29-07-19
Landfill Directive 1999/31 - Bad application cases opened (157)
Ref. Ares(2019)4960844 - 29/07/2019
YR/N°
Unit
MS Member state
Title
Incriminated fact
Last step
Date
days
Legal base
Stage
Key words
DOP
Last
Last Commission
reached in the
ago
Commission decision Decision label
procedure
decision
Date
1999/525 ENVI/A/02 ES Spain
WASTE - PROJET DE
Projet de centre de
Referral to Court ########
4769
31975L0442, Bad application - Directives ENV1 IMPACT
JMS
31-01-2008
Closing of the case
2
CONSTRUCTION D'UN
traitement de déchets, à
Art. 258 TFEU -
31980L0068,
CENTRE DE
San Roman de la Vega,
Decision
31991L0689,
TRAITEMENT DE
dans un endroit
31999L0031,
DECHETS A SAN ROMAN innaceptable du point de
32006L0012
DE LAVEGA
vue géologique et
géotechnique, contraireà
ce qui est prévu dans la
directive 80/68
2000/468 ENVI/A/02 ES Spain
WASTE - DECHARGE
Éxecution de l'arrêt de la
Reasoned
########
4503
197A228,319 Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
JMS
14-05-2009
Closing of the case
9
ILLEGALE - LA GOMERA
Cour du 28 avril 2005
opinion ex Art.
75L0442,319
(affaire C-157/04).
228 EC
76L0160,319
91L0689,319
99L0031,320
06L0012
2001/215 ENVI/A/02 ES Spain
WASTE - DÉCHETS
Non respect de la part des Formal notice
########
5754
31975L0442, Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
JMS
13-10-2004
Closing of the case
8
DANGEREUX -
autorités espagnoles des
Art. 258 TFEU
31991L0689,
DÉCHARGE À
directives 75/442/CEE
31999L0031,
L'ENTREPRISE DEL ZINC (déchets) 91/689/CEE
32000D0532
SA À CARTAGENA
(déchets dangereux)
80/68/CEE (protection des
eaux souterraines contre la
pollution causée par des
substances dangereuses
et 85/337/CEE (Impact) en
relation avec la présence
de produits cancérigènes
dans la décharge de
déchets industrielles de la
société Zinc S.A de
Cartagena, Murcia
2001/222 ENVI/A/02 ES Spain
WASTE - SERRA DE
Mauvaise application des
Formal notice
3-04-2003
5951
31975L0442, Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
FER
15-10-2003
Closing of the case
5
FONTCALENT (ALACANT, directives 75/442/CEE et
Art. 258 TFEU
31999L0031
ESPAGNE)
91/689/CEE en relation
avec la détérioration
environnementale dont
souffre la Serra de
Fontcalent (Alciante) en
raison de la présence de
décharges incontrôllés,
usines de sechage de
boues d'épuration et
plusieurs carrières, ainsi
que le déversement de
déchets dangereux.
Page 1 of 34
29-07-19
Landfill Directive 1999/31 - Bad application cases opened (157)
YR/N°
Unit
MS Member state
Title
Incriminated fact
Last step
Date
days
Legal base
Stage
Key words
DOP
Last
Last Commission
reached in the
ago
Commission decision Decision label
procedure
decision
Date
2001/226 ENVI/A/02 IT Italy
WASTE - POLLUTION
A landfill in Ca' di Capri
Referral to Court ########
5358
31975L0442, Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
ONI
3-05-2005
Withdrawal from the Court
8
FROM LANDFILL IN CA' DI (Verona), authorised for
258(ex226) -
31985L0337,
CAPRI (VERONE)
non hazardous waste, is
Application
31991L0156,
claimed to have received
31991L0689,
hazardous waste (EWC
31996L0059,
130108,
31999L0031
130203,130601,160601,13
0101,060403,060405) and
certain waste containing a
quantity of PCB exceeding
the limits set out in
Dir.96/59/EC (50ppm). The
above mentioned situation
is claimed to be the source
of water table and soil
pollution. This is claimed to
be contrary to Directives
75/442, as amended, and
91/689.
2001/226 ENVI/A/02 ES Spain
WASTE - DECHARGE DE Existence d'une décharge None
31975L0442, Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
JOR
30-03-2004
Closing of the case
9
MIRAMUNDO (CADIZ) - (
incontrôlée dans la localité
31999L0031
DIR.. 75/442/CE ET
de Miramundo, Jerez de la
99/31/CE )
Frontera, dans la province
de Cádiz, dans la
Communauté autonome
d'Andalousie (Espagne).
2001/445 ENVI/A/02 ES Spain
WASTE - DEPOT BOUES Mauvaise application des
None
31975L0442, Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
JMS
13-10-2004
Closing of the case
7
DRAGAGE PROJET
directives déchets en
31985L0337,
D'ELARGISSEMENT DU
relation avec le dépôt de
31991L0689,
PORT DE LA CORUNA
boues contaminées sur la
31999L0031
SUR LA PLAGE DE O
plage de O Lazareto, la
LAZARETO,
Coruña
2001/460 ENVI/A/02 ES Spain
WASTE -TRAITEMENT
Mauvaise application de la Formal notice
2-05-2003
5922
31999L0031
Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
FER
5-07-2005
Closing of the case
2
DE DECHETS A TOLEDO directive 99/31/CE en
Art. 258 TFEU
(CASTILLA LA MANCHA)
relation avec l'absence de
plan de conditionnement
pour la décharge de
Tolède et avec le non
respect des conditions
établies par la directive en
relation avec le projet
d'élargissement de cette
décharge.
2001/467 ENVI/A/02 ES Spain
WASTE - DECHARGE -
Mauvaise application de la None
31975L0442, Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
FER
26-06-2002
Closing of the case
9
MADRID
directive 75/442/CEE en
31991L0156,
relation avec la situaction
31999L0031
d'une décharge à proximité
d'une zone résidentielle.
Page 2 of 34
29-07-19
Landfill Directive 1999/31 - Bad application cases opened (157)
YR/N°
Unit
MS Member state
Title
Incriminated fact
Last step
Date
days
Legal base
Stage
Key words
DOP
Last
Last Commission
reached in the
ago
Commission decision Decision label
procedure
decision
Date
2001/479 ENVI/A/02 ES Spain
WASTE - MISE EN
Non transposition par
None
31999L0031
Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
JOR
20-03-2002
Cas traité sous
5
DECHARGE DE
l'Espagne de la directive
DECHETS
1999/31/CE du Conseil, du
26 avril 1999, concernant
la mise en décharge des
déchets.
2001/505 ENVI/A/02 IT Italy
WASTE - - LANDFILL IN
A landfill in a residential
None
31975L0442, Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
MAG
13-10-2004
Cas traité sous
1
PITELLI ( LA SPEZIA)
area (Pitelli - La Spezia),
31991L0689,
which is described as
31999L0031
having started in 1979 and
having granted the last
authorisation in 1995, is
claimed to be the source of
soil and water pollution
because of the lechate.
The situation is claimed to
be in contrast with
Directive75/442, on waste,
as amended by Dir.
91/156.
2001/508 ENVI/A/02 ES Spain
WASTE - ENLEVEMENT
Mauvaise application de la None
31999L0031
Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
FER
26-06-2002
Closing of the case
5
DES ORDURES
directive 75/442/CEE en
relation avec l'absence
d'enlèvement des ordures
dans un lotissement à
Valencia.
2001/509 ENVI/A/02 SE Sweden
WASTE - DIR 75/442 &
The complainant alleges
Formal notice
########
6056
31975L0442, Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
MAU
9-07-2003
Closing of the case
7
99/31, DEPOSITION OF
that illegal deposition of
Art. 258 TFEU
31999L0031
WASTE
waste takes place on his
property.
2001/513 ENVI/A/02 ES Spain
WASTE - DECHARGE
Mauvaise application des
None
31975L0442, Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
FER
9-07-2003
Closing of the case
9
D'ANDORRE
directives 75/442/CEE,
31985L0337,
99/31/CE et 85/337/CEE
31999L0031
en relation avec le projet
de construction d'une
dégarge à résidus inertes à
Noves de Segre (Lleida).
2001/529 ENVI/A/02 ES Spain
WASTE - MISE EN
Mauvaise application des
None
31975L0442, Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
FER
9-07-2003
Closing of the case
2
FONCTION D'UNE
directives 79/409/CEE,
31979L0409,
DECHARGE A
92/43/CEE, 75/442/CEE et
31992L0043,
TORREMENDO
99/31/CE de la part des
31999L0031
autorités espagnoles en
relation avec le projet de
construction d'une
décharge dans un
S.I.C./ZPS.
Page 3 of 34
29-07-19
Landfill Directive 1999/31 - Bad application cases opened (157)
YR/N°
Unit
MS Member state
Title
Incriminated fact
Last step
Date
days
Legal base
Stage
Key words
DOP
Last
Last Commission
reached in the
ago
Commission decision Decision label
procedure
decision
Date
2001/532 ENVI/A/02 IT Italy
WASTE - LANDFILL IN
It is claimed that the landfill None
31975L0442, Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
ONI
2-04-2003
Closing of the case
8
VENTOTENE
(no longer working) of
31991L0156,
waste coming from an
31999L0031
incinerator (which is also
no longer working) in
Ventotene (Latina) is now
an abandoned
contaminated site and that
it is the source of danger
for human health and of
pollution air water and soil.
This is claimed to be in
breach of Directive 75/442
on waste as amended.
2002/206 ENVI/A/02 ES Spain
WASTE - DECHARGE A
Incorrecte application des
None
31975L0442, Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
JMS
7-07-2004
Closing of the case
3
VILLANUEVA DEL
directives 75/442
31985L0337,
CARNERO, LEON,
(Déchets); 91/689 (Déchets
31996L0061,
ESPAGNE
dangereux) 96/61 (IPPC)
31999L0031
en relation avec une
décharge illégale à
Vllanueva del Carnero,
León, Espagne
2002/206 ENVI/A/02 ES Spain
WASTE - VERTEDERO
None
31975L0442, Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
LCO
16-10-2002
Cas traité sous
7
DE OZA (CORUNA)
31985L0337,
31991L0689,
31999L0031
2002/218 ENVI/A/02 ES Spain
WASTE - IMPACT,
Éxécution de l'arrêt de la
Referral to Court ########
4439
197A228,319 Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
JMS
29-10-2009
Closing of the case
0
DECHARGES ILLEGALES, Cour dans l'affaire C-
258(ex226) -
75L0442,319
EL EGIDO, LA
361/05 (décharges
Judgment
85L0337,319
MOJONERA ET NIJAR,
illégales de la province de
91L0689,319
ALMERIA
Almería, Espagne).
