended as follows:
amended as follows:
292.
Art. 17, para
(a)
In Article 6(2),
(a)
In Article 6(2),
(a)
In
Article
6(2),
(a)
In Article 6(2), point
1, point (a)
point (b) is replaced by the
point (b) is replaced by the
point (b) is replaced by the
(b) is replaced by the
following:
following:
following:
following:
107

Location
COMMISSION
EP TEXT
COUNCIL TEXT
POSSIBLE
PROPOSAL
COMPROMISE
doc. 9134/18
COM(2016)593
SOLUTION
293.
Art. 17, para
"(b) where there is use
"(b) where there is use
"(b) where there is use
GREEN
1, point (a)
for the sole purpose of
for the sole purpose of
for the sole purpose of
"(b) where there is use for
illustration for teaching
illustration for
illustration for teaching
the sole purpose of
or scientific research, as
teaching or scientific
or scientific research, as
illustration for teaching or
long as the source is
research, as long as the
long as the source is
scientific research, as
indicated and to the
source is indicated and
indicated and to the
long as the source is
extent justified by the
to the extent justified
extent justified by the
indicated and to the
non-commercial
by the non-
non-commercial
extent justified by the
purpose to be achieved,
commercial purpose to
purpose to be achieved,
non-commercial purpose
without prejudice to the
be achieved, without
without prejudice to the
to be achieved, without
exceptions and the
prejudice to the
exceptions and the
prejudice to the
limitation provided for
exceptions and the
limitation provided for
exceptions and the
in Directive [this
limitation provided for
in Articles 3 and 4 of
limitation provided for in
Directive];"
in Directive [this
Directive [this
Articles 3 and 4 of
Directive];"
Directive];"
Directive [this
Directive];"
[ provisionally agreed at
technical meeting of
13.11.2018]

294.
Art. 17, para
(b)
In Article 9, point
(b)
In Article 9, point
(b)
In Article 9, point
(b)
In Article 9, point (b)
1, point (b)
(b) is replaced by the
(b) is replaced by the
(b) is replaced by the
is replaced by the following:
following:
following:
following:
295.
Art. 17, para
"(b) in the case of
"(b) in the case of
"(b) in the case of
GREEN
1, point (b)
extraction for the
extraction for the
extraction for the
purposes of illustration
purposes of illustration
purposes of illustration
108

Location
COMMISSION
EP TEXT
COUNCIL TEXT
POSSIBLE
PROPOSAL
COMPROMISE
doc. 9134/18
COM(2016)593
SOLUTION
for teaching or
for teaching or scientific
for teaching or
"(b) in the case of extraction for
scientific research, as
research, as long as the
scientific research, as
the purposes of illustration for
long as the source is
source is indicated and
long as the source is
teaching or scientific research,
indicated and to the
to the extent justified by
indicated and to the
as long as the source is
extent justified by the
the non-commercial
extent justified by the
indicated and to the extent
justified by the non-commercial
non-commercial
purpose to be achieved,
non-commercial
purpose to be achieved, without
purpose to be achieved,
without prejudice to the
purpose to be achieved,
prejudice to the exceptions and
without prejudice to the
exceptions and the
without prejudice to the
the limitation provided for in
exceptions and the
limitation provided for
exceptions and the
Articles 3 and 4 of Directive
limitation provided for
in Directive [this
limitation provided for
[this Directive];"
in Directive [this
Directive];"
in Articles 3 and 4 of
[provisionally agreed at
Directive];"
Directive [this
technical meeting of
Directive];"
13.11.2018]
296.
Art. 17, para
2.
Directive
2.
Directive
2.
Directive
2.
Directive
2
2001/29/EC is amended as
2001/29/EC is amended as
2001/29/EC is amended as
2001/29/EC is amended as
follows:
follows:
follows:
follows:
297.
Art. 17, para
(a)
In Article 5(2),
(a)
In Article 5(2),
(a)
In
Article
5(2),
(a)
In Article 5(2), point
2, point (a)
point (c) is replaced by the
point (c) is replaced by the
point (c) is replaced by the
(c) is replaced by the
following:
following:
following:
following:
298.
Art. 17,
"(c) in respect of specific
"(c) in respect of
"(c) in respect of
GREEN
para 2,
acts of reproduction
specific acts of
specific acts of
"(c) in respect of specific
point (a)
made by publicly
reproduction made by
reproduction made by
acts of reproduction made
accessible libraries,
publicly accessible
publicly accessible
by publicly accessible
educational
libraries, educational
libraries, educational
libraries, educational
establishments or
establishments or
establishments or
109

