From:
(ENV)
Sent:
lundi 3 décembre 2018 16:35
To:
(ENV)
Subject:
FW: Final PWC Report on Tethered Caps / Art 6 SUP Directive
Attachments:
20181130 FINAL - Tethered Caps Report PWC.pdf; 20181130 Background
Note on Model Review - FINAL Tethered Caps Report PWC.pdf
Bonjour
,
pourrais-tu le classer en ares stp? Je te l'envoie à partir de ma réunion - pas de mail Ares ici. Désolé!
From: Hans van Bochove [xxxxxxxxxxx@xxxxxxx.xxx]
Sent: 02 December 2018 20:50
To: NELEN Sarah (ENV);
(ENV)
Cc:
@unesda.eu);
Subject: Final PWC Report on Tethered Caps / Art 6 SUP Directive
Dear Sarah and
,
Once again I would like to thank you for the conversation we had on November 23 around the tethered
cap requirement in the SUP Directive. As agreed, I am sharing with you the final report from PWC on the
economic and financial impact of the measure for the soft drinks and bottled water industry.
As we mentioned at the meeting, the results we shared were preliminary pending the final report from
PWC. Per their quality processes, PWC had their original findings reviewed by another team. This
brought to light an inconsistency in the datasets used to establish the number of production lines
impacted and the impact of ‘lost’ production per production line. As a result of cautionary using lower
line speed / capacity, the number of impacted production lines in the EU28 has gone down (from 1.350
to 1.030), as has the ‘lost’ value added per line. Attached you will also find an explanatory note that
addresses the difference in the preliminary and the final numbers. For your ease, I have inserted the
table below that shows the final results including the major differences from the preliminary numbers
we shared with you.
As you can see, the overall impact for the soft drinks and bottled water industry is still very significant.
As such, we ask the EU Institutions involved in the trilogue around the proposed SUP Directive to take
this impact into account when deciding on Article 6. Industry suggests to make Article 6 conditional to
Article 9 regarding the 90% collection target for plastic beverage containers and their caps and lids and
only require tethered caps should that target not be met. Should you need any clarification on the
attached report or its methodology, we can arrange an exchange with PWC at any time.
Many thanks for your consideration and kind regards,
Hans
Costs to Producers of
SCENARIO 1
SCENARIO 2
Implementing Art. 6, SUP Dir. # of impacted PET bottling lines
‘change caps only’
‘change caps and bottles’
across EU28 is c. 1.030
In Euros
In Euros
Supplier Capital Expenditure
438m
1,179bn
Bottler Material Costs
105m
388m
Bottler Capital Expenditure
680m
3,778bn
1,479bn
3,347bn
‘Lost’ Value Added
(was: 3,647bn)
(was: 8,272bn)
2,703bn
8,692bn
Total
(was: 4,890bn)
(was: 13,596bn)
Hans VAN BOCHOVE
Vice-President European Public Affairs
Coca-Cola European Partners
EU Transparency Register: 392447132015-41
E. xxxxxxxxxxx@xxxxxxx.xxx
Bergensesteenweg 1424 Chaussée de Mons
M.
1070 Brussels
T. +32 2 529 15 90
Belgium
www.ccep.com