99L0031
Page 4 of 34
29-07-19
Landfill Directive 1999/31 - Bad application cases opened (157)
YR/N°
Unit
MS Member state
Title
Incriminated fact
Last step
Date
days
Legal base
Stage
Key words
DOP
Last
Last Commission
reached in the
ago
Commission decision Decision label
procedure
decision
Date
2002/224 ENVI/A/02 FR France
WASTE - DECHARGE
La plainte dénonce
None
31975L0442, Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
SER
7-07-2004
Closing of the case
2
SAUVAGE A SAINTE-
l'existence et le
31999L0031
ROSE (REUNION)
fonctionnement sans
autorisation d'une
décharge sauvage depuis
1977, dans la forêt
domaniale du « Grand
Brûlé » en bord de mer, sur
le terriroire de la commune
de Sainte-Rose à la
Réunion. Des déchets
ménagers, des déchets
verts, des pneus et
batteries usagés, des «
épaves » de véhicules, de
machines à laver et de
frigos seraient stockés en
plein air, ce qui entraînerait
la pollution du sol, de la
nappe phréatique, de l'air
et du milieu marin. La
décharge s'étalerait en
pente douce sur 800
mètres depuis la route
nationale, à 100 mètres
d'altitude, jusqu'à quelques
dizaines de mètres de
l'océan.
2002/225 ENVI/A/02 UK United
WASTE - LANDFILL AT
The emission of odours
None
31975L0442, Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
GRO
15-10-2003
Closing of the case
0
Kingdom
BROOMHOUSE
from Paterson of Greenoak
31991L0689,
landfill site alleged to be in
31999L0031
breach of harardous waste
licence conditions (1)
causing a nuisance under
Council Directive
74/442/EEC on waste, and
(2) in potential breach of
Council Directive
99/31/EEC requirements to
review the operation of
existing landfill sites.
Page 5 of 34
29-07-19
Landfill Directive 1999/31 - Bad application cases opened (157)
YR/N°
Unit
MS Member state
Title
Incriminated fact
Last step
Date
days
Legal base
Stage
Key words
DOP
Last
Last Commission
reached in the
ago
Commission decision Decision label
procedure
decision
Date
2002/230 ENVI/A/02 ES Spain
WASTE - DECHARGE
Possible mauvaise
None
31975L0442, Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
JOR
13-10-2004
Closing of the case
6
DES DECHETS DE
application des directives
31985L0337,
CHARBON A
75/442/CEE (déchets),
31999L0031
PONFERRADA (LEON)
91/689/CEE (déchets
dangereux), 1999/31/CE
(mise en décharge des
déchets) et 85/337/CEE
(impact) en relation avec
l'existence d'une décharge
des déchets de charbon
dans la ville de Ponferrada,
dans la province de León,
dans la Communauté
autonome de Castilla y
León, en Espagne.
2002/408 ENVI/A/02 ES Spain
WASTE - USINE DE
Mauvaise application des
Formal notice
1-04-2004
5587
31975L0442, Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
JMS
12-12-2006
Closing of the case
1
GENERATION
directives 75/442/CEE,
Art. 258 TFEU
31996L0061,
D'ELECTRICITE PAR
99/31/CE et 96/61/CE en
31999L0031,
THERMOLYSE
rélation avec une usine de
32006L0012
(INCINERATION) DES
génération d'électricité par
PNEUMATIQUES A
thermolyse (incinération)
ARDOCINO (CASTILLA Y des pneumatiques à
LEON).
Ardoncino (Castilla y
León).
2002/414 ENVI/A/02 BE Belgium
WASTE - DEVERSEMENT La plainte dénonce le
None
31975L0442, Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
GRA
13-10-2004
Closing of the case
3
DE DECHETS SUR UN
déversement de 170
31999L0031
TERRAIN PRIVE A
tonnes de déchets sur un
BRAINE LE COMTE
terrain privé à Braine le
Comte, en
méconnaissance des
dispositions de la directive
75/442/CEE et de la
directive 99/31/CE.
2002/417 ENVI/A/02 IE Ireland
NATURE - HABITATS
The complainant disagrees Additional formal 5-07-2005
5127
197A010,319 Bad application - Directives ENV7 NATURE
LCO
28-06-2006
Cas traité sous
4
WATERFORD
with Ireland's failure to
notice Art. 258
75L0442,319
include the River Lickey,
TFEU
85L0337,319
Co. Waterford as a
92L0043,319
propsed SAC. The
99L0031,320
complaint also notes that
06L0012
Waterford County Council
proposes to establish a
new landfill site adjacent to
the River Lickey.
Page 6 of 34
29-07-19
Landfill Directive 1999/31 - Bad application cases opened (157)
YR/N°
Unit
MS Member state
Title
Incriminated fact
Last step
Date
days
Legal base
Stage
Key words
DOP
Last
Last Commission
reached in the
ago
Commission decision Decision label
procedure
decision
Date
2002/423 ENVI/A/02 ES Spain
WASTE - MISE EN
Mauvaise application de la None
31975L0442, Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
FER
12-10-2005
Closing of the case
5
DECHARGE DES
directive 75/442/CEE en
31999L0031
DECHETS (GALICIA)
relation avec l'existence
d'une décharge illégale à
Celanova (Ourense).
2002/431 ENVI/A/02 IE Ireland
WASTE - BOTTLEHILL
Failure by the Irish
None
31975L0442, Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
LCO
18-11-2009
Cas traité sous
1
authorities to properly
31985L0337,
implement inter alia,
31999L0031
Dir.85/337/EEC, Directive
75/442/EEC Waste
Directive and also Directive
99/31/EEC. Complaint
made in the contenxt of a
proposed Local Authority
landfill facility at Bottlehill,
Co. Cork.
2002/436 ENVI/A/02 EL Greece
WASTE - DECHARGE
Fonctionnement d'une
None
31975L0442, Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
AMP
16-10-2002
Cas traité sous
4
INCONTROLEE
décharge illégale en
31991L0156,
violation des article 4, 8 et
31991L0689,
9 de la directive 75/442,
31999L0031
telle que modifiée par la
directive 91/156.
2002/440 ENVI/A/02 UK United
WASTE - HOUGTON LE Alleged illlegalities in the
None
31975L0442, Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
GRO
13-10-2004
Closing of the case
2
Kingdom
SPRING QUARRY
operation of a licensed
31997L0011,
LANDFILL SITE
sub water table landfill at
31999L0031
Houghton Le Spring
Quarry. Possible
infringements of Council
Directive 75/442/EEC on
waste as amended by
Directive 91/156/EEC,
Council Directive
99/13/EEC on the landfill of
waste and Council
Directive 80/68/EEC on
groundwater pollution.
Page 7 of 34
29-07-19
Landfill Directive 1999/31 - Bad application cases opened (157)
YR/N°
Unit
MS Member state
Title
Incriminated fact
Last step
Date
days
Legal base
Stage
Key words
DOP
Last
Last Commission
reached in the
ago
Commission decision Decision label
procedure
decision
Date
2002/444 ENVI/A/02 EL Greece
WASTE - DECHARGE
Operation of the temporary Referral to Court ########
4893
31975L0442, Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
AMP
18-09-2008
Withdrawal from the Court
9
ILLEGALE A
installation for
258(ex226) -
31991L0156,
MESSOMOURI
compression, baling and
Application
31999L0031,
storage of waste situated in
32006L0012
Messomouri and non-
rehabilitation of the old
Kouroupitos dump: failure
to comply with Directive
75/442/EEC, as amended
by Directive 91/156/EEC
(Art.4 et 8) and Directive
99/31/EC (Art.14, point b).
2002/454 ENVI/A/02 DE Germany
IMPACT - FILLING OF
Permit concerning the
None
31985L0337, Bad application - Directives ENV1 IMPACT
DOP
16-03-2005
Closing of the case
8
EMS SEDIMENTS
depositing of mud of the
31997L0011,
(NIEDERSACHSEN)
River Ems on an area
31999L0031
close to the town Ihrhove in
Lower Saxony claimed to
have been issued without
prior environmental impact
assessment (EIA).
2002/458 ENVI/A/02 IE Ireland
WASTE - BALLYGUYROE Nuisances caused by
None
31999L0031
Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
LCO
30-03-2004
Closing of the case
2
NORTH, MALLOW, CO.
existing municipal landfill
CORK
(Cork County Council) at
Ballyguyroe North, Mallow,
Co. Cork. 35 acre landfill in
operation for several years.
Proposal by Celtic Waste
to develop a further 70
acres.
2002/486 ENVI/A/02 ES Spain
WASTE - COMBUSTION
Mauvaise application des
None
31975L0442, Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
FER
12-10-2005
Closing of the case
3
DE DECHETS DANS LA
directives 75/442/CEE et
31999L0031
DECHARGE DE YAIZA (
99/31/CE en relation avec
LANZAROTE)
la combustion de déchets
dans la décharge de Yaïza
(Lanzarote).
2002/491 ENVI/A/02 EL Greece
WASTE - COMBUSTION
Elimination sauvage des
None
31975L0442, Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
AMP
15-10-2003
Cas traité sous
7
DES DECHETS NAXOS
déchets sur l'île de Naxos
31991L0156,
en violation des article 4, 8
31999L0031
et 9 de la directive
75/442/CEE, telle que
modifiée par la directive
91/156/CEE.
Page 8 of 34
29-07-19
Landfill Directive 1999/31 - Bad application cases opened (157)
YR/N°
Unit
MS Member state
Title
Incriminated fact
Last step
Date
days
Legal base
Stage
Key words
DOP
Last
Last Commission
reached in the
ago
Commission decision Decision label
procedure
decision
Date
2002/495 ENVI/A/02 ES Spain
WASTE - DEPOT
Mauvaise application des
None
31975L0442, Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
FER
9-07-2003
Closing of the case
3
SAUVAGE DE DETRITUS directives 75/442/CEE et
31999L0031
GALAPAGAR (MADRID)
99/31/CE en relation avec
l'accumulation de déchets
dans la commune de
Galapagar (Madrid).
2002/497 ENVI/A/02 FR France
WASTE - BRULAGES
La plainte dénonce des
None
31975L0442, Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
SER
30-03-2004
Closing of the case
4
SAUVAGES DE DECHETS brûlages sauvages de
31999L0031
INDUSTRIELS, FRANCHE- déchets industriels dans
COMTE
une cinquantaine de zones
industrielles en Franche-
Comté.
2002/507 ENVI/A/02 IT Italy
WASTE - LANDFILL IN
A project to locate a landfill None
31985L0337, Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
ONI
2-04-2003
Closing of the case
3
TROFARELLO
in an area claimed to be
31999L0031
subject to hydrological risk
is considered to represent
a breach of Directive
99/31/EC on the landfill of
waste
Page 9 of 34
29-07-19
Landfill Directive 1999/31 - Bad application cases opened (157)
YR/N°
Unit
MS Member state
Title
Incriminated fact
Last step
Date
days
Legal base
Stage
Key words
DOP
Last
Last Commission
reached in the
ago
Commission decision Decision label
procedure
decision
Date
2002/511 ENVI/A/02 FR France
WASTE - DECHARGE A
La plainte dénonce le
None
31975L0442, Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
SER
30-03-2004
Closing of the case
6
MONCORNEIL - GRAZAN fonctionnement du centre
31985L0337,
d'enfouissement technique
31999L0031
Moncorneil-Grazan et son
projet d'extension sur le
territoire de la commune de
Moncorneil-Grazan, dans
le département du Gers.