Location
COMMISSION
EP TEXT
COUNCIL TEXT
POSSIBLE
PROPOSAL
COMPROMISE
doc. 9134/18
COM(2016)593
SOLUTION
museums, or by archives,
museums, or by
museums, or by
establishments or
which are not for direct
archives, which are not
archives, which are not
museums, or by archives,
or indirect economic or
for direct or indirect
for direct or indirect
which are not for direct or
commercial advantage,
economic or
economic or
indirect economic or
without prejudice to the
commercial advantage,
commercial advantage,
commercial advantage,
exceptions and the
without prejudice to the
without prejudice to the
without prejudice to the
limitation provided for in
exceptions and the
exceptions and the
exception and the
Directive [this
limitation provided for
limitationexception
limitations provided for
Directive];"
in Directive [this
provided for in Article
in Article 5 of Directive
Directive];"
5 of Directive [this
[this Directive];"
Directive];"
[provisionally agreed at
technical meeting of
13.11.2018]

299.
Art. 17, para
(b)
In Article 5(3),
(b)
In Article 5(3),
(b)
In
Article
5(3),
(b)
In Article 5(3), point
2, point (b)
point (a) is replaced by the
point (a) is replaced by the
point (a) is replaced by the
(a) is replaced by the
following:
following:
following:
following:
300.
Art. 17,
"(a) use for the sole
"(a) use for the sole
"(a) use for the sole
GREEN
para 2,
purpose of illustration for
purpose of illustration for
purpose of illustration
"(a) use for the sole
point (b)
teaching or scientific
teaching or scientific
for teaching or
purpose of illustration for
research, as long as the
research, as long as the
scientific research, as
teaching or scientific
source, including the
source, including the
long as the source,
research, as long as the
author's name, is
author's name, is
including the author's
source, including the
indicated, unless this
indicated, unless this
name, is indicated,
author's name, is
turns out to be
turns out to be impossible
unless this turns out to
indicated, unless this
impossible and to the
and to the extent justified
be impossible and to the
turns out to be impossible
extent justified by the
by the non-commercial
extent justified by the
110

Location
COMMISSION
EP TEXT
COUNCIL TEXT
POSSIBLE
PROPOSAL
COMPROMISE
doc. 9134/18
COM(2016)593
SOLUTION
non-commercial purpose
purpose to be achieved,
non-commercial
and to the extent justified
to be achieved, without
without prejudice to the
purpose to be achieved,
by the non-commercial
prejudice to the
exceptions and the
without prejudice to the
purpose to be achieved,
exceptions and the
limitation provided for in
exceptions and the
without prejudice to the
limitation provided for in
Directive [this
limitation provided for
exceptions and the
Directive [this
Directive];"
in Articles 3 and 4 of
limitation provided for in
Directive];"
Directive [this
Articles 3 and 4 of
Directive];"
Directive [this
Directive];"
[provisionally agreed at
technical meeting of
13.11.2018]