Le plaignant dénonce le
non-respect des
prescriptions de l'arrêté
d'autorisation de la
décharge (notamment
absence d'analyse des
eaux, risque de pollution
par les lixiviats, non-
respect de la capacité
autorisée de la décharge,
absence de recouvrement
journalier réglementaire,
absence de contrôle de
pesée à l'entrée de la
décharge, absence de
clôture mobile
réglementaire et de
compacteur, existence
d'odeurs nauséabondes).
Par ailleurs, le plaignant
dénonce le projet
d'extension de la décharge:
insuffisance de l'étude
d'impact environnemental
du projet, notamment
absence de prise en
compte d'un site proposé
Natura 2000 ("Vallée et
côteaux de la lauze") qui
se situerait à 500 m de la
décharge.
2002/519 ENVI/A/02 IT Italy
WASTE - MALAGROTTA
Failure to comply with
Referral to Court 7-07-2004
5490
31999L0031
Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
ONI
5-07-2005
Closing of the case
2
LANDFILL IN ROME
Article 14(1, letters a and
Art. 258 TFEU -
b) of Directive 1999/31/EC Decision
on the landfill of waste, by
not having elaborated a
conditioning plan for the
landfill of Malagrotta
(Rome)
2002/521 ENVI/D/03 IE Ireland
WASTE - TYNAGH MINES - Pollution risks at the former Reasoned
########
5330
31975L0442, Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
LCO
13-12-2005
Cas traité sous
9
GALWAY 1
Tynagh Mines in County
opinion Art. 258
31991L0689,
Galway
TFEU
31996L0061,
31999L0031
Page 10 of 34
29-07-19
Landfill Directive 1999/31 - Bad application cases opened (157)
YR/N°
Unit
MS Member state
Title
Incriminated fact
Last step
Date
days
Legal base
Stage
Key words
DOP
Last
Last Commission
reached in the
ago
Commission decision Decision label
procedure
decision
Date
2002/534 ENVI/A/02 BE Belgium
WASTE - DECHARGE AU Le plaignant dénonce
Reasoned
5-07-2005
5127
31975L0442, Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
CLM
5-06-2008
Closing of the case
9
LIEU DIT D'HOPPE
l'exploitation d'un décharge opinion Art. 258
31976L0464,
(FLOBECQ)
situé dans la commune de TFEU
31980L0068,
Flobecq près de sites du
31992L0043,
"Bois du Pottelberg" et du
31999L0031,
"Brakelbos", tous les deux
32006L0012
des sites proposée
d'importance
communautaire (pSIC) en
vertu de la directive
92/43/CEE.
2002/537 ENVI/A/02 ES Spain
WATER -
According to the
None
31975L0442, Bad application - Directives ENV10 WATER
JMS
30-03-2004
Closing of the case
4
CONSERVATION DES
complainant the
31976L0464,
FLEUVES A NAVARRA
construction of pluvial
31985L0337,
parks may have negative
31991L0271,
effects on the water quality
31999L0031
of the river. The
complainant also refers to
episodes of industrial
pollution. The size of the
proposed project my have
negtive effects on nature
conservation values.
2002/542 ENVI/A/02 NL Netherlands
IMPACT - RIVER
Complainant alleges that in None
31985L0337, Bad application - Directives ENV1 IMPACT
EBE
30-03-2004
Closing of the case
0
WIDENING WORKS -
relation to plans for
31999L0031
MAASWERKEN
riverworks in Limburg
(Grensmaas)
environmental Community
law has not been
respected.
2003/202 ENVI/A/02 ES Spain
IMPACT - MINE DE
Mauvaise application des
None
31985L0337, Bad application - Directives ENV1 IMPACT
FER
15-10-2003
Closing of the case
6
NICKEL A CIEL OUVERT
directives 85/337/CEE et
31999L0031
(BADAJOZ)
99/31 en relation avec le
projet d'exploitation d'une
mine de nickel à ciel ouvert
dans la commune de
Monesterio (Estrémadure).
2003/203 ENVI/A/01 FR France
WASTE - DECHARGES
Violation des articles 4, 8
Formal notice
8-05-2008
4089
197A228,319 Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
CLM
21-06-2012
Closing of the case
0
ILLEGALES EN FRANCE
et 9 de la directive
Art. 260 TFEU
75L0442,319
75/442/CEE relative aux
99L0031
déchets, telle que modifiée
par la directive 91/156/CEE
et de l'article 14, a) de la
directive 99/31/CE, en
raison du fonctionnement
en France d'un très grand
nombre de décharges
illégales.
Page 11 of 34
29-07-19
Landfill Directive 1999/31 - Bad application cases opened (157)
YR/N°
Unit
MS Member state
Title
Incriminated fact
Last step
Date
days
Legal base
Stage
Key words
DOP
Last
Last Commission
reached in the
ago
Commission decision Decision label
procedure
decision
Date
2003/206 ENVI/A/02 IT Italy
WASTE - ILLEGAL
Several illegal landfills are None
31975L0442, Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
MAG
9-07-2003
Cas traité sous
0
LANDFILLS IN SICILY
claimed to have been
31999L0031
discovered in Sicily,
creating environmental
hazard and danger for
human health of the nearby
population
2003/207 ENVI/E/02 IT Italy
WASTE - ILLEGAL
Violation des articles 4, 8
Referral to Court 2-12-2014
1690
12008E260§2 Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
TIC
24-10-2012
Referral to Court Art. 260
7
LANDFILLS IN ITALY
et 9 de la directive
260(ex228) -
,197A228,319
TFEU
75/442/CEE relative aux
Judgment
75L0442,319
déchets, telle que modifiée
91L0689,319
par la directive 91/156/CEE
99L0031
et de l'article 14, a) de la
directive 99/31/CE, en
raison du fonctionnement
en Italie d'un très grand
nombre de décharges
illégales.
2003/218 ENVI/E/03 EL Greece
WASTE - PLANIFICATION Non-exécution de l'arrêt du Referral to Court 7-09-2016
1045
12008E260§2 Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
CNN
25-09-2014
Referral to Court Art. 260
7
ET GESTION DES
10.09.2009 (C-286/08).
260(ex228) -
,31975L0442,
TFEU
DECHETS DANGEREUX
Violation de l'article 4, 5§§1-Judgment
31991L0689,
2, 7§1 et 8 de la directive
31999L0031,
2006/12/CE, des articles
32006L0012,
1§2 et 6§1 de la directive
32008L0098
91/689/CEE relative aux
déchets dangereux, ainsi
que les art.3§1, 6-9, 13 et
14 de la directive 99/31/CE
sur la mise en décharge à
cause de: - l'absence de
planification adéquate pour
la gestion des déchets
dangereux - l'absence d'un
réseau intégré et adéquat
d'installations d'élimination
des déchets dangereux - la
non adoption de toutes les
mesures afin d'assurer une
gestion des dechets
conforme a la legislation
UE
Page 12 of 34
29-07-19
Landfill Directive 1999/31 - Bad application cases opened (157)
YR/N°
Unit
MS Member state
Title
Incriminated fact
Last step
Date
days
Legal base
Stage
Key words
DOP
Last
Last Commission
reached in the
ago
Commission decision Decision label
procedure
decision
Date
2003/222 ENVI/A/02 ES Spain
WASTE - PROJET
éventuelle mauvaise
None
31985L0337, Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
FER
14-12-2004
Closing of the case
7
DECHARGE ET USINE
application des directives
31999L0031
COMPOSTAGE, BASSIN
85/337/CEE, modifiée par
DE BARBERA
la directive 97/11/CE, et
(TARRAGONE)
99/31/CE en relation avec
un projet de construction
d'une décharge et d'une
usine de compostage à
l'Esplugue du Francoli
(Conque du Barbera,
Catalogne - Espagne).
2003/408 ENVI/A/02 PT Portugal
WASTE -
Mauvais fonctionnement
Reasoned
########
4769
31975L0442, Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
SOA
18-09-2008
Closing of the case
0
FONCTIONNEMENT
de la décharge pour des
opinion Art. 258
31999L0031,
DECHARGE DE OESTE
déchets urbains de la
TFEU
32006L0012
Région Ouest.
2003/417 ENVI/A/02 EL Greece
WASTE -
Conditions de
None
31975L0442, Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
AMP
4-04-2006
Cas traité sous
1
FONCTIONNEMENT
fonctionnement du site de
31991L0156,
DECHARGE ANO LIOSIA
mise en décharge d'Ano
31991L0689,
Liosia en violation de la
31999L0031
directive 75/442/CEE
relative aux déchets, telle
que modifiée par la
directive 91/156/CEE
(articles 4 et 9).
2003/418 ENVI/A/02 FR France
WASTE - DECHARGE
La plainte dénonce les
None
31975L0442, Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
GRA
4-04-2006
Closing of the case
9
CHAMPIGNY-SUR-YONNE risques pour
31999L0031
l'environnement et la santé
publique, s'agissant de
l'exploitation d'une
décharge près d'une
clinique psychiatrique, sur
le territoire de la commune
de Champigny-sur-Yonne,
dans le département de
l'Yonne.
2003/423 ENVI/A/02 ES Spain
WASTE - PROJET
Construction du centre
None
31985L0337, Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
JMS
13-10-2004
Cas traité sous
5
CENTRE TRAITEMENT
traitement déchets sur le
31997L0011,
DECHETS SUR
site de la décharge illégale
31999L0031
DECHARGE ILLEGALE,
de La Bañeza, sans
LA BANEZA - LEON
scellement préalable de
celle-ci.
2003/424 ENVI/A/02 NL Netherlands
WASTE - RIVER WORKS - The complainant alleges
None
31985L0337, Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
EBE
30-03-2004
Closing of the case
8
MAASWERKEN II
that the EU-rules on EIA
31999L0031
have not been respected in
relation to plans for
riverworks in Limburg
(Grensmaas), whereby
contaminated soil will be
stored in certain areas
Page 13 of 34
29-07-19
Landfill Directive 1999/31 - Bad application cases opened (157)
YR/N°
Unit
MS Member state
Title
Incriminated fact
Last step
Date
days
Legal base
Stage
Key words
DOP
Last
Last Commission
reached in the
ago
Commission decision Decision label
procedure
decision
Date
2003/426 ENVI/A/02 BE Belgium
WASTE - EXTENSION
La plainte dénonce
None
31975L0442, Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
GRA
13-10-2004
Closing of the case
4
D'UNE DECHARGE
l'exploitation et l'extension
31992L0043,
de la décharge de
31999L0031
Tenneville dans la région
Wallonne en
méconnaissance de
certaines dispositions des
directives 94/43, 75/442,
99/31.