301.
Art. 17, para
(c)
In Article 12(4), the
(c)
In Article 12(4), the
(c)
In Article 12(4), the
(c)
In Article 12(4), the
2, point (c)
following points are added:
following points are added:
following points are added:
following points are added:
302.
Art. 17, para
"(e) to examine the
"(e) to examine the
"(e) to examine the
"(e) to examine the impact of
2, point (c)
impact of the
impact of the
impact of the
the transposition of Directive
transposition of Directive
transposition of Directive
transposition of
[this Directive] on the
[this Directive] on the
[this Directive] on the
Directive [this Directive]
functioning of the internal
functioning of the
functioning of the
on the functioning of the
market and to highlight any
internal market and to
internal market and to
internal market and to
transposition difficulties;
highlight any
highlight any
highlight any
transposition difficulties;
transposition difficulties;
transposition difficulties;
303.
Art. 17, para
(f) to facilitate the
(f) to facilitate the
(f) to facilitate the
(f) to facilitate the exchange
2, point (c)
exchange of information
exchange of information
exchange of information
of information on the
on the relevant
on the relevant
on the relevant
relevant developments in
111

Location
COMMISSION
EP TEXT
COUNCIL TEXT
POSSIBLE
PROPOSAL
COMPROMISE
doc. 9134/18
COM(2016)593
SOLUTION
developments in
developments in
developments in
legislation and case law as
legislation and case law
legislation and case law
legislation and case law
well as on the practical
as well as on the
as well as on the practical
as well as on the
application of the measures
practical application of
application of the
practical application of
taken by Member States to
the measures taken by
measures taken by
the measures taken by
implement Directive [this
Member States to
Member States to
Member States to
Directive];
implement Directive [this
implement Directive [this
implement Directive
Directive];
Directive];
[this Directive];
304.
Art. 17, para
(g) to discuss any other
(g) to discuss any other
(g) to discuss any other
(g) to discuss any other
2, point (c)
questions arising from
questions arising from the
questions arising from
questions arising from the
the application of
application of Directive
the application of
application of Directive [this
Directive [this
[this Directive]."
Directive [this
Directive]."
Directive]."
Directive]."
305.
Art. 17a,
Article 17 a
GREEN
title
Article 17 a
306.
Art. 17a
Member States may adopt
GREEN
or maintain in force
Member States may adopt or
broader provisions,
maintain  in  force  broader
compatible with the
provisions,  compatible  with
exceptions and limitations
the 
exceptions 
and
existing in Union law, for
limitations 
set 
out 
in
uses covered by the
Directives 
96/9/EC 
and
exceptions or the
2001/29/EC,  for  uses
or
fields
covered 
by 
the
112

Location
COMMISSION
EP TEXT
COUNCIL TEXT
POSSIBLE
PROPOSAL
COMPROMISE
doc. 9134/18
COM(2016)593
SOLUTION
limitation provided for in
exceptions  or  limitations
this Directive.
provided for in this Directive
and  on  condition that  their
application 

does 
not
adversely 
affect 
nor
circumvent  the  mandatory
rules set out in this Directive.

[provisional agreement at
trilogue 25/10/2018
/26/11/2018; a recital should
clarify that Article 17a does
not allow MS to not
implement the mandatory
exceptions under this
Directive]

307.
Art. 18
Article 18
Article 18
Article 18
Article 18
Application in time
Application in time
Application in time
Application in time
308.
Art. 18, para
1.
This Directive shall
1.
This Directive shall
1.
This Directive shall
1.
This Directive shall
1
apply in respect of all
apply in respect of all
apply in respect of all
apply in respect of all works
works and other subject-
works and other subject-
works and other subject-
and other subject-matter
matter which are protected
matter which are protected
matter which are protected
which are protected by the
by the Member States'
by the Member States'
by the Member States'
Member States' legislation in
legislation in the field of
legislation in the field of
legislation in the field of
the field of copyright on or
copyright on or after [the
copyright on or after [the
copyright on or after [the
after [the date mentioned in
Article 21(1)].
113