2003/440 ENVI/D/03 IE Ireland
WASTE - REMISE EN
Problems with regard to
None
31999L0031
Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
LCO
18-11-2009
Cas traité sous
8
SERVICE D'UNE
the former main landfill for
DECHARGE
Dublin situated at Dunsink
2003/449 ENVI/A/02 ES Spain
WASTE - DECHARGE
Mauvaise application des
None
31975L0442, Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
JMS
12-10-2005
Closing of the case
6
ILLEGALE A ARUZA
directives déchets et eau
31980L0068,
(CORUNA)
en relation avec l'existence
31991L0689,
d'une décharge incontrôlée
31999L0031
et illégale dans la
municipalité de Arzúa,
dans la province de A
Coruña, Galicia.
2003/452 ENVI/A/02 FR France
WASTE - TRAVAUX DE
Le plaignant dénonce des None
31975L0442, Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
SER
12-10-2005
Closing of the case
2
REMBLAIEMENT AVEC
travaux de remblaiement
31999L0031,
DES DECHETS INERTES avec des déchets inertes
32003D0033
A RIBOUX ET CUGES LES sur le territoire des
PINS
communes de Riboux (Var)
et de Cuges les Pins
(Bouches du Rhône) dans
le Massif de la Sainte
Baume.
2003/455 ENVI/A/01 IT Italy
WASTE - LANDFILLS IN
It is claimed that a landfill
None
31975L0442, Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
TBL
27-09-2012
Closing of the case
0
CASTEL FIRMIANO
site in Castel Firmiano
31999L0031
(BOLZANO)
(Bolzano), where waste
have been disposed of in
an uncontrolled way for
many years, is the cause of
serious water and soil
pollution. The site is
located near to wineyards.
Page 14 of 34
29-07-19
Landfill Directive 1999/31 - Bad application cases opened (157)
YR/N°
Unit
MS Member state
Title
Incriminated fact
Last step
Date
days
Legal base
Stage
Key words
DOP
Last
Last Commission
reached in the
ago
Commission decision Decision label
procedure
decision
Date
2003/460 ENVI/A/02 ES Spain
WASTE - DECHARGE
éventuelle mauvaise
None
31975L0442, Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
FER
13-12-2005
Closing of the case
8
INCONTROLEE (MELILLA) application des directives
31985L0337,
75/442/CEE, 99/31/CE et
31999L0031
85/337/CEE, modifiée par
la directive 97/11/CE, en
relation avec une décharge
incontrôlée et le projet
d'une nouvelle décharge et
centre de compostage
ainsi que d'amélioration du
front littoral et construction
de plages dans la Ville
autonome de Mélille,
Espagne.
2003/480 ENVI/A/02 ES Spain
WASTE - DECHARGE DE Éventuelle mauvaise
None
31999L0031
Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
FER
16-03-2005
Closing of the case
3
MONTICANO (LA
application de la directive
COROGNE)
99/31/CE en relation avec
la décharge de Monticaño
(La Corogne).
2003/483 ENVI/A/02 ES Spain
WASTE - DECHARGE DE Éventuelle mauvaise
None
31975L0442, Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
FER
12-10-2005
Closing of the case
2
VALDESENOR
application des directives
31999L0031
(PALENCE)
75/442 et 99/31 en relation
avec la décharge de
Valdeseigneur (Palence).
2003/498 ENVI/A/02 IT Italy
WASTE - ILLEGAL
An illegal landfill site is
None
31975L0442, Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
RM
14-04-2009
Closing of the case
3
LANDFILL IN MUGGIA
claimed to be the cause of
31999L0031
(TRIESTE)
serious environmental
contamination in Muggia
(Trieste) and to represent a
hazard to the environment
and human health of the
nearby population
2003/506 ENVI/A/02 ES Spain
WASTE - DECHARGE
Mauvaise application des
None
31975L0442, Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
VRY
27-06-2007
Closing of the case
4
ILLEGALE A CONGOSTO directives déchets et eau
31991L0689,
(LEON)
en relation avec l'existence
31999L0031,
d'une décharge incontrôlée
32006L0012
et illégale dans la
municipalité de Congosto,
dans la province de León,
dans la Communauté
autonome de Castilla et
León, en Espagne.
Page 15 of 34
29-07-19
Landfill Directive 1999/31 - Bad application cases opened (157)
YR/N°
Unit
MS Member state
Title
Incriminated fact
Last step
Date
days
Legal base
Stage
Key words
DOP
Last
Last Commission
reached in the
ago
Commission decision Decision label
procedure
decision
Date
2003/506 ENVI/A/02 FR France
WASTE - CENTRES DE
La plainte dénonce le
Formal notice
########
4501
31975L0442, Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
CLM
28-02-2008
Cas traité sous
8
STOCKAGE DE DECHETS fonctionnement, d’une part, Art. 258 TFEU
31999L0031,
AMIANTE ET DE
d’un centre de stockage de
32003D0033,
DECHETS ULTIMES A
déchets d’amiante ciment,
32006L0012
EROUDEVILLE
autorisé par arrêté
préfectoral en septembre
1997, sur le territoire de la
commune d’Eroudeville, et,
d’autre part, d’un centre de
stockage de déchets
ultimes d’une capacité
annuelle de 125.000
tonnes, autorisé par arrêté
préfectoral du 6 juin 2003,
sur le territoire des
communes d’Eroudeville et
de Le Ham, dans le
département de la Manche.
2003/513 ENVI/A/02 DE Germany
WASTE - DIEPENSEE IN
Possible infringement of
None
31975L0442, Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
HAL
4-04-2006
Closing of the case
1
BERLIN
Directives 75/442 5Waste
31999L0031
Framework), 99/31
(Landfill) and 2000/60
(Water Framework)
through contaminated soil
site at the former waste
water installation at
Diepensee/Berlin
2003/513 ENVI/A/02 EL Greece
IMPACT - PROJET
Projet de construction d'un None
31975L0442, Bad application - Directives ENV1 IMPACT
AMP
12-10-2005
Closing of the case
7
CONSTRUCTION SITE
site de mise en décharge à
31985L0337,
MISE EN DECHARGE A
Agios Thomas
31999L0031
AGIOS THOMAS
(département de
(MESSOLONGI)
Messolongi) en violation de
la directive 99/31/CE et de
la directive 85/337/CEE,
telle que modifiée par la
directive 97/11/CE.
2003/524 ENVI/A/02 FR France
WASTE - DECHARGE
Le plaignant dénonce
None
31975L0442, Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
SER
13-10-2004
Cas traité sous
4
ILLEGALE A CARGESE -
l'existence d'une décharge
31999L0031
CORSE DU SUD
illégale à Cargèse, en
Corse.
Page 16 of 34
29-07-19
Landfill Directive 1999/31 - Bad application cases opened (157)
YR/N°
Unit
MS Member state
Title
Incriminated fact
Last step
Date
days
Legal base
Stage
Key words
DOP
Last
Last Commission
reached in the
ago
Commission decision Decision label
procedure
decision
Date
2004/205 ENVI/A/02 ES Spain
WASTE - DECHARGE
Mauvaise application des None
31975L0442, Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
JOR
4-04-2006
Closing of the case
7
INCONTROLEE A
directives communautaires
31991L0689,
VITIGUDINO
en matière de déchets en
31999L0031
(SALAMANCA)
relation avec le
fonctionnement de la
décharge de Vitigudino,
dans la province de
Salamanca, dans la
Communauté autonome de
Castilla y León, en
Espagne.
2004/409 ENVI/A/02 BE Belgium
WASTE - LANDFILL -
The complainant alleges
None
31975L0442, Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
EBE
13-10-2004
Closing of the case
8
LENDELEDE
that a landfill in Lendelede
31999L0031
(Flanders) provokes
permanent nuisances to
the inhabitants, such as
dust, smell, noise and
visual nuisance. The
complainant claims this
goes against Dir 75/442.
2004/423 ENVI/A/02 UK United
NATURE - AUCHENINNES Failure to correctly apply
None
31985L0337, Bad application - Directives ENV7 NATURE
GRO
16-03-2005
Closing of the case
8
Kingdom
MOSS DESIGNATION -
Council Directive
31992L0043,
DIR 92/43
92/43/EEC on the
31997L0011,
conservation of natural
31999L0031
habitats and wild fauna and
flora, Council Directive
85/337/EEC on the
assessment of of the
effects of certian public and
private projects on the
environment as amended
by Directive 97/11/EC and
Council Directive
1999/31/EC on the landfill
of waste
2004/428 ENVI/A/02 ES Spain
WASTE - DECHARGE
Éventuelle mauvaise
None
31975L0442, Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
JMS
4-04-2006
Closing of the case
9
ILLEGALE DANS LA
application des directive
31999L0031
PROVINCE D'ALMERIA
75/442 et 99/31 en relation
(ANDALOUSIE)
avec une décharge illégale
dans la province d'Almérie.
Page 17 of 34
29-07-19
Landfill Directive 1999/31 - Bad application cases opened (157)
YR/N°
Unit
MS Member state
Title
Incriminated fact
Last step
Date
days
Legal base
Stage
Key words
DOP
Last
Last Commission
reached in the
ago
Commission decision Decision label
procedure
decision
Date
2004/449 ENVI/A/02 FR France
WASTE - DEPOT
L’attention de la
None
31975L0442, Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
GRA
28-06-2006
Closing of the case
8
SOUTERRAIN DE
Commission a été attirée
31980L0068,
DECHETS DANGEREUX A par un député européen
31991L0689,
WITTELSHEIM
sur les risques pour
31999L0031,
l’environnement, s’agissant
32006L0012
de l’existence d’un dépôt
souterrain de 45.000
tonnes de déchets
dangereux, lié aux activités
de l’entreprise Stocamine,
sur le territoire de la
commune de Wittelsheim,
en Alsace.
2004/450 ENVI/A/02 FR France
WASTE - DECHARGE A
La plainte dénonce les
None
31975L0442, Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
SER
12-10-2005
Closing of the case
7
AUTUN EN SAONE ET
risques pour
31999L0031
LOIRE
l’environnement, s’agissant
du fonctionnement d’un
centre d’enfouissement
technique (« CET ») situé
sur le territoire de la
commune d’Autun, dans le
département de Saône-et-
Loire.
2004/454 ENVI/A/02 IE Ireland
WASTE - DREHID
Alleged non-compliance
None
31985L0337, Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
LCO
12-10-2005
Closing of the case
2
with EU impact
31999L0031
assessment and waste
rules in relation to a
proposed landfill at Drehid,
County Kildare
2004/464 ENVI/A/02 ES Spain
WASTE - DÉCHARGE
Possible mauvaise
None
31975L0442, Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
JMS
12-10-2006
Closing of the case
4
ILLÉGALE À NOHALES
application de la directive
31999L0031,
(CUENCA)
75/442/CEE du Conseil, du
32006L0012
15 juillet 1975, relative aux
déchets, modifiée par la
directive 91/156/CEE du
Conseil, du 18 mars 1991,
en relation avec une
décharge illégale et
incontrôlée dans la
municipalité de Nohales,
dans la province de
Cuenca, dans la
Communauté autonome de
Castilla-La Mancha, en
Espagne.