Location
COMMISSION
EP TEXT
COUNCIL TEXT
POSSIBLE
PROPOSAL
COMPROMISE
doc. 9134/18
COM(2016)593
SOLUTION
date mentioned in Article
date mentioned in Article
date mentioned in Article
21(1)].
21(1)].
21(1)].
309.
Art. 18, para
2.
The provisions of
Deleted
2.
[Deleted]
(Deleted)
2
Article 11 shall also apply
to press publications
published before [the date
mentioned in Article
21(1)].
310.
Art. 18, para
3.
This Directive shall
3.
This Directive shall
3.
This Directive shall
3.
This Directive shall
3
apply without prejudice to
apply without prejudice to
apply without prejudice to
apply without prejudice to
any acts concluded and
any acts concluded and
any acts concluded and
any acts concluded and
rights acquired before [the
rights acquired before [the
rights acquired before [the
rights acquired before [the
date mentioned in Article
date mentioned in Article
date mentioned in Article
date mentioned in Article
21(1)].
21(1)].
21(1)].
21(1)].
311.
Art. 19, title
Article 19
Article 19
Article 19
Article 19
Transitional provision
Transitional provision
Transitional provision
Transitional provision
312.
Art. 19
Agreements for the licence
Agreements for the licence
Agreements for the licence
Agreements for the licence
or transfer of rights of
or transfer of rights of
or transfer of rights of
or transfer of rights of
authors and performers
authors and performers
authors and performers
authors and performers shall
shall be subject to the
shall be subject to the
shall be subject to the
be subject to the
transparency obligation in
transparency obligation in
transparency obligation in
transparency obligation in
Article 14 as from [one
Article 14 as from [one
Article 14 as from [one
Article 14 as from [one year
year after the date
year after the date
year after the date
after the date mentioned in
Article 21(1)].
114

Location
COMMISSION
EP TEXT
COUNCIL TEXT
POSSIBLE
PROPOSAL
COMPROMISE
doc. 9134/18
COM(2016)593
SOLUTION
mentioned in Article
mentioned in Article
mentioned in Article
21(1)].
21(1)].
21(1)].
313.
Art. 20, title
Article 20
Article 20
Article 20
Article 20
Protection of personal
Protection of personal
Protection of personal
Protection of personal data
data
data
data
314.
Art. 20
The processing of personal
The processing of personal
The processing of personal
The processing of personal
data carried out within the
data carried out within the
data carried out within the
data carried out within the
framework of this
framework of this
framework of this
framework of this Directive
Directive shall be carried
Directive shall be carried
Directive shall be carried
shall be carried out in
out in compliance with
out in compliance with
out in compliance with
compliance with Directives
Directives 95/46/EC and
Directives 95/46/EC and
Directives 95/46/EC and
95/46/EC and 2002/58/EC.
2002/58/EC.
2002/58/EC.
2002/58/EC.
315.
Art. 21, title
Article 21
Article 21
Article 21
Article 21
Transposition
Transposition
Transposition
Transposition
316.
Art. 21, para
1.
Member States
1.
Member States
1.
Member States
1.
Member States shall
1
shall bring into force the
shall bring into force the
shall bring into force the
bring into force the laws,
laws, regulations and
laws, regulations and
laws, regulations and
regulations and
administrative provisions
administrative provisions
administrative provisions
administrative provisions
necessary to comply with
necessary to comply with
necessary to comply with
necessary to comply with
this Directive by [12
this Directive by [12
this Directive by [1224
this Directive by [[12][24]
months after entry into
months after entry into
months after entry into
months after entry into
force] at the latest. They
force] at the latest. They
force] at the latest. They
force] at the latest. They
shall forthwith
shall forthwith
shall forthwith
shall forthwith communicate
communicate to the
communicate to the
communicate to the
115