Page 18 of 34
29-07-19
Landfill Directive 1999/31 - Bad application cases opened (157)
YR/N°
Unit
MS Member state
Title
Incriminated fact
Last step
Date
days
Legal base
Stage
Key words
DOP
Last
Last Commission
reached in the
ago
Commission decision Decision label
procedure
decision
Date
2004/466 ENVI/A/02 ES Spain
WASTE - DECHARGE
Autorisation pour la mise
None
31999L0031
Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
JMS
4-04-2006
Closing of the case
1
VACAMORTA GIRONA.
en décharge des déchets à
Cruïlles (Catalogne) non
conforme aux exigences
techniques de la Directive
1999/31/CE.
2004/468 ENVI/A/02 ES Spain
WASTE - DECHARGE
Autorisation pour la mise
None
31999L0031
Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
JMS
12-10-2005
Cas traité sous
3
VACAMORTA GIRONA.
en décharge des déchets à
Cruïlles (Catalogne) non
conforme aux exigences
techniques de la Directive
1999/31/CE.
2004/471 ENVI/A/02 UK United
WASTE - NON RESPECT Failure to correctly apply
None
31999L0031
Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
GRO
12-10-2005
Closing of the case
2
Kingdom
DIR 1999/31 - MISE EN
the requirements of
DECHARGE DES
Council Directive
DECHETS
1999/31/EC of 26 April
1999 on the landfill of
waste
2004/481 ENVI/A/02 BE Belgium
WASTE - DIR 75/442 ET
Le plaignant dénonce la
None
31975L0442, Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
MEL
12-10-2005
Closing of the case
8
1999/31 - GESTION DES
violation des articles 3, 4, 5
31999L0031
DECHETS
et 7 de la directive
75/442/CEE et de l'article 8
de la directive 1999/31/CE
2004/488 ENVI/A/02 IE Ireland
WASTE - INAGH
Failure to comply with
None
31985L0337, Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
LCO
12-10-2006
Closing of the case
2
conditions on
31997L0011,
biodegradable waste and
31999L0031
screening in relation to a
new landfill situated at
Inagh, County Clare
2004/488 ENVI/A/02 MT Malta
WASTE - MAGHTAB
Failure to comply with
None
31975L0442, Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
CLM
27-11-2008
Closing of the case
8
LANDFILL
Directive 75/442/EEC on
31999L0031,
waste in the operation of a
32006L0012
landfill site at Maghtab,
Malta
2004/492 ENVI/A/02 MT Malta
WASTE - MAGHTAB
Failure to comply with
None
31975L0442, Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
WGR
12-10-2005
Cas traité sous
0
LANDFILL 2
Directive 75/442/EEC on
31999L0031
waste in the operation of a
landfill site at Maghtab,
Malta
2004/505 ENVI/A/02 EL Greece
IMPACT -
Projet de construction d'un None
31985L0337, Bad application - Directives ENV1 IMPACT
AMP
16-03-2005
Closing of the case
8
CONSTRUCTION D'UNE
site de mise en décharge à
31999L0031
DECHARGE A
"Mavro Vouno"
GRAMMATIKO (MAVRO
Grammatikou
VOUNO)
(département d'Attiki) en
violation de la directive
99/31/CE et de la directive
85/337/CEE, telle que
modifiée par la directive
97/11/CE.
Page 19 of 34
29-07-19
Landfill Directive 1999/31 - Bad application cases opened (157)
YR/N°
Unit
MS Member state
Title
Incriminated fact
Last step
Date
days
Legal base
Stage
Key words
DOP
Last
Last Commission
reached in the
ago
Commission decision Decision label
procedure
decision
Date
2004/510 ENVI/A/02 PL Poland
WASTE - NATURE -
Non-compliance by Polish None
31975L0442, Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
EBE
12-10-2006
Closing of the case
3
LANDFILL IN MAZANY
authorities with Community
31979L0409,
legislation in relation to
31985L0337,
operation of landfill
31999L0031,
(Directives: 85/337/EEC as
32006L0012
amended by Directive
97/11/EC, 75/442/EEC,
1999/31/EC) and nature
conservation (Directive
79/409/EEC)
2004/513 ENVI/A/02 FR France
WASTE -
La plainte dénonce des
None
31975L0442, Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
GRA
4-04-2006
Closing of the case
6
REMBLAIEMENT D'UNE
travaux de drainage et de
31999L0031
ZONE HUMIDE A
remblaiement d'une zone
KEROUAT, FINISTERE -
humide, au lieu dit Kerouat
NATURE DES DECHETS
sur le territoire de la
UTILISES
commune de Trégunc,
dans le département du
Finistère, avec des déchets
de bâtiments tels que des
plaques de ciment, de
placoplatre, de mâchefers
et d'amiante-ciment, entre
mai 2003 et mai 2004.
2004/514 ENVI/A/02 UK United
WASTE - DUMPING IN
Failure to correctly apply
None
31975L0442, Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
GRO
4-04-2006
Cas traité sous
1
Kingdom
PORT OF TYNE
Council Directive
31999L0031
85/337/EEC on the
assessment of the effects
of certain public and pivate
projects on the
environment as amended
by Directive 97/11/EC
2004/516 ENVI/A/02 MT Malta
WASTE - ST ANTNIN
Failure to comply with
None
31975L0442, Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
WGR
11-12-2007
Closing of the case
0
RECYCLING PLANT
Directive 75/442/EEC on
31997L0011,
the disposal of waste and
31999L0031,
the EIA Directive 97/11/EC
32006L0012
regarding the disposal of
waste and the proposal to
redevelop a waste disposal
plant in Sant Antnin, Malta
Page 20 of 34
29-07-19
Landfill Directive 1999/31 - Bad application cases opened (157)
YR/N°
Unit
MS Member state
Title
Incriminated fact
Last step
Date
days
Legal base
Stage
Key words
DOP
Last
Last Commission
reached in the
ago
Commission decision Decision label
procedure
decision
Date
2005/211 ENVI/A/02 FR France
WASTE - DECHARGE
Le cas décelé d'office
Additional formal ########
3928
31975L0442, Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
GRM
25-06-2009
Closing of the case
5
D'ENTRESSEN
dénonce les conditions de notice Art. 258
31999L0031,
fonctionnement de la
TFEU
32006L0012
décharge d’Entressen dans
les Bouches-du-Rhône qui
reçoit les déchets de la
Ville de Marseille et des
huit autres communes de
la communauté urbaine
(Carry le Rouet, Ensuès-La
–Redonne, Gignac,
Marignane, Saint-Victoret
et Sausset-Les-Pins), soit
environ 1.300 tonnes par
jour. Il s’agit de la
décharge à ciel ouvert la
plus grande d’Europe (130
ha), dont un tumulus sur
une superficie de 45 ha et
une hauteur de 30 mètres.
Règulièrement, les filets de
protection de la décharge
cèdent et les déchets
plastiques jonchent les
alentours sous l’effet du
vent.
2005/213 ENVI/A/02 ES Spain
WASTE - WASTE
Potentielle pollution d'un
None
31975L0442, Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
JMS
4-04-2006
Closing of the case
1
DISPOSAL SITE AT
aquifère a cause de
31980L0068,
TIVISSA
plusieurs déficiences
31985L0337,
structurelles de
31999L0031
construction d'une
décharge à Tivissa
(province de Tarragona).
2005/407 ENVI/A/02 EL Greece
IMPACT -
Projet de construction d'un None
31985L0337, Bad application - Directives ENV1 IMPACT
AMP
4-04-2006
Closing of the case
9
CONSTRUCTION D'UNE
site de mise en décharge à
31997L0011,
DECHARGE A AMFISSA
Agrilioulia Amfissas
31999L0031
(département de Fokida)
en violation de la directive
99/31/CE et de la directive
85/337/CEE, telle que
modifiée par la directive
97/11/CE.
2005/408 ENVI/A/02 AT Austria
WASTE -
Claimed infringement of
None
31999L0031
Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
HAL
5-07-2005
Closing of the case
6
ALTLASTENBEITRAG
Directive 1999/31/EC
(TAXE SUR DECHETS
through inequal treatment
MIS EN DECHARGE)
of waste landfill operators
in comparison to waste
incinerator operators
Page 21 of 34
29-07-19
Landfill Directive 1999/31 - Bad application cases opened (157)
YR/N°
Unit
MS Member state
Title
Incriminated fact
Last step
Date
days
Legal base
Stage
Key words
DOP
Last
Last Commission
reached in the
ago
Commission decision Decision label
procedure
decision
Date
2005/415 ENVI/A/02 ES Spain
WASTE- DÉCHARGE
Décharge illegal (sans
None
31975L0442, Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
JMS
13-12-2005
Closing of the case
6
ILLEGALE À SANTA
autorisation) à Santa María
31991L0156,
MARÍA DEL PÁRAMO
del Páramo (province de
31999L0031
(LEÓN)
León) qui fonctionne
depuis mars 2001 comme
dépôt temporel de résidus
solides urbaines.
2005/427 ENVI/A/02 FR France
WASTE - INSTALLATIONS La plainte dénonce deux
None
31975L0442, Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
CLM
21-03-2007
Closing of the case
2
DE STOCKAGE DE
installations de stockage
31991L0689,
DECHETS DANGEREUX - de déchets dangereux sur
31996L0061,
METALEUROP
le site pollué de l'ancienne
31999L0031,
société Métaleurop,
32006L0012
autorisées par arrêté du
18.04.04, et dont la
construction a commencé
en mars 2005. La 1ère
installation de stockage
acueille les matériaux de
démolition du site pollués
au plomb, au zinc, à
l'arsenic et au cadmium. La
deuxième installation
acueille les plaques
contenant de l'amiante
après démontage des
toitures des bâtiments.
2005/433 ENVI/A/02 ES Spain
WASTE - DECHETS DANS Éventuelle mauvaise
None
31975L0442, Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
JMS
12-10-2006
Closing of the case
7
LE LIT DE LA
application des directives
31999L0031,
MAJILLONDA.
75/442 et 99/31 en relation
32006L0012
avec une décharge illégale
dans la municipalité de
Pradejón (LA Ríoja).
2005/435 ENVI/A/02 IE Ireland
WASTE - MISE EN
Alleged uncontrolled
None
31999L0031
Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
LCO
12-10-2005
Closing of the case
1
DECHARGE DES
disposal of waste tyres in
DECHETS
Ireland
2005/435 ENVI/A/02 IE Ireland
WASTE - MISE EN
Alleged uncontrolled
None
31999L0031
Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
LCO
12-10-2005
Closing of the case
2
DECHARGE DES
disposal of waste tyres in
DECHETS
Ireland
Page 22 of 34
29-07-19
Landfill Directive 1999/31 - Bad application cases opened (157)
YR/N°
Unit
MS Member state
Title
Incriminated fact
Last step
Date
days
Legal base
Stage
Key words
DOP
Last
Last Commission
reached in the
ago
Commission decision Decision label
procedure
decision
Date
2005/441 ENVI/A/02 IT Italy
NATURE - IMPACT -
It is claimed that several
None
31975L0442, Bad application - Directives ENV7 NATURE
LCI
4-04-2006
Closing of the case
2
WASTE - BAD PRACTICE decisions of the
31979L0409,
IN APPLYING EC ENV
"Commissario delegato
31985L0337,
LAW IN SICILY
all'emergenza rifiuti della
31992L0043,
Regione Sicilia" have
31994L0062,
breached Directives 75/442
31999L0031,
on waste, as modified,
32000L0076,
94/62 on packaging waste,
32003L0004
1999/31, on landfill
2000/76 on waste
incineration, 85/337 on
EIA, as modified, 2001/42
on strategic impact
assessment, 92/43 on
habitat conservation,
79/409 on wild birds
conservation, 2003/4 on
access to environmental
information.
2005/459 ENVI/A/02 ES Spain
WASTE - PROBLEMES
Décharge illégale dans la
None
31975L0442, Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
GNZ
5-06-2008
Closing of the case
0
ENVIRONNEMENTAUX
Serra Gelada, municipalité
31992L0043,
DANS LA SIERRA
de Benidorm (Alicante).
31999L0031,
HELADA DIR. 92/43
32006L0012
2005/461 ENVI/A/02 EL Greece
WASTE - ELIMINATION
Violation de l'article 4 et 8
None
31975L0442, Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
AMP
12-10-2005
Closing of the case
8
ILLEGALE DES DECHETS de la directive 75/442/CEE
31991L0689,
DANGEREUX A ELPE
relative aux déchets, telle
31999L0031
THESSALONIQUE
que modifiée par la
directive 91/156/CEE, en
combinaison avec l'article
1§2 de la directive
91/689/CEE relative aux
déchets dangereux, ainsi
que des art.3§1, 6-9, 13 et
14 de la directive 99/31/CE
sur la mise en décharge à
cause de l'élimination
inappropriée des déchets
dangereux de la raffinerie
d'ELPE à Thessalonique.
2005/474 ENVI/A/02 IE Ireland
WASTE - 1999/31/CE -
Delays in licensing a waste None
31994L0062, Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
LCO
4-04-2006
Closing of the case
5
2000/53/CE - 94/62/CE
facility proposed for Calf
31999L0031,
CALF FIELD
Field, Ballynadrumny,
32000L0053
County Kildare
Page 23 of 34
29-07-19
Landfill Directive 1999/31 - Bad application cases opened (157)
YR/N°
Unit
MS Member state
Title
Incriminated fact
Last step
Date
days
Legal base
Stage
Key words
DOP
Last
Last Commission
reached in the
ago
Commission decision Decision label
procedure
decision
Date
2005/480 ENVI/A/02 AT Austria
WASTE - DEPOT ILLEGAL Illegal landfill of waste in
None
31999L0031, Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
HAL
12-12-2006
Closing of the case
9
DE DECHETS HOLZGAU the Lech valley of the Tyrol
32006L0012
TIROL
might infringe Directives
75/442 and 1999/31
2005/486 ENVI/A/02 ES Spain
WASTE - LANDFILL IN
Possible bad application of None
31979L0409, Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
JMS
12-10-2006
Closing of the case
9
TOLEDO
severel Directives in
31985L0337,
relation with the project for
31990L0313,
a landfill in Toledo.
31992L0043,
31996L0061,
31997L0011,
31999L0031
2005/493 ENVI/A/02 PL Poland
WASTE - ILLEGAL
Functionning of an illegal
None
31975L0442, Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
KZL
17-10-2007
Closing of the case
7
LANDFILL IN GMINA
landfill in the commune of
31991L0689,
ZAKROCZYM
Zakroczym - bad
31999L0031,
application of provisions of
32006L0012
Directive 75/442/EEC on
waste, Directive
91/689/EEC on hazardous
waste and Directive
1999/31/EC on the landfill
of waste
2005/496 ENVI/A/02 AT Austria
WASTE - MISE EN
Illegal landfill of waste in
None
31975L0442, Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
HAL
4-04-2006
Cas traité sous
7
DECHARGE ILLEGALE
the Lech valley of the Tyrol
31999L0031
DANS LA VALLEE DE
might infringe Directives
LECH
75/442 and 1999/31
2006/223 ENVI/A/02 UK United
WASTE - BURIAL AND
Failure to correctly apply
None
31975L0442, Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
GRO
26-06-2008
Closing of the case
9
Kingdom
STORAGE OF ASBESTOS Council Directive
31985L0337,
WASTE - NORTHERN
1999/31/EC on the landfill
31999L0031,
IRELAND
of waste, Council Directive
32006L0012
85/337/EEC on the
assessment of the effects
of certain public and
private projects on the
environment (as amended
by Directive 97/11/EC), and
Council Directive
75/442/EEC on waste (as
amended by Directive
91/156/EEC and now
Directive 2006/12/EC).
2006/224 ENVI/A/02 UK United
WASTE - STORAGE OF
None
31975L0442, Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
WGR
28-06-2006
Closing of the case
7
Kingdom
ASBESTOS
31985L0337,
31999L0031,
32006L0012
Page 24 of 34
29-07-19
Landfill Directive 1999/31 - Bad application cases opened (157)
YR/N°
Unit
MS Member state
Title
Incriminated fact
Last step
Date
days
Legal base
Stage
Key words
DOP
Last
Last Commission
reached in the
ago
Commission decision Decision label
procedure
decision
Date
2006/464 ENVI/A/02 LT Lithuania
WASTE - POLLUTION IN
Illegal underground landfill None
31975L0442, Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
CLM
27-06-2007
Closing of the case
8
RADVILISKIS DISTRICT
of hazardous waste - bad
31991L0689,
application of Directive
31999L0031,
75/442/EEC on waste, as
32006L0012
amended, Directive
91/689/EEC on hazardous
waste and Directive
99/31/EC on the landfill of
waste.
2006/467 ENVI/A/02 DE Germany
WASTE - MISE EN
Illegal landfill of waste in
None
31999L0031, Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
HAL
27-06-2007
Closing of the case
9
DECHARGE ILLEGALE
the nature reserve
32006L0012
Trottheide in Brandenburg
might infringe Directives
2006/12and 1999/31
2006/482 ENVI/A/02 CY Cyprus
WASTE - PROBLEMES
Violation des articles 4, 8, Formal notice
########
4503
31999L0031, Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
AMP
17-10-2007
Closing of the case
3
POUR LA POPULATION
9 et 13 de la directive
Art. 258 TFEU
32006L0012
ET POUR
2006/12/CE, de l'article 14
L'ENVIRONNEMENT
a) et b) de la directive
PIGENIA
99/31/CE et de l'article 10
TCE, en raison de
l'élimination incontrôlée et
illégale des déchets aux
ruines du village Cypriot
turc d'Agios Theodoros.
2006/497 ENVI/A/01 ES Spain
WASTE - NON RESPECT Mauvaise application de la Referral to Court ########
3378
31999L0031
Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
JMS
30-09-2010
Withdrawal from the Court
8
OF DIRECTIVE
Directive 1999/31/CE
258(ex226) -
1999/31/CE IN COVA DA
relative à la mise en
Application
LOBA (O GROVE -
décharge des déchets
GALICIA) LANDFILL
2006/500 ENVI/A/02 IT Italy
WASTE - GL CARBON -
It is claimed that hazardous None
31991L0689, Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
MAG
21-03-2007
Cas traité sous
7
ASCOLI PICENO
waste have been
31999L0031,
discharged illegaly under
32006L0012
the industrial site SGL
Carbon of Ascoli Piceno
2007/238 ENVI/A/01 MT Malta
WASTE - DIRECTIVE
WASTE - Bad application - Reasoned
8-10-2009
3571
31999L0031
Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
CLM
5-05-2010
Closing of the case
8
99/31/EC ON THE
failure to provide national
opinion Art. 258
LANDFILL OF WASTE,
strategy for reduction of
TFEU
ART. 5 STRATEGY
biodegradable waste going
to landfills, in accordance
with Art 5 Landfill Directive
(Directive 1999/31/EC).
Page 25 of 34
29-07-19
Landfill Directive 1999/31 - Bad application cases opened (157)
YR/N°
Unit
MS Member state
Title
Incriminated fact
Last step
Date
days
Legal base
Stage
Key words
DOP
Last
Last Commission
reached in the
ago
Commission decision Decision label
procedure
decision
Date
2007/239 ENVI/A/01 SK Slovakia
WASTE - DIRECTIVE
Slovakia has not presented Referral to Court ########
3348
31999L0031
Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
OBR
6-04-2011
Withdrawal from the Court
0
99/31/EC ON THE
to the Commission a
258(ex226) -
LANDFILL OF WASTE,
national strategy for the
Application
ART. 5 STRATEGY
implementation of the
reduction of biodegradable
waste going to landfills.
2007/443 ENVI/A/02 UK United
WASTE - LONDON
Failure to correctly apply
None
31999L0031
Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
GRO
14-05-2009
Closing of the case
3
Kingdom
MUNICIPAL WASTE
the requirements of
Council Directive
1999/31/EC on the landfill
of waste
2007/453 ENVI/A/02 EL Greece
WASTE - OPERATION OF Mauvais fonctionnement
Additional formal ########
3186
31999L0031, Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
CNN
16-06-2011
Closing of the case
4
THE LANDFILL AT
d'une nouvelle décharge à notice Art. 258
32006L0012
SKALISTIRI
Fyli contrairement aux
TFEU
dispositions des directives
2006/12/CE et 99/31/CE.
2007/455 ENVI/A/02 EL Greece
WASTE -
Mauvais fonctionnement
None
31999L0031, Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
AMP
5-06-2008
Closing of the case
2
FONCTIONNEMENT
d'une nouvelle décharge à
32006L0012
DECHARGE
Messolongi au site d'Agios
MESSOLONGI
Thomas contraire aux
dispositions des directives
2006/12/CE et 99/31/CE.