Location
COMMISSION
EP TEXT
COUNCIL TEXT
POSSIBLE
PROPOSAL
COMPROMISE
doc. 9134/18
COM(2016)593
SOLUTION
Commission the text of
Commission the text of
Commission the text of
to the Commission the text
those provisions.
those provisions.
those provisions.
of those provisions.
317.
Art. 21, para
When Member States
When Member States
When Member States
When Member States adopt
1, sub-
adopt those provisions,
adopt those provisions,
adopt those provisions,
those provisions, they shall
para 2
they shall contain a
they shall contain a
they shall contain a
contain a reference to this
reference to this Directive
reference to this Directive
reference to this Directive
Directive or be accompanied
or be accompanied by such
or be accompanied by such
or be accompanied by such
by such a reference on the
a reference on the occasion
a reference on the occasion
a reference on the occasion
occasion of their official
of their official
of their official
of their official
publication. Member States
publication. Member
publication. Member
publication. Member
shall determine how such
States shall determine how
States shall determine how
States shall determine how
reference is to be made.
such reference is to be
such reference is to be
such reference is to be
made.
made.
made.
318.
Art. 21, para
2.
Member States
2.
Member States
2.
Member States
2.
Member States shall
2
shall communicate to the
shall communicate to the
shall communicate to the
communicate to the
Commission the text of the
Commission the text of the
Commission the text of the
Commission the text of the
main provisions of national
main provisions of national
main provisions of national
main provisions of national
law which they adopt in
law which they adopt in
law which they adopt in
law which they adopt in the
the field covered by this
the field covered by this
the field covered by this
field covered by this
Directive.
Directive.
Directive.
Directive.
319.
Art. 22, title
Article 22
Article 22
Article 22
Article 22
Review
Review
Review
Review
320.
Art. 22, para
1.
No sooner than
1.
No sooner than
1.
No sooner than
1.
No sooner than [five
1
[five years after the date
[five years after the date
[five years after the date
years after the date
116

Location
COMMISSION
EP TEXT
COUNCIL TEXT
POSSIBLE
PROPOSAL
COMPROMISE
doc. 9134/18
COM(2016)593
SOLUTION
mentioned in Article
mentioned in Article
mentioned in Article
mentioned in Article 21(1)],
21(1)], the Commission
21(1)], the Commission
21(1)], the Commission
the Commission shall carry
shall carry out a review of
shall carry out a review of
shall carry out a review of
out a review of this Directive
this Directive and present a
this Directive and present a
this Directive and present a
and present a report on the
report on the main findings
report on the main findings
report on the main findings
main findings to the
to the European
to the European
to the European
European Parliament, the
Parliament, the Council
Parliament, the Council
Parliament, the Council
Council and the European
and the European
and the European
and the European
Economic and Social
Economic and Social
Economic and Social
Economic and Social
Committee.
Committee.
Committee.
Committee.
321.
Art. 22, para
2.
Member States
2.
Member States
2.
Member States
2.
Member States shall
2
shall provide the
shall provide the
shall provide the
provide the Commission
Commission with the
Commission with the
Commission with the
with the necessary
necessary information for
necessary information for
necessary information for
information for the
the preparation of the
the preparation of the
the preparation of the
preparation of the report
report referred to in
report referred to in
report referred to in
referred to in paragraph 1.
paragraph 1.
paragraph 1.
paragraph 1.
322.
Art. 23, title
Article 23
Article 23
Article 23
Article 23
Entry into force
Entry into force
Entry into force
Entry into force
323.
Art. 23
This Directive shall enter
This Directive shall enter
This Directive shall enter
This Directive shall enter
into force on the twentieth
into force on the twentieth
into force on the twentieth
into force on the twentieth
day following that of its
day following that of its
day following that of its
day following that of its
publication in the Official
publication in the Official
publication in the Official
publication in the Official
Journal of the European
Journal of the European
Journal of the European
Journal of the European
Union.
Union.
Union.
Union.
117

Location
COMMISSION
EP TEXT
COUNCIL TEXT
POSSIBLE
PROPOSAL
COMPROMISE
doc. 9134/18
COM(2016)593
SOLUTION
324.
Art. 24, title
Article 24
Article 24
Article 24
Article 24
Addressees
Addressees
Addressees
Addressees
325.
Art. 24
This Directive is addressed
This Directive is addressed
This Directive is addressed
This Directive is addressed
to the Member States.
to the Member States.
to the Member States.
to the Member States.
118