2007/459 ENVI/A/02 IE Ireland
WASTE - NUISANCES
Failure of Irish authorities
None
31999L0031, Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
LCO
11-12-2007
Closing of the case
4
OLFACTIVES A CAUSE
to control odours from a
32006L0012
D'UNE DECHARGE A
local authority landfill
CIEL OUVERT
situated at Corranure,
County Cavan
2007/489 ENVI/A/02 SI Slovenia
WASTE - WASTE
Possible breaches of
None
31992L0043, Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
DSG
19-02-2009
Closing of the case
2
LANDFILL IN TENETISE,
provisions of Directives
31999L0031,
SLOVENIA
2006/12/EC, 1999/31/EC
32006L0012
and 92/43/EEC in relation
to the operation of the
landfill site at Tenetise,
Slovenia
2007/490 ENVI/A/02 SI Slovenia
WASTE - ILLEGAL
Possible infringements of
None
31999L0031, Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
DSG
27-11-2008
Closing of the case
6
WASTE LANDFILL AT
Directives 2006/12/EC on
32006L0012
RAKOVNIK, ŠMARTNO
waste and 1999/31/EC on
PRI LITIJI
the landfill of waste in
relation to the Rakovnik
landfill
Page 26 of 34
29-07-19
Landfill Directive 1999/31 - Bad application cases opened (157)
YR/N°
Unit
MS Member state
Title
Incriminated fact
Last step
Date
days
Legal base
Stage
Key words
DOP
Last
Last Commission
reached in the
ago
Commission decision Decision label
procedure
decision
Date
2007/493 ENVI/A/02 UK United
WASTE - GYPSUM
Bad application of Article
None
31999L0031, Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
WGR
24-11-2010
Closing of the case
4
Kingdom
RECYCLING
16 of Directive 1999/31/EC
32003D0033
of 26 April 1999 on the
landfill of waste in relation
to the criteria for the
acceptance of gypsum
waste at landfills (in
accordance with Council
Decision 2003/33)
2007/494 ENVI/A/01 IT Italy
WASTE - LANDFILL IN
It is alleged that a closed
None
31999L0031, Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
TBL
26-04-2012
Closing of the case
2
PARCO SAN GIULIANO
landfill has been reclaimed
32006L0012
without ensuring that no
harm to human health is
caused by the waste
disposed of therein.
2007/495 ENVI/E/01 SI Slovenia
WASTE - LANDFILLS IN
Outstanding IPPC permit
None
31992L0043, Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
DSG
19-02-2009
Cas traité sous
3
THE VOLCEKE
for the operation of the
31996L0061,
PROTECTED AREA
Cinkarna Celje, the zinc
31999L0031,
factory managing also two
32006L0012
landfills for TiO2, and an
outstanding IPPC permit
for the operation of the
CERO landfill for
communal waste
2008/214 ENVI/A/02 BG Bulgaria
WASTE - BAD
Illegal storage of
None
31999L0031, Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
ARK
9-02-2012
Cas traité sous
8
APPLICATION OF
household waste (long-
32006L0012
DIRECTIVE 2006/12/EC
term storage of more than
ON WASTE
500 000 tonnes of baled
household waste)
2008/231 ENVI/A/02 ES Spain
WASTE - JUAN GRANDE Operation of the Juan
None
31999L0031, Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
JMS
29-01-2009
Cas traité sous
1
LANDFILL
Grande Waste tip in breach
32008L0001
of the requirements set up
by the Landfill Directive
1999/31/EC and the IPPC
Directive 2008/1/EC.
Page 27 of 34
29-07-19
Landfill Directive 1999/31 - Bad application cases opened (157)
YR/N°
Unit
MS Member state
Title
Incriminated fact
Last step
Date
days
Legal base
Stage
Key words
DOP
Last
Last Commission
reached in the
ago
Commission decision Decision label
procedure
decision
Date
2008/415 ENVI/E/03 SK Slovakia
WASTE - WASTE
Non-compliance with the
Referral to Court 4-07-2018
380
12008E260§2 Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
ACM
16-06-2016
Referral to Court Art. 260
0
LANDFILL IN POVAZSKY CJEU ruling of 25 April
260(ex228) -
,31999L0031
TFEU
CHLMEC, ZILINA
2013 in Case C-331/11,
Judgment
where the Court of Justice
declared that by
authorising the operation of
the Žilina-Považský
Chlmec waste site without
a site conditioning plan and
in the absence of a final
decision on the continued
operation on the basis of
an approved site
conditioning plan, the
Slovak Republic had failed
to comply with its
obligations under Article
14(a) to (c) of the Landfill
Directive.
2008/422 ENVI/A/02 EL Greece
IMPACT - Décharge
Projet de décharge à
None
31975L0442, Bad application - Directives ENV1 IMPACT
AMP
5-06-2008
Closing of the case
2
Grammatiko
Mavro Vouno Grammatiko
31980L0068,
31985L0337,
31999L0031,
32006L0012
2008/462 ENVI/A/01 IT Italy
WASTE - LANDFILL IN
Alleged breach of Directive None
31992L0043, Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
LGR
29-09-2011
Closing of the case
8
SIC IT5210012 BOSCHI DI 92/43/EC (Habitats) and of
31999L0031
MONTELOVESCO,
Directive 99/31/EC (Landfill
UMBRIA
of waste) within a SIC site
in Umbria
2008/467 ENVI/A/02 RO Romania
WASTE - NON-
NON-CONFORMITY OF
None
31999L0031
Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
MRN
29-10-2009
Closing of the case
0
CONFORMITY OF
LANDFILL SITUATED IN
LANDFILL SITUATED IN
SINTESTI-VIDRA,
SINTESTI-VIDRA,
BUCHAREST, WITH
BUCHAREST, WITH
DIRECTIVE 1999/31/EC
DIRECTIVE 1999/31/EC
Page 28 of 34
29-07-19
Landfill Directive 1999/31 - Bad application cases opened (157)
YR/N°
Unit
MS Member state
Title
Incriminated fact
Last step
Date
days
Legal base
Stage
Key words
DOP
Last
Last Commission
reached in the
ago
Commission decision Decision label
procedure
decision
Date
2009/205 ENVI/A/02 MT Malta
WASTE - NON-
Non-communication of
Formal notice
########
3748
31975L0439, Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
CLM
8-10-2009
Closing of the case
2
COMMUNICATION OF
reports for the three-year
Art. 258 TFEU
31986L0278,
THREE-YEAR REPORTS period from 2004 to 2006
31994L0062,
2004-2006 OF
as requested by the
31999L0031,
DIRECTIVES 75/439/EEC, provisions of the Article 18
32002L0096,
86/278/EEC,
of Directive 75/439/EEC,
32006L0012
94/62/EC,1999/31/EC,
the Article 17 of Directive
2002/96/EC, 2006/12/EC
86/278/EEC, the Article 17
of Directive 94/62/EC, the
Article 15 of Directive
1999/31/EC, the Article 12
of Directive 2002/96/EC
and the Article 16 of
Directive 2006/12/EC.
2009/205 ENVI/A/02 DK Denmark
WASTE - NON-
Non-communication of
Formal notice
########
3718
31999L0031
Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
AIS
8-10-2009
Closing of the case
4
COMMUNICATION OF
three-year report 2004-
Art. 258 TFEU
THREE-YEAR REPORTS 2006 under Directive
2004-2006 OF
1999/31
DIRECTIVES 91/689/EEC
AND 1999/31/EC
2009/234 ENVI/E/03 EL Greece
WASTE -
Non-exécution de l'arrêt C- Formal notice
########
813
12008E260§2 Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
CNN
27-04-2017
Formal notice Art. 260
0
FONCTIONNEMENT DE
600/12 du 17/07/2014
Art. 260 TFEU
,31992L0043,
TFEU
LA DECHARGE A
portant sur la violation des
31999L0031,
ZAKYNTHOS (GRECE)
articles 13 et 36,
32008L0098
paragraphe 1, de la
directive 2008/98/CE
relative aux déchets, des
articles 8, 9, 11,
paragraphe 1, sous a), 12
et 14 de la directive
1999/31/CE du Conseil, du
26 avril 1999, concernant
la mise en décharge des
déchets et de l’article 6,
paragraphe 3, de la
directive 92/43/CEE du
Conseil, du 21 mai 1992,
concernant la conservation
des habitats naturels ainsi
que de la faune et de la
flore sauvages en raison
du fonctionnement non
conforme de la décharge
Page 29 of 34
29-07-19
Landfill Directive 1999/31 - Bad application cases opened (157)
YR/N°
Unit
MS Member state
Title
Incriminated fact
Last step
Date
days
Legal base
Stage
Key words
DOP
Last
Last Commission
reached in the
ago
Commission decision Decision label
procedure
decision
Date
2009/430 ENVI/A/02 EL Greece
WASTE - DECHARGES
Décharges illegales a
None
31985L0337, Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
CNN
30-09-2010
Closing of the case
6
SANITAIRES A
Karvounari (departement
31997L0011,
KARVOUNARI +
de Thesprotie) et Lefkimmi
31999L0031
LEFKIMMI
(departement de Corfou)
en violation de la directive
99/31/CE et de la directive
85/337/CEE telle que
modifiée par la directive
97/11/CE
2009/442 ENVI/A/02 DE Germany
WASTE - DISPOSAL OF
DISPOSAL OF
Formal notice
8-10-2009
3571
31999L0031
Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
KRM
26-01-2012
Closing of the case
2
HAZARDOUS WASTE ON HAZARDOUS WASTE ON Art. 258 TFEU
LANDFILL FOR NON-
LANDFILL FOR NON-
HAZARDOUS WASTE
HAZARDOUS WASTE,
breach of Art. 6(a), 6(c)(iii)
Dir. 1999/31/EC and para
3.2 2nd indent and para
2.3.2 Decision 2003/33/EC
2009/442 ENVI/E/02 IT Italy
IMPACT -
Breach of directive
Additional
########
1576
31985L0337, Bad application - Directives ENV1 IMPACT,ENV9
TIC
26-03-2015
Additional reasoned
6
REHABILITATION OF A
2011/92/EU on EIA and of reasoned
31997L0011,
WASTE
opinion Art. 258 TFEU
FORMER CHEMICAL SITE directive 99/31/EC on the
opinion Art. 258
31999L0031,
EX ACNA IN CENGIO
landfill of waste in relation TFEU
32011L0092
(LIGURIA REGION)
with a project of
rehabilitation of a former
industrial site in the Liguria
region.
2010/204 ENVI/E/03 EL Greece
WASTE – LACK OF
Non exécution de l’arrêt du Referral to Court ########
813
12008E260,3 Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
CNN
10-12-2015
Referral to Court Art. 258
8
APPROPRIATE
27/04/2017 (C-202/16)
258(ex226) -
1999L0031,3
TFEU
MANAGEMENT OF THE
portant sur la violation de Judgment
2008L0098
TEMPLONI LANDFILL
l’article 13 de la directive
2008/98/CE du Parlement
européen et du Conseil, du
19 novembre 2008, relative
aux déchets et abrogeant
certaines directives, ainsi
que de l’article 8, sous a),
de l’article 11, paragraphe
1, et de l’annexe I de la
directive 1999/31/CE du
Conseil, du 26 avril 1999,
concernant la mise en
décharge des déchets en
raison du fonctionnement
non conforme de la
décharge
Page 30 of 34
29-07-19
Landfill Directive 1999/31 - Bad application cases opened (157)
YR/N°
Unit
MS Member state
Title
Incriminated fact
Last step
Date
days
Legal base
Stage
Key words
DOP
Last
Last Commission
reached in the
ago
Commission decision Decision label
procedure
decision
Date
2010/418 ENVI/A/02 EL Greece
WASTE - DECHARGE DE Fonctionnement de la
Formal notice
########
3159
31999L0031, Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
CNN
27-02-2012
Closing of the case
9
KORYTIANI
décharge sans autorisation Art. 258 TFEU
32008L0098
et de manière
problématique. Violation de
la legislation dechets
(2008/98 et 99/31)
2011/200 ENVI/E/03 CY Cyprus
WASTE – DECHARGES
Non-execution of the ruling Formal notice
########
813
12008E260§2 Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
CNN
27-04-2017
Formal notice Art. 260
5
ILLEGALES
of the Court of 18.07.2013 Art. 260 TFEU
,31999L0031
TFEU
in case C-412/12, which
stated that "En ne
procédant pas à la
désaffectation de toutes les
décharges d’élimination
incontrôlée des déchets
(XADA) qui sont exploitées
sur son territoire ou en ne
se conformant pas aux
exigences de la directive
1999/31/CE du Conseil, du
26 avril 1999, concernant
la mise en décharge des
déchets, la République de
Chypre a manqué aux
obligations qui lui
incombent en vertu de
l’article 14 de cette
directive."
2011/203 ENVI/E/02 PT Portugal
WASTE - Implementation
Bad application of Council Reasoned
########
1975
31999L0031
Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
SOA
17-11-2016
Closing of the case
1
of Council Directive
Directive 1999/31/EC of 26 opinion Art. 258
1999/31/EC of 26 April
April 1999 on the landfill of TFEU
1999 on the landfill of
Waste in Portugal
Waste in Portugal
2011/206 ENVI/A/02 LV Latvia
WASTE - Implementation
Implementation of Council Formal notice
########
2955
31999L0031
Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
AIS
29-09-2011
Closing of the case
9
of Council Directive
Directive 1999/31/EC of 26 Art. 258 TFEU
1999/31/EC of 26 April
April 1999 on the landfill of
1999 on the landfill of
Waste in Latvia
Waste in Latvia
2011/207 ENVI/E/02 ES Spain
WASTE - Breach of Article Implementation of the
Formal notice
8-12-2016
953
12008E260§2 Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
JMS
8-12-2016
Formal notice Art. 260
1
14 of Landfill Directive
EUCJ ruling of 25.02.2016 Art. 260 TFEU
,31999L0031
TFEU
1999/31/EC
in Case C-454/14 -
substandard landfills
(Article 14 of the Landfill
Directive).
Page 31 of 34
29-07-19
Landfill Directive 1999/31 - Bad application cases opened (157)
YR/N°
Unit
MS Member state
Title
Incriminated fact
Last step
Date
days
Legal base
Stage
Key words
DOP
Last
Last Commission
reached in the
ago
Commission decision Decision label
procedure
decision
Date
2011/208 ENVI/E/03 EL Greece
WASTE –
Non exécution de l’arrêt C- Formal notice
########
813
12008E260§2 Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
CNN
27-04-2017
Formal notice Art. 260
2
FONCTIONNEMENT DE
677/13 du 11/12/2014
Art. 260 TFEU
,31999L0031,
TFEU
LA DECHARGE DE
portant sur la violation des
32008L0098
KIATO
articles 13 et 36(1) de la
directive 2008/98/CE
relative aux déchets et des
articles 8,9,11(1)(a) et 12
de la directive 99/31/CE
sur les décharges.
2011/218 ENVI/E/01 SI Slovenia
WASTE: Implementation of Bad application regarding
Referral to Court ########
233
12008E260§2 Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
RLO
13-07-2017
Referral to Court Art. 258
6
Article 14 of the Landfill
Article 14 of Council
258(ex226) -
,31999L0031
TFEU
Directive in Slovenia
Directive 1999/31/EC of 26 Judgment
April 1999 on the landfill of
waste due to the
continuous existance of
non-compliant landfills in
Slovenia - Article 260,
compliance with judgment
C-506/17.
2011/221 ENVI/E/02 IT Italy
WASTE - Breach of Art.14 Bad application of Art. 14
Referral to Court ########
120
31999L0031
Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
TIC
17-05-2017
Referral to Court Art. 258
5
of Directive 1999/31/EC on of Directive 99/31/EC on
258(ex226) -
TFEU
the landfill of waste in Italy the landfill of waste in Italy
Judgment
2011/402 ENVI/E/02 IT Italy
WASTE - Breach of Article Breach of Directive
Referral to Court ########
1738
12008E260§2 Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
TIC
8-12-2016
Closing of the case
1
6(a) of Landfill Directive
1999/31/EC on the landfill 258(ex226) -
,31999L0031,
1999/31 in Lazio
of waste and of Directive
Judgment
32008L0098
(Malagrotta)
2008/98/EC on waste in
the Lazio Region
2012/200 ENVI/E/01 RO Romania
WASTE - Council Directive Bad application of Article
Referral to Court ########
274
12008E260§2 Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
EOB
15-02-2017
Referral to Court Art. 258
7
1999/31/EC of 26 April
14 and Article 13 of the
258(ex226) -
,31999L0031
TFEU
1999 on the landfill of
Council Directive
Judgment
waste
1999/31/EC of 26 April
1999 on the landfill of
waste
2012/205 ENVI/A/02 UK United
WASTE - Breach of Art.14 Bad application of Art. 14
Formal notice
########
2640
31999L0031
Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
GRO
21-11-2012
Closing of the case
8
Kingdom
of Directive 1999/31/EC on of Directive 99/31/EC on
Art. 258 TFEU
the landfill of waste in UK
the landfill of waste in UK
Page 32 of 34
29-07-19
Landfill Directive 1999/31 - Bad application cases opened (157)
YR/N°
Unit
MS Member state
Title
Incriminated fact
Last step
Date
days
Legal base
Stage
Key words
DOP
Last
Last Commission
reached in the
ago
Commission decision Decision label
procedure
decision
Date
2012/208 ENVI/E/01 BG Bulgaria
WASTE – Breach of Article Execution of the Court
Referral to Court ########
1464
12008E260§2 Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
ARK
23-01-2014
Referral to Court Art. 258
2
14 of Directive 1999/31/EC ruling of16/07/2015
258(ex226) -
,31999L0031
TFEU
on the landfill of waste in
according to whcich "by not Judgment
Bulgaria
having taken the necessary
measures to ensure that
from 16 July 2009 existing
landfills for non-hazardous
waste in its territory shall
only continue to operate if
they comply with the
requirements of Council
Directive 1999/31/EC of 26
April 1999 on the landfill of
waste, the Republic of
Bulgaria has failed to fulfil
its obligations under Article
14, (a) to (c) of that
Directive"
2012/220 ENVI/D/03 EL Greece
WASTE- Eventuelle
Fonctionnement non
Formal notice
########
2367
31999L0031, Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
CNN
18-06-2015
Closing of the case
8
violation des Dir. 99/31 et
conforme de la decharge
Art. 258 TFEU
32008L0098
2008/98 en raison du
avec la legislation de l'UE
fonctionnement
sur les dechets
problématique de la
décharge de Karvounari
(Thesprotie)
2012/406 ENVI/D/02 ES Spain
WASTE - discharge in
Operation by the
Reasoned
########
2276
31999L0031, Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
JMS
20-02-2014
Cas traité sous
8
Barranco de Sedases
municipality of Fraga
opinion Art. 258
32008L0098
(Fraga, Huesca-Aragón)
(Huesca-Aragón) of a
TFEU
waste discharge without a
valid permit.
2012/413 ENVI/E/01 SI Slovenia
WASTE - Inappropriate
Execution of the Court
Referral to Court 6-04-2017
834
12008E260§2 Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
RLO
25-02-2016
Referral to Court Art. 258
6
treatment of waste tyres in ruling C-153/16 of 7 April
258(ex226) -
,31999L0031,
TFEU
Lovrenc na Dravskem polju 2017 in relation to
Judgment
32008L0098
inappropriate treatment
and landfilling of waste
tyres in Lovrenc na
Dravskem polju (Slovenia)
2012/415 ENVI/E/01 SI Slovenia
WASTE - illegal landfills in Execution of the Court
Formal notice
7-06-2018
407
12008E260§2 Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
RLO
7-06-2018
Formal notice Art. 260
0
the area of Celje and
ruling C-104/14 of 16 July
Art. 260 TFEU
,31999L0031,
TFEU
inappropriate waste
2015 in relation to two
32008L0098
treatment linked to the
illegal landfills in Celje
brownfield "old
Cinkarna Celje"
Page 33 of 34
29-07-19
Landfill Directive 1999/31 - Bad application cases opened (157)
YR/N°
Unit
MS Member state
Title
Incriminated fact
Last step
Date
days
Legal base
Stage
Key words
DOP
Last
Last Commission
reached in the
ago
Commission decision Decision label
procedure
decision
Date
2013/205 ENVI/D/03 EL Greece
WASTE - Fonctionnement Violation des
Formal notice
########
2241
31999L0031, Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
CNN
28-04-2016
Closing of the case
2
de la decharge de
directives1999/31/CE du
Art. 258 TFEU
32008L0098
Mesolonghi
Conseil du 26 avril 1999
concernant la mise en
décharge des déchets et
2008/98/CE du Parlement
européen et du Conseil du
19 novembre 2008 relative
aux déchets en raison du
fonctionnement
problématique de la
décharge de Mesolonghi
2014/220 ENVI/D/03 EL Greece
ERREUR DOUBLE
Non conform functioning of None
31999L0031, Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
CNN
4
ENCODAGE - Voir fiche
the waste facility on the
32008L0098
2014/2207 - WASTE - Non island of Mykonos
compliant functioning of
Mykonos landfill and of
garbage collection system
on the island (Directives
2008/98 and 99/31)
2014/220 ENVI/E/03 EL Greece
WASTE - Non conform
Fonctionnement non
Formal notice
########
1758
31999L0031, Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
CNN
25-09-2014
Formal notice Art. 258
7
functioning of the waste
conforme de la décharge
Art. 258 TFEU
32008L0098
TFEU
facility on the island of
sur l'ile de Mykonos en
Mykonos (Directives
violation des obligations
2008/98 and 99/31)
des directives 99/31/CE
sur les décharges et
2008/98/CE sur la gestion
des déchets.
2017/203 ENVI/E/03 SK Slovakia
WASTE- Implementation
Bad application of Article
Reasoned
7-03-2019
134
31999L0031
Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
ACM
7-03-2019
Reasoned opinion Art. 258
5
of Article 14 of the Landfill 14 of Council Directive
opinion Art. 258
TFEU
Directive in Slovakia
1999/31/EC of 26 April
TFEU
1999 on the landfill of
waste as a result of
continuous existance of
non-compliant landfills in
Slovakia
2019/201 ENVI/E/01 PL Poland
WASTE- Implementation of Bad application of Article
Formal notice
7-03-2019
134
31999L0031
Bad application - Directives ENV9 WASTE
AJN
7-03-2019
Formal notice Art. 258
3
Article 14 of the Landfill
14(b) and (c) in conjunction Art. 258 TFEU
TFEU
Directive in Poland
with Article 13 of Council
Directive 1999/31/EC of 26
April 1999 on the landfill of
waste related to the
existence of non-compliant
landfills in Poland
Page 34 of